new bath looks great. I don't think it has to "match" the rest of the house. Besides, browns and tans are outdated

looks fine.

who said anything about bathrooms having to match the rest of the house? how boring would that be? browns and tans everywhere in a house? I'd lose my mind.

It's fine. move on.

consider redoing the other parts of the house to match this much brighter bathroom. that travertine, wood, and brown mosaic tile is no longer in style. trends change. brown and tan have moved on.

Bathroom looks nice, no need to have it match the rest. It is a nice updated bath and is pretty neutral. I would put up a nice shower curtain, some towels and art on the wall and call it done. Don't overthink it.

To me the new bathroom looks like a good compromise between the old one and an updated one. It is certainly acceptable to have your hall bath look different from your master bath.

It would never have occurred to me to have our bathrooms match--both match the overall style of the house, yes, but they don't match each other. And they intentionally have different color schemes (as do most of the rooms in our house, unless they open into each other--and even then, they have related colors but not the same color). The only reason to use the same granite and tile in separate rooms, IMO, is if you're renovating everything at once so it's less expensive to use the remnants in the bath. Otherwise--definitely not needed, and I'd find it a little odd in a house that wasn't a flip.

You lost me with your initial need/assumption the bathroom needed to "match" color wise with the rest of the home. The room looks beautiful. My DH INSISTED on stupid brown accent tiles too so not I am STUCK with brown brown browns. White was my goal so I could swap out colors towels etc. as times change, my mood changed....hate that I am STUCK.

If you were wanting the bathroom to reflect other colors in home, I think it’s a good choice in that it is warm but you benefit from it also feeling airy and fresh. The combination looks great and that’s the most important thing and as others have said, bathrooms often stand on their own.

Bathrooms do not have to match anything but who chose that mix of tile I do not find those choices attractive but now the best is to get a glass shower screen and forget adding a shower curtain IMO it will only add to the mish mash.

I think the wall niche tile is throwing it off. Can that be replaced?

I suggest you try a white shower curtain with some texture such as a basketweave pattern so you don't introduce a competing color.

It looks great!

Too bad a certain ”pro” can’t keep her rude and unhelpful comments to herself. Ignore her; she’s known for this and seems to take pride in being a jerk. I think it looks nice, fresh and updated, too I love a shower curtain instead of glass. You can add color or pattern or stay with a plain color. Much easier upkeep, too.

Just because a certain 'pro' doesn't like YOUR choice of tile, it doesn't mean that it's wrong? I think it all goes well together. I personally like shower curtains and prefer them to glass. Your bathroom is NO mish mash!

She hates everything and is incredibly nasty for no reason.

I think both bathrooms look great, and coordinate just fine.

Browns/tans as a color choice are most certainly not ”out”. They’re coming back in a big way among top designers (and I don’t mean Hygge or MCM, but saturated browns in various tones mixed with other colors and with patterns).

OP, get a rug and shower curtain you love, and other decor … it’ll come together. I don’t know your style preferences to be more specific, but you could go neutral, bring in patterns you like, or a bit of both.