Is the roof color changing to a flat tan or the roof pitch changing to a flat roof? You could do a stucco coat over the rocks.

Those are some scary looking tarantulas on the front lawn.

It’s changing to shingles like this and yea gotta redo the whole front yard and fence too

Check with your local real estate agents, but I believe they will tell you that changing your concrete barrel tile roof to asphalt shingles will reduce the value of your home.

You might want to check some of the synthetic substitutes now being offered to replace your roof.

I'd use Romabio Limewash or Masonry Paint on the total house. See images below.

I think your home would be more charming like this.

Hmm what color tho. I was thinking maybe painting the rock a dark grey and the house a light color maybe? Like that kind of dark grey? The rocks are just so big kind of reminds me of the flintstones lol

Definitely not gray with a tan roof.

When you say ’flat roof’ you don’t mean removing the whole roof and its pitch, do you? In my experience, flat roofs always leak because they don’t drain off.

I’d see if I could get the rocks and chimney the same color as the siding/stucco (or whatever the body of the house is). If you stay with the current roof color or go to a tan, make the rest of the house a pale tan or cream or beige.

^^^ limewash the stone, paint the stucco to match including the fence columns. Remove the ornaments off the fence, paint all the ironwork and the windows black.

I want to second what Beverly has suggested that your Spanish Style home should embrace the terracotta roof and warm white body. I think gray would look terribly out of sync with the architecture of the home.

Wow great advice!!! I was looking at limewashing the rocks too and just have everything match. My dad decided to change the roof to the flat material I showed you instead of keeping the tile so I can’t go back now I liked the tile roof a lot too!

Too bad because changing the roof, especially if the tiles were still good just lowered the value of your house significantly.

If the roof isn't leaking but you've already paid for new material, resell it. If the roof is leaking, is it time for replacement, or can it be repaired? It is a shame to be replacing it with plain shingles.

Those roofs last forever unless they get damaged. If there is a problem underneath I believe you can take them off and then re-lay. My Grandpa installed one in Salt Lake City area over 40 years ago (maybe 50 now?) and it's still going strong. At the time my dad worked for Monier Roof Tile, hauled the tiles up all the way up from southern CA, and installed it for him.

edit - man it's probably been close to or over 60 years.