Volunteer Great Blue Lobelia?

last year

Hi everyone. Any idea what this is? I DO have a Great Blue Lobelia nearby and do know they self-sow....and the leaves on this do look similar to GBL..But I'm not certain...
Thanks!

Featured Answer

floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK

last year

The last one looks to me like an actual strawberry, as do the seedlings beside it. There seem to bits of other fruit next to it. Has this container been used as a compost pot?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (19)

Lynn Nevins
Original Author
last year
Lynn Nevins
Original Author
last year
Related Discussions
WANTED: Lobelia Queen Victoria, and Great Blue..
Q
Comments (1)
Hi. I have the Lobelia 'Queen Victoria' if your still interested. I looked at your list and would be interested in Fragrant Angel Coneflower. Let me know. Thanks, Tina
...See More
HAVE: Great blue lobelia and obedient plant
Q
Comments (1)
bumping down
...See More
Qs on Jacob's Ladder, Great Blue Lobelia, Echinacea Butterfly Kiss
Q
Comments (7)
No, not a joke. Some Ranunculus species can be weeds while others are planted as ornamentals. It doesn't look particularly like a Ranunculus to me, but I only know a few species. Try uploading to Houzz Photos via Your Houzz in the upper right corner and then link from there or try uploading directly here from a different browser - some forms of Internet Explorer doesn't do well with Houzz. many folks here aren't on FB. With perennials, they often need a year before performing to their best, so if they are happy with their growing situation they should perform better next season. Jacob's Ladder (Polemonium) is a spring bloomer that in my garden prefers part shade, but Great Blue Lobelia (Lobelia siphilitica) prefers a lot of light and is dense in full sun. It doesn't like to dry out. Echinacea is another full sun plant. Also, you could ask on the Container Forum to see if you have chosen a good soil mix for the plants you are growing - often commercial potting mix doesn't work long-term since it breaks down over time.
...See More
Great Blue Lobelia… NOT!
Q
Comments (7)
Apart from the colors (which could be just a matter of different lighting) your leaves look much thicker and the toothing is a little different.
...See More
peren.all Zone 5a Ontario Canada
last year
No not a Lobelia. If you break a leaf is there white sap?
Lynn Nevins
Original Author
last year
Let me check and advise re white sap. Also, here's another volunteer I'm trying to figure out... the larger green leaves...
ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
last year
always add your location.. sometimes it matter to IDs .. big city name

and it not a poekweed.. lol ..

ken
peren.all Zone 5a Ontario Canada
last year
The second could possibly be Potentilla indica - Mock strawberry.
carolb_w_fl_coastal_9b
last year
That first one does remind me of a milkweed, and the second definitely has a strawberry - or mock strawberry - vibe.
Lynn Nevins
Original Author
last year
last modified: last year
Ha! Thanks all. I'm in NYC, which I think is Zone 6b. And indeed, I DO often throw less than optimal blueberries and strawberries out onto my planters, for the local birds, squirrels etc to enjoy.

So that's cool...that maybe I have a strawberry seedling on my hands. I'll transplant it to another pot and see what happens (though I imagine nothing will come to fruition so to speak, this year...). I'm not as savvy re: fruits/vegetables.... are strawberries perennial...and/or do they re-seed?

Also, for peren.all Zone 5a Ontario Canada: Regarding the first plant ...my original question in this thread.... Bingo! Yes...as soon as I broke off a leaf, white sap. So...what do you think it is, then? Thanks!
cecily 7A
last year
Strawberries are perennial, yes, and they make a nice groundcover.

The plant with white milky sap is milkweed.
peren.all Zone 5a Ontario Canada
last year
last modified: last year
Yes Lynn I was thinking Asclepias sp. - Milkweed.
Lynn Nevins
Original Author
last year
Common Milkweed?? Wow, that's interesting...perplexing... and exciting!! Let me explain.... the volunteer milkweed appeared on my 3rd floor balcony....in a planter... Just one floor above my balcony, and just a bit inward from the balcony, is our 4th floor rooftop, where the landlord allows me to keep additional planters. And up on the 4th floor is where I planted some Common Milkweed seedlings that I had successfully germinated, in April or so.

But here's the weird part....the Common Milkweed seedlings on the roof stagnated....once they germinated, the seedlings never grew beyond 2" in height. It's very odd. I'll post another pic here, of what my rooftop milkweed seedlings look like. Strange that the seedlings I Wanted to grow are stagnant, and yet, a volunteer version just a floor below, seems to be doing very well.....
Lynn Nevins
Original Author
last year
macranthos
last year
Are those lots of orange aphids on your milkweed seedlings?
Lynn Nevins
Original Author
last year
I've not seen any aphids. You just may be seeing that some of the leaves are a bit dried out looking (for some reason). I'm really stumped why these seedlings (on my roof) are so stagnant...barely alive...yet the other (volunteer) milkweed on my balcony are doing so well. Is it possible that the seedlings don't like something about the rooftop and being in such direct sun all day? (My balcony, on the other hand, gets direct sun until 100p or so, and indirect sun after that...) Otherwise, all the plants are growing in the same type of potting medium.....
floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
last year
Milkweed seeds are borne by the wind on silky fluff similar dandelions. They could easily reach your balcony from anywhere.

Even if the strawberries do fruit, they will not necessarily be much like the fruit you threw out. They may or may not be garden worthy. Named cultivars are propagated vegetatively. nb the genus name is FragAria.
Lynn Nevins
Original Author
last year
@macranthos.... I was looking at my original Milkweed seedlings...the ones that are stagnant and never grew beyond 2" in height and....I think you are right!...I observed some teeny weeny little orange mounds on the backs of the leaves... So, could that explain why those seedlings never grew...the aphids essentially killed the seedlings, which at this point are just barely hanging on?

Is there a natural remedy for aphids, do you know? I do have some neem oil/soap I believe... Thanks!
floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
last year
On seedlings a natural remedy would be your finger and thumb possibly aided by a spray of plain water.
Lynn Nevins thanked floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
Lynn Nevins
Original Author
last year
Thanks. And could the aphids explain why the seedlings never grew beyond 2"?