Consider painting it all in the lightest color in your roof tiles. I wouldn't bother with the columns. In back, you could remove the awning, add more columns and balance a pergola on top of them where the awning has been. If you need sun protection pergolas can use curtains or shade cloth.

Product Gallery · More Info

Trex Pergola+ShadeTree Canopy Poolside · More Info

a soft green paint would compliment the landscaping you already have.

Do you have an inspiration photo of "Greek Tuscan"?

I can see why you don't like the pink. I'd go with a creamy off-white. I'd bet if you painted your roof, it would be a flaky, peeling mess in a few years. The Spanish tile goes with the roof. I'd plant some trees and other greenery around your porch. A pergola with vines might be nice.

Thanks for all the reply’s. Here’s a few pictures of houses that I like, I think the house would still scream pink to me if I painted it the lightest paint color of the tile. They are so pink 😱

I love the pergola, our back porch is an odd shape, the pool is to close to the back doors so the columns are close to the slider resulting in difficult furniture placement. It’s a huge back yard, the original owners added an addition, wish they would have pushed the pool back more so we could entertain better.

Love this entry way, we are planning on getting a new door too

Kept the rounded windows but that light bed paint really helped

Then there is this beauty, the new windows transform the house. New windows just aren’t in the budget, I do like the dark roof with the white as well. We are in Florida so the sun will prob fade them if it’s not something that is typically done.

Thanks for photos. Paint it soft white. Before the painters arrive, have the shrubs pruned back to make at least a foot of room for the painters next to the wall. White will be quite a dramatic change from the pink. Then live with the new look for a few months and see if there's anything else that you really want in your budget.