Yet another book related question

2 months ago

A respected author writes a highly successful novel set in the present day, featuring ordinary people living plausible lives with no sci-fi, speculative, or contrived elements. Let's say it's a suspense story. The book tops bestseller lists for months and is later adapted into a critically acclaimed, box-office hit film.

You can only "do" one, see the movie or read the book. Not both.

I'd choose the book every time. A well-received novel by a recognized author is enough to interest me on its own. I rarely discuss books with friends, so I don't read them in time to join anticipated conversations simply because it's a topical subject. Heavy media attention tends to make me less interested rather than more. My reading choices are generally driven by personal preference, not popularity or trends.

By necessity, movies based on a book need to extract story elements and leave things out because of limited space within the time constraints of a feature film.

How about you, which would you be more likely to choose?

Featured Answer

KW PNW Z8

2 months ago

last modified: 2 months ago

If I could do only one, hands down it’s the book. My imagination and the finite details in the written story cannot be matched by any movie version. Having answered the question asked, I’ll add that often my having read the book determines whether or not I’ll also see a movie made of it. An older example of that is ”The Help” by Kathryn Stockett. I both listened to the audio book & then read the book before I saw the movie. In this particular movie, the actors were able to add detail and flavor that my imagination couldn’t ’see’ because I’ve never lived in the deep south.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (16)

LoneJack Zn 6a, KC
2 months ago
neither
Elmer J Fudd thanked LoneJack Zn 6a, KC
Offie Myffy
2 months ago
The book.

Based on personal experience with having read books then seen the movie, only one film adaptation was (in my opinion) better than the book: Christine by Stephen King.
Elmer J Fudd thanked Offie Myffy
Related Discussions
yet another mulch question
Q
Comments (10)
There are many great discussions on mulches to use in the vegetable garden over on the Soil, Compost & Mulch forum you might want to check out. And I linked a recent one on favorite muches below for you too. There is nothing wrong with the Garden Guardian stuff, it's just fir bark and corn gluten meal and gives the added bonus of weed control. But it is awfully expensive! Straw or hay either one would be a lot cheaper. Nothing wrong with using grass clippings either - especially if you compost them some first - but it is hard to get enough. Some use hedge and brush clippings along with grass to get it thicker. I prefer hay - but then I have tons of it to use. Straw too is excellent and both will also improve the soil for the next year - and cheaper than the store bought stuff. I don't care for bark as it takes too long to break down, doesn't do much for the soil for quite some time, and jams the tiller. ;) Shredded paper works great when wet it stays in place but doesn't look all that great but you can top it with anything. The important point is just to mulch. ;) Dave Here is a link that might be useful: Favorite mulches discussion
...See More
Another set of pruning-related questions
Q
Comments (14)
Hi Anthony - I'm glad to hear that so many of them survived. I know you were worried there for a bit that you'd have few viable plants this year. Guess they are tougher then we give them credit for, tight? ;) Cagers often say that they don't prune and they get lots of production. QUESTION: Does this have many fruits ripening at the same time, are the fruits smaller that typical fruits for the variety? More pounds of smaller tomatoes is not something that I want. Hope it's alright if I restrict myself to just this part. As you probably know, I'm a cager and don't prune. But this year I also set up a Florida weave row to try and for comparison. Same varieties in each - Stupice, Bloody Butcher, Brandy Boy, Opalka, Black Cherry, Tappy's Heritage, Super Marmande, Marianna's Peace, and Sweet Cluster. We are eating the Stupice, B. Butcher and a couple of S. Cluster so far. I pruned all of them up to the first fruit cluster and then stopped on the caged ones but pruned the FW row to 3 stems each. Right now they both have just about the same number of fruit +/- a couple, with the exception of the Opalkas, Black Cherry, and the Sweet Clusters. The caged plants of those varieties are at least 18 inches taller and have 1/2 again more green fruit than the pruned ones do. On all the plants the fruit size is the same to the naked eye - I didn't dig out the calipers. ;) The caged ones are ripening from the lowest cluster up - same as the pruned ones - no faster, no slower so far. Don't know if this helps or not? But so far the only real advantage I can see is that the pruned plants are going to be a lot easier to pick the fruit on but I am also worried that I'm going to have more sun scald on them and less production. Time will tell. Hope this is of some help. Dave
...See More
Yet another Gaggenau vs. Miele steam oven question....
Q
Comments (21)
(Cross-posted in other Miele Steam Oven threads) We bought a Miele DGC 6800 XL Combination Steam Oven (non-plumbed) and a few months later on a whim descaled the unit. Right after the descaling process, my Miele steam oven gives me a 'Fault 20' whenever I try to do steam cooking. The regular convection cooking works fine. Expected more from Miele. I wish I had bought something else! It's out of warranty even though we probably used it about 20 times. Now Miele is asking for $150 for a technician to come out and pay an additional $90/hr for labor + $ for parts!
...See More
Yet another bar stool question
Q
Comments (5)
OH MY Goodness!! They have no opinion, and they have no opinion, and they don't care, then -- BAMM -- they have an opinion! Where did that come from!? That's happened to me and caught me off guard, with a slap across the face more than once! What's the deal with DH's that suddenly come awake during an important decision? I really want to help you and know what you want to do to involve DH in your home projects; but do not let him influence you on an important decision that you know is WRONG! Been there, you will regret it! I have desperately wanted my husband to participate in our decisions, but he simply does not care and doesn't get involved too often. On the rare occasions when he did have an opinion, I wanted to give him his opportunity for input; but it was way too late in the process and very limited in scope, and I have regretted it. Take charge and let your DH make a decision where it doesn't compromise your long range decorating decisions unless you're both in it together. If he wants input, make sure he's in the decision process from the beginning. Good Luck Annie
...See More
Elmer J Fudd
Original Author
2 months ago
No entiendo, lonejack. Are you saying you don't go to movies and don't read books?
LoneJack Zn 6a, KC
2 months ago
No to movies in theaters and I very rarely read books.
Elmer J Fudd thanked LoneJack Zn 6a, KC
stacey_mb
2 months ago
Definitely read the book first, and perhaps not even see the movie. I was reminded again how difficult it is to translate the complexity of a book into a movie when seeing the film Still Alice. I loved the book which is a portrait of a women experiencing dementia but the movie was pretty tepid in comparison.
Elmer J Fudd thanked stacey_mb
lily316
2 months ago
Probably the book. The thriller book I just read could not have been more riveting in a movie.
Elmer J Fudd thanked lily316
cyn427 (z. 7, N. VA)
2 months ago
Definitely the book. The only movie I have seen that I think was a very good adaptation of the book is To Kill a Mockingbird with Gregory Peck. Of course, I thought I would like him to be my father back then and later I thought I should try to be the kind of parent he was in that.
Elmer J Fudd thanked cyn427 (z. 7, N. VA)
Patriciae
2 months ago
The book. It seems to me movie makers simply use the title and the names of characters and then make the rest up. Creative license and expressing themselves or some such nonsense.
Elmer J Fudd thanked Patriciae
bpath
2 months ago
It depends on the author. I used to read Tom Clancy and saw a few of the movies, and I much preferred the movies. Clancy did a lot of research and included it all in the novels. The movies told the story.

Stacey, interesting about Still Alice. I didn’t read the book but the movie was scary.
Elmer J Fudd thanked bpath
donna_loomis
2 months ago
Book for sure.
Elmer J Fudd thanked donna_loomis
dedtired
2 months ago
Most times, the book, however the movie version of Brooklyn was better than the book.
Elmer J Fudd thanked dedtired
Fun2BHere
2 months ago
The book. I see very few movie adaptations and, to go further, I avoid most serial television shows based on book characters.
Elmer J Fudd thanked Fun2BHere
laceyvail 6A, WV
2 months ago
Always the book. The only movie I ever saw that I liked better than the book was The Secret of Roan Inish. Many of you know that I am a mad fan of Tolkien and have read The Lord of the Rings over 20 times. But I have never seen the movies and don't intend to. When it was on Netflix, I did decide to try it. Twenty minutes into it, I turned it off. However good others thought it was, however much it has been praised, it simply was not Tolkien or his vision.
Elmer J Fudd thanked laceyvail 6A, WV
rob333 (zone 7b)
2 months ago
last modified: 2 months ago
The movie version of The Horse Whisperer was far better. I hated the book's ending. That said, I always do both. Heck, I cast my book characters with movie stars when reading it. I hear it in their voices, and picture their faces. I'd be great at casting movies.
Elmer J Fudd thanked rob333 (zone 7b)
Alisande
2 months ago
Definitely the book. That would have been my answer as far back as I can remember, but today I can add that the older I get, the less interested I am in movies. I'm fonder of streaming series, especially ones I get attached to, like Bosch, and hate to see end. I still like books though.
Elmer J Fudd thanked Alisande

Yet another book related question

KW PNW Z8

Comments (16)

LoneJack Zn 6a, KC

Offie Myffy

Related Discussions

Elmer J Fudd
Original Author

LoneJack Zn 6a, KC

stacey_mb

lily316

cyn427 (z. 7, N. VA)

Patriciae

bpath

donna_loomis

dedtired

Fun2BHere

laceyvail 6A, WV

rob333 (zone 7b)

Alisande

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Yet another book related question

Comments (16)

Related Discussions

Elmer J FuddOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Elmer J Fudd
Original Author