Beautiful home. Does your house face north? That can bring out the blue in a color.

@skynina Thank you! That's what I thought too, but from checking, my house faces south.

It's possible Grayish is being influenced by the other paint colors and the stone facade colors. Peach tones will create contrast with blue tones, enhancing both; although, it leans more toward purple to my eye. Wonder if the cloudy sky is having an effect.

All the paints you selected are very near neutral greyed colours, from the Yellow-Red Hue Family.

They have little inherent colour of their own to help withstand changes in light quality.

Such colours as these, from this Hue Family neighbourhood, are highly prone to shifting purpleish where the light weights more heavily in blue/violet wavelengths.

On the most well-balanced, sunnier days you may see more monents of the colour as you imagined it to be.

I would advise moving further clockwise, selecting more colourful colours.

The "almost black" of gutter line and red of brick is going to make EVERY single shade of gray read blue to your eye.

I'd do all, body and trim in a soft white, and remove those too small shutters as well.

The color doesnt go well with the brick. Pick a color from the brick itself, for the body of your house. White trim, and once its all done, paint the front door a nice brighter color of your choice.

I agree the gray in any form does not play well with the brick unless you use a gray from the brick. A nige sagey green is a much better combo. The colors you chose are all over the map one too light one too darl and the Proper gray way too blue . I love this color and I also like the fact all the trim is the same. Pease remove the shutters thay are all wrong on that house and those windows

We struggled with the same issue - with several grays going violet in morning light. Our paint consultant moved us much warmer to more of a greige and we lost all the blue and purple we were seeing

Same here, la_la Girl. We sampled several darker grays to work with a peachy brick, and the best was BM Kendall Charcoal that leans a tad green. The house doesn't look green, though.

HU-822985052, I hesitated to make suggestions to repaint everything, because I know how expensive it is. I'm not sure what lighter color would work with Kendall Charcoal, but we can certainly do some research if you want to go that route. It's so tricky to choose colors that will look as good on your whole house as they do in your hand.

Not my house, but you can see it doesn't look green. You can use it for just the trim, and find a lighter color that gives the same non-blue/purple result.

Your brick looks more like stone to me, and I see no "peachy" tone on my monitor, as others keep referencing. I think this is where www.samplize.com would have been helpful. I would suggest you finish the paint job, see if you can get used to it, and if not; save up to redo it in the future.

I don't use SW. But in southern exposure? BM Navaho White will read as a sweet spot between soft white and palest beige. Won't go yellow. I think gray just not the right choice for the house in any shade. Sort of as wrong feeling as the shutters incorrectly sized to the window.

The peachy brick is on my house, but I am suspecting a peach tone in the OP's stone. Saving for a future redo is a smart option.

Thank you all for your advice/suggestions. We will be getting samples and testing out new paint colors for a couple day to find new ones to redo in the future.

I see that I’m late to the party. But I’ll chime in to say that blues and grays are questionable on your lovely brick home.

Pitch the shutters as they cheapen the house.

Many things can impact the appearance of a lighter shade like the sky, other colors, and the time of the day here. I agree with houssaon’s ta/brown suggestions here.