Advice for Severe Pruning (Apple / Plum)

13 years ago

This past summer, I moved into a house that has about a dozen fruit trees in the yard. It's obvious that they've all been neglected for years. Many were planted 10 feet apart but are now 20 feet high, so you can imagine how fiercely their branches invade the space of proximal trees. It seems every tree (except the plums) are producing loads of fruit, although 90% of the fruit is either infected or too high to reach without a bucket-truck.

I'm a newbie in tree-care, and I'm researching pruning methods to prepare for this winter. So far, what I've read about pruning presumes that the trees have been somewhat attended in recent years.

Can I cut a central leader if the diameter is 5 inches, without devastating the tree? I imagine these trees in the size and shape that I'd like them to be, which is quite disproportionate to what I imagine their root system must look like. Is it hopeless for these trees?

Does anyone have any experience, guidance, advice or reading referrals for severe pruning methods?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (3)

alan haigh
13 years ago
Apples survive a tremendous amount of wood removal if they're healthy to begin with- plums not so much. I've lost track of how many old neglected apple trees I've remodeled but when I started doing this professionally I read Hall-Bayer's "Ecological Fruit Production in the North" which has a very easy to understand chapter on getting overgrown apple trees back into production.

After spending half my work days pruning mostly apple trees for the last 20 years I've developed my own systems, of course, but a lot of the trees I face could be quite adequately managed using the photos and explanations in this book.

If the plums are Japanese you can go after them more aggressively then Europeans.

Yes, you can usually get away with removing the largest scaffolds on any healthy tree, depending, I guess, on local insect and disease pressure. Here in southeastern NY I don't believe I've ever had trees die from wounds I've inflicted on them and I remove whatever I have to to bring trees down in height. I just don't do it all at once.
calistoga_al ca 15 usda 9
13 years ago
Making the cut as you describe if done the normal dormant pruning time will very likely cause several rapidly growing water sprouts around the edge of the cut. Drastic pruning to reduce the tree size, besides being done a few cuts a year, would better be done in the summer which is much less likely to cause a flush of water sprouts. Al
Related Discussions
New Home Owner: Mature Apple & Plum Tree advice
Q
Comments (3)
I would skip pruning this year and take a year learning from this forum. Pruning is far more then cutting some branches. you have to learn the hows and whys. you may discover the previous owner was not very good at it and you have things to fix. But you need to have your mind around it first. Furthermore what is right for me may be all wrong for the next guy. For example I didn't think picking apples from a ladder was that big of a deal.. until I had to to pick a whole lot of them. I prune to keep my fruit as low as possible, but my friend in the country cannot do it that way
...See More
Young apple trees - spray, prune - what to do?
Q
Comments (4)
Hi Jiver! I live north of Detroit and also have a HoneyCrisp. This is its fourth year of life. The first year that it fruited we had about five gorgeous and tasty apples (that is all it gave us). Last year it was full of apples, but it was also full of every pest and fungus known to Michigan apples (Cedar Apple Rust, flyspeck, Plum Leaf Curculio, apple maggot, web worms, leaf roller, and more)! I was a newbie and had no clue how to prepare for it or what to do about it. This year I have read up and am hoping for better success. I want to avoid chemicals so am climbing uphill. I would love to keep up with you as we both attempt to keep our apples healthy to harvest so maybe we can learn from each other. I cleaned up every leaf and dropped apple, threw away all the bad apples from the tree, and carefully inspected the tree (often) for signs of bad leaves or bugs (which I pinched off upon discovery). I semi-thinned (left two or three on each bunch) my apples out a few weeks ago but hadn't yet learned about bagging. I sprayed it with copper soap and a soap spray distributed by Gardens Alive to control fungus. This method requires reapplication every 7 days AND after every rain. This is high-maintenance but not a big deal when you only have one tree. I just bagged my tree this week and noticed as I was out there that several of the baby apples had bug bites already. I am afraid this means they've been parasitized, so I clipped them off and threw them away. I thinned to only one or two apples on a bunch and bagged all that looked healthy. I hated to clip off all those with bug bites, but I should still have over 100 large apples to harvest. I think next year I will be sure to bag it the week BEFORE Memorial Day since this week (the week following Memorial Day) there was a fairly high incidence of insect activity. I look forward to hearing of your success.
...See More
Good Plums this year, still waiting on apples
Q
Comments (5)
Alderman vs Superior? No comparison whatsoever. I'm positive I have Superior (weeping branches/fruit looks similar to what I've seen from others), but maybe my Alderman is not what its suppose to be. Both were ordered from Gurney's a long time ago. My Alderman is always later then Superior. The fruit is darker and doesn't crack as bad as Superior. Taste? Garbage.
...See More
Several Apple Planting Questions
Q
Comments (28)
Bob, I have many zig-zag plantings, you and I are thinking alike! In fact the majority of my trees are in this form. The idea has also been around for some time, I found some Italian researchers exploring this idea in the 1970's, they called it a "double row". My double rows I did more narrowly than yours; I have apples with only 1.5' diagonal, and my pears and Euro plums have a ~2.75' diagonal. These double row spacings have not been a big success, and its one reason why I was above complaining about problems with Euro plums and pears (the apples actually worked out OK, they fruited well, but they are still too much hassle to prune). I didn't mention the fact that they were double rows above, but I think that made the close spacing problem even worse for my problematic Euro plums and pears. Your double-rows are a lot wider than I made mine, with 4' between the zig and the zag. That may make things work for you, not sure. The one case where I feel a double row has so far worked well is in a peach/plum planting I did a few years ago, I did them at about 5' horizontal spacing and about 4' vertical. So, given how peaches are a bit more vigorous than a dwarf apple I could see 4' working for you. Your pears are only two and have more space on all the other sides so 4' would not be as big a deal for those two; if you had a long row of pears I would make the zig/zag width be 5' or 6' minimum. Overall I'm not sure how much help if any the zig/zag is over just putting the trees in a straight line at the same net spacing (i.e. putting your apples in a line at 3'), but its worth experimenting with. Scott
...See More
alan haigh
13 years ago
The difference in season is not important as far as water sprouts- they're easy to remove. I prune winter, spring and summer and watersprouts are the least concern when you're dealing with an out of control apple tree.

The best thing would be to get started as soon as possible than come back mid to late summer and do some more. It's always good to mop out water sprouts when renovating to get the light where you need it but waiting until summer to get started would be a waste of time IMO.

I actually believe that the safest time to remove largest scaffolds is late summer because the sun is weakening and sun scald seems less likely from my frequent observation. By the time strong sun returns the following spring the apple has already generated enough active new leaf bud to assure adequate transpiration to cool cambium.

Summer pruning does not stop plenty of new water sprouts in the spring and only reduces vigor over time.

Advice for Severe Pruning (Apple / Plum)

Comments (3)

alan haigh

calistoga_al ca 15 usda 9

Related Discussions

alan haigh

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US