Old home renovation

2 years ago

Doing a complete renovation on a 1900’s farmhouse. the entire downstairs has oak trim, large columns. the kitchen is a full gut and will be updated with painted cabinets. the harwood floors in the living room/dining space will be stripped and sealed. How do we finish all the stained trim? leave or paint to flow with new kitchen?

Featured Answer

PRO

HALLETT & Co.

2 years ago

If the trim is nice leave it natural and paint the kitchen/ most houses from that era had painted trim on kitchen and bathrooms because it was considered more hygienic.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (12)

HU-467915565
last year
last modified: last year
If you're considering painting all the trim to flow with the new kitchen, I recommend doing a few test patches on the trim first to see how the paint will look and hold up over time. If you're set on keeping the stained trim, I would recommend looking into a clear polyurethane or varnish to help protect it from wear and tear. Also, during your renovation process, I recommend storing all the furniture and items in unit storage. In this way, you will prevent them from damaging while renovating your house. It's my life lesson after I cracked the screen of my 30-inch TV. :D
Related Discussions
Renovating and Lead Paint question...
Q
Comments (45)
With adequate ventilation (outdoors is preferred) the methylene chloride (MC) strippers still work better than anything else. I routinely remove trim fr stripping, and cannot remember the last time a piece was damaged by removal. It just takes a lot of patience and gentle prying. If you cover MC stripper with plastic wrap (I use the wider thicker food service grade) it slows evaporation enough to remove MANY layers of finish in a single application. The cheap plastic drywall knives have been a boon (I used to purchase plastic sheets (PVC) and shape them and then drill a hole to use on a cabinet scrapper handle in place of the metal blade). You can even cut them to shape for molding patterns (used more like a scrapper at 90 degrees than a 'knife' at a lower angle). Sawdust is also great for rubbing away softened paint (clay type kitty litter works if you do not have a lot of sawdust). MC is hazardous to folks that may have compromised blood circulation to the heart. It behaves much like carbon monoxide and ties up the ability of heme on your blood to carry oxygen.
...See More
"This Old House" - renovating a cottage
Q
Comments (19)
LOL! I remember the one Bob Vila did, where they added on an entire house to the back of the old house. Do you remember the one where they had a living room, dining room, small walk through office and a kitchen...then a breezeway out to the old garage and outhouse??? That was a neat old house, but rather than work with it and make it really charming again...they added on a new kitchen (like they need another seating area where the old kitchen used to be!) and an eating area and another living area. It was huge and then they chose some very 'interesting' wallpaper for the upstairs. Anyway, the owners were going to contribute a lot of 'sweat equity' to keep the budget under control. They steamed off some old wallpaper and a few other things...then the budget basically doubled because they hired everything else done. Bob Vila made a big deal about that on the final few episodes and it was actually pretty funny. That might have been the end of the owner contribution and discussing budgets :)
...See More
My friend's childhood home featured
Q
Comments (3)
Cool. I saw that article. Not easy seeing your parents' choices called "dated" on national TV! But the show needs the drama.
...See More
buying first remodel, 1906 four square and I have SO MANY QUESTIONS
Q
Comments (56)
You will have only one opportunity in your life to buy that house so if owning a spectacular vintage home is your dream, buy it. Owning an old house is a lifestyle, not an investment. If it is worth substantially more after your updates, that's great but don't include that value in your financial planning for retirement. However fantastic the house is, I would not buy it if you couldn't live in it with the room types and sizes as it was built. Obviously the mechanicals have to be in good working order but an outdated kitchen can wait until you have spent enough time to learn about the quirks and qualities of this house. Decisions made after you live there will be different than those made after just walking through. Our previous home looked much like the one directly above and we owned it for 26 years. We moved in when I was pregnant with my oldest, moved out when youngest graduated from college. Buying a more modest house would have been a better overall deal financially because midrange houses in our community appreciated much more than ones at the top of the range. When we did sell, the net was 25% higher than we had paid. However we had the pleasure (and occasional pain!) of living in an architect designed house with tons of natural light, top quality construction and fittings, in a desirable neighborhood. Unlike many owners might have done, we did not update the house. We did have to redo the flat roof section, then added a few more electrical outlets and converted the coal room into a wine cellar and pantry. The mid 70s steam boiler was a cast iron monster that never failed. In particularly bad heat waves, we used a couple window AC units but solid masonry house and an attic fan handled most of the summer weather. We raised two kids in an old house with only one bathroom and no central air. We had coat hooks in a hallway, not a mudroom. We had basement laundry and a clothesline for good weather. Of course we would have enjoyed a big kitchen and a master suite but that wasn't how the house was built. My personal view is that if you want the features of a new house, buy or build one. If you love the beautiful house, be gentle and err on the side of doing less, not more
...See More
PRO
Diana Bier Interiors, LLC
last year
Oh yes, DON'T paint the wood trim--it looks very nice! As Hallett says, painted kitchens and natural wood trim are totally appropriate for a home of that era. Would love to see your progress in renovating this old home!
njmomma
last year
Love older homes! I will be watching, please post pictures as you go along renovating.
PRO
Norwood Architects
last year
Beautiful home!! Love the wood trim and the columns. What you do to the trim is somewhat dependent on what you are doing overall - especially with wall color. What condition is the trim? Is it worn or battered? Has the finish gone gummy or is it still in decent shape? A compromise between leaving as is or painting is pickling. This would lighten the trim but allow for the woodgrain to still show thru. Would love to see some progress photos.
PRO
GN Builders L.L.C
last year
Agreeing with all of the above comments, I would leave the aesthetics of 1900s architecture, nothing can beat the natural beauty of wood.

When I was starting out in the early '80s there were lots of requests for naturally stained wood, solid wood doors, wood columns, beautiful trip packages, etc as time went on all that was slowly fading away, and I can't remember when the last time a customer requested for a nice stained wood trim package and most homes you enter today it's the same old boring colors, and when you come across something like this with original woodwork you can really appreciate woodwork and true craftsmanship.

Good luck with your renovation!
ShadyWillowFarm
last year
OMG I just want to hug your house. I love the wood too, but if in some areas it’s not sensible to leave it, don’t lose any sleep over making changes.
Alice Edwards
last year
Following and looks like you have a good helper there! Beautiful old home, if it’s feasible, as mentioned above, keep the wood trim stained. Kitchen and bath can go painted. Cannot wait to see your progress here :)
Alice Edwards
last year
And also there are many images out there that have the stained wood trim in the kitchens as well. And many are not a dark feel as most would imagine.
HU-187528210
last year
Wowwww!!! 💗💗💗

Beautiful house!
I’d tackle this project one room at a time.
Look at each room and visualize how you want it.

Some of the wood, I think I would paint. Or remove.
Like the door behind the pillars in the first photo.

And I might remove the columns.
But things like the trim, the baseboards. That magnificent closet door in the second photo ,THE FLOORS - 💗
That id keep…
PRO
Diana Bier Interiors, LLC
last year
Stained wood trim can be awesome--here's a photo of the entry foyer of a 1900s Queen Anne Victorian in my town--original wood trim and stained glass windows. The owners have kept all the wood, and even matched it where there were missing pieces. I think they've done an outstanding job.
Historic home · More Info
hbeing
last year
I vote not to paint that beautiful woodwork.

Old home renovation

HALLETT & Co.

Comments (12)

HU-467915565

Related Discussions

Diana Bier Interiors, LLC

njmomma

Norwood Architects

GN Builders L.L.C

ShadyWillowFarm

Alice Edwards

Alice Edwards

HU-187528210

Diana Bier Interiors, LLC

hbeing

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US