I have a Scotts Classic that I really like. It was roughly 130 dollars at Home Depot. Cuts 20 inches wide, and up to 3 inches tall.

You didn't mention what kind of turf you are cutting or how low you wish to go. The Brill is an excellent machine and can go down to .5". It is expensive, but YGWYPF.
I use it on my Bermuda lawn.

I would not recomend the Hoosier manufacturing one I got a Home Depot a few years ago can mow anything over 3"!

The average residential lot. Were not golfing on these greens. We actually don't mind the grass to be a bit longer than usual. Can't stand short grass that gets burnt. I have heard that some have had issues with certain brands regarding the handle(s) "Y" or "bar" not being as sturdy as it should? What's the difference between the 2 wheeled and 4 wheeled models?

The 4 wheel model simply uses a set of wheels in the back instead of a roller. So far, my Scotts has had no issues, I've been using it about 3 months now. I'm cutting St. Augustine and Centipede grass with mine, does a nice job, especially since I'm not having to buy 4 buck a gallon gas for a lawn mower. It is a good idea to spray a light oil on the reel after mowing, keeps it lubed up and ready for the next cutting. I use a silicon spray that works really good. The biggest thing is, you have to cut often. If your grass gets tall, you are going to catch he!! getting it cut like you want it. I made that mistake once, and had to use the gas mower.

We just purchased a reel mower from Lee Valley about three weeks ago. We have about 1/4 acre of lawn surrounding our property and so far have used it twice and are very happy with the product. We have the 20" and find that it now takes much less time to mow than it did with our gas mower. Also, we feel great in that our daughter (13) can help since there's no 'starting' the mower, or blades going a million miles a minute. She actually enjoys using it. :O)

We raise butterflies and this was a responsible way to go. The height is set at 2.5 inches, but we may decide to go higher when the heat of the summer hits.

It was raining most of last week so the mowing didn't get done until today. The lawn was a bit high and is really thick, but DH said it cut a smooth as a hot knife in butter. I tried it and know he was right.

Lee Valley also features seminars in the summer on how to care for your reel mower. I like that... DH is not the most mechanically inclined. :O) We are already signed-up!

Here is a link that might be useful: Reel Mower - Lee Valley

Has anyone tried the Sunlawn LMM-35 Manual Reel Mower? I like that it doesn't need to be sharpened, and that it's relatively light. But is it worth spending $155.00?

We have a small lawn, and the electric mower I inherited has fallen apart. Not worth spending the money to fix it, when I can provide my own power.

Thanks for your input.
Judye