Look at Urbane Bronze.

Other things you didn't ask about but people here are famous for giving extra suggestions:

The brick needs to be cleaned.

It seems the gutter by your chimney is insufficient in size or is leaking.

Remove the shutters on your front big window

The storm door should match the color of the front door to avoid the "white rectangle" effect.

Whatever you do, paint samples on large foamboard and look at it in different lights against the brick.

Cute house.

Read through this thread, it may help you:

https://www.houzz.com/discussions/5934636/advice-needed-for-choosing-exterior-trim-colors-for-a-yellow-tan-brick

I can't see if you have a light, but a beautiful light of the correct size would be a lovely touch.

I would go in a different direction with your charming house that has such great details (love those diamond panes windows and dormer shutters so much) — more Storybrook cottage than dark Tudor. Something fun and different than the charcoal trim trend (say that three times fast).

The roof and brick are in the brown family, I’d look for a blue or green that would compliment that, making sure it would also be cohesive with the red tones in your roof.

Obviously these aren’t exactly like your brick, just wanted to show trim color ideas.

Just sharing this purple one for fun, not recommending it for your house. It made me smile, though. Looks like a happy house. :)

Jinx, we just watched an episode of "Restored" that featured a Storybook Cottage that was TO... DIE...FOR. At the end, I told my husband that was hands down my favorite episode and house. I think he was a little concerned I was going to try to find a house in CA like that...

Anna, I love them! That episode sounds great. They’re just so cute and cheery. :)

I think you’ll like this story about the green one I posted above:

https://www.oldhouseonline.com/house-tours/storybook-odyssey/

PS: I’m moving to Portland. :D

https://www.cottagesandbungalowsmag.com/real-estate/storybook-cottages-portland-oregon/

Thanks, Jinx. Here's a gallery of the renovation:

https://www.oldcalifornia.com/1927-storybook-cottage-gallery.html

I LOOOOVE rounded front doors.

OP, sorry to hijack your thread.

ETA: Jinx, the article was awesome! I loved the Art Nouveau radiators...it's killing me.

Another vote for SW Urbane Bronze, not too brown , not too charcoal, I’m having the siding on my MCM home painted that color in a few weeks.

If the OP decides on a darker color for sure, I agree with the Urbane Bronze suggestions. It’s such an amazing chameleon-type color that seems to play well with nearly everything!

OP, I hope you’ll update us, would love to see ”afters”. I really love your house. :)

@Anna (6B/7A in MD) … love that link, thank you!

May be too much drama with Urbane Bronze?

I like the dark color of Urban Bronze. I light warm gray might work or a light tan. Remove the shutters. Paint the front door a contrasting color.

Thank you all so much for your ideas! I absolutely love this house and will definitely update you when I finally commit to a color! The front shutters are coming off and several repairs still need to be made. I loved the idea of a fun color, but I don’t think I am brave enough to try it:) I’m almost fully convinced to go with Urbane Bronze and for sure a bold door color. Thoughts on if I need a second color or to go all one color how the red is now?

Please remember to TEST the colors. But here are the coordinating colors suggested by SW:

Bet an earthy green would look pretty great with it. Or a light slate blue?

https://www.sherwin-williams.com/architects-specifiers-designers/inspiration/color-forecast/2021-color-forecast/2021-color-of-the-year-urbane-bronze

Buy the book "Storybook Style" by Gellner & Keister ($20 used). It will help you with ideas (colors/landscaping) to enhance your charming house. Love your home! Please keep us posted.