I don’t care for the big logos on the first pair, but that may not be an issue for everyone. Regardless, I adore the last pair!

I agree, SueB, the logos are too much. My first pass did not turn up any naked loafers.

One vote for tweed!

The second pair look much more suitable for fall/winter.

So many more!

Some of these are suede, which I don’t think I want as they might be too difficult to keep clean. Pebbled leather seems like the best low maintenance choice for the all pink options.

I wouldn't do pink moccasins. They look too much like slippers. I like the Talbots and the first and last ones in the latest group.

I really like the tweed pair from Talbot’s and for what/when you plan on wearing them think they are a good choice. I did see them in a recent catalog but have not stopped in store.

I love the Kate Spade with the grosgrain bow!

I have had much better luck with RL Loafers fitting well than Talbots. Talbots shoes almost always hurt my heel .. and they do run narrow (which could be good for you or a problem). That said, I love the Talbots shoe and I would think it would give you a lot of wear if the fit works for you. Note: only one of the three Talbots in my area carries shoes-- and even online, they sell out quickly in popular sizes

I don't like toe cleavage so the Michael Kors would be a no for me.

@KSWL The tweed state ”Indigo multi” in catalog. I thought it was black.

just an FYI

I also love the Kate Spade bow shoes. 🥰

I love pink loafers and wear them with light wash jeans and lighter color pants. I have this strange thing about not wearing shoes that are much lighter than the pants (most especially black pants) it’s weird, I don’t know why I am like that, lol. I do love those KS shoes and now I am considering buying them.🤣 And all that said, for black pants I would wear the tweed loafers.

I like the tweed and would probably opt for them, since it seems like you might get more wear out of them. That said, the Kate Spades are adorable. Those are my absolute favorites among the all-pink options.

The tweed are great and in the solid pink group, I really like the Gucci-esque loafer.

Love the tweed!

Love them all! The ballet style always feel short on me so I wouldn't get them.

Could you tell me the brand of the pink driving moc? I'm having a hard time finding size 12 in a cute one.

Don't think you could go wrong with any of them so get the most comfortable pair.

#3 for me !!

Of the three you posted originally, I like the RL and the Talbots tweed best. Also, you sound like you have a very classy style. Love it!

The suede driving shoes are Samuel Hubbard

https://samuelhubbard.com/products/free-spirit-for-her-petal-pink-suede?variant=41371829829819

I am not familiar with the brand but they look very much loke my Born blue suede driving mocs.

and here is a pair of pebbled leather pink driving shoes

https://www.6pm.com/p/massimo-matteo-pebbled-leather-bit-driver-rose/product/9537899/color/603

I like the tweed ones best but if you are set on pink then the Kate Spade ones would be my choice. I refuse to be a walking billboard for any designer. I think the wearer should be paid to wear the first pair - the logo becomes the focal point of the shoe and thus your whole outfit. I suppose that is the point...

I kinda like the RL pink loafers ... i especially like that the logo is the same color as the shoe. FWIW I wouldn't be able to read it on a shoe LOL. I don't love large logos but they are all around and really, don't you recognize the bigger or iconic brand items anyhow?

I appreciate all this feedback. A deeper dive into some of these sites is revealing… the gucci style loafers which I like very much are actually a man made upper… so that’s off the table, and the real Guccis are not only close to $1k but are the wrong color pink.

The Kate Spades have a brown, very visible sole that I don’t like at all.

I ordered the tweed ones from Talbots, and they had a Buy one, get one at 50% off sale so I bought the basketweave style suede driving shoes (the first ones pictured in my second post) from their site as well. They were already 30% off, and then 50% of that sale price, so about $35, which makes me far less concerned about their upkeep.

”I refuse to be a walking billboard for any designer” I so agree! i really do not like logos.

The kate spade shoes are cute, but almost too much so, if that makes sense. For me, the toes are too rounded.

I am so sad that Born has pretty much stopped selling size 12. I have two pair that now I wear with kid gloves! Those two that you linked unfortunately don't come big enough. 😕

RNmom, I have not appreciated how difficult—and expensive—-it must be to get quality shoes in a size 12. I will never complain again!

Hu, the combination of round toe and brown sole were problems for me; I think the sole would torpedo my plans to wear the shoe with black slacks.

BBstx, I nearly fell off my chair reading your comment….. that guy is probably wearing a clone of my light tan vintage 70’s alligator belt!