Your second picture could pass for my Moonlight in Paris but the first and third pictures look like too many small petals for MiP. Mine has larger, looser inner petals. I'll vote for Crocus Rose.

I'm going to label it as Crocus Rose! I do believe that's what it is. For now😁

In my garden Crocus Rose is a little paler.

But sometimes it does this, which is kind of similar to your rose:

It looks to me like my Crocus Rose might have more petals.

Hmm.. after looking at those, I'm not so sure it's crocus Rose! I'm tempted to buy another Moonlight in Paris and another Crocus Rose to grow in my garden to compare it to, just to figure it out. I'm sure that explanation would hold enough weight to convince my husband.

@Ashley Smith zone 5a It could just be me, but my MiP has far less petals.

Erasmus, my blooms do lighten as they age. Here's a full bush shot where they look lighter.

And yes if you zoom in you can see I haven't picked Japanese Beetles off this morning yet😖

Magpie, I agree, I think your MIP looks different.

I planted a hedge of MIP this Spring (bought from Home Depot as those plastic containers ), half of those are pink which makes me think they were mislabeled, the other half are cream/peachy/apricot, more like the pictures everyone else posted above.

Pink MIP . May be mislabeled? 😅 anyone knows if this looks like Heritage?

Ashley , that whole bush shot does look more like Crocus Rose.

Rosecanadian and Toto, those are some gorgeous pics of MIP blooms. I bought one last fall from Heirloom and my plant has had a lot of blooms this year but most are more washed out looking. I don't fret about that because for me blooms usually improve as a plant gets older and bigger. The pink rose kind of looks like Heritage. One distinct thing about Heritage is that the blooms blow fast. They do have a strong, sweet, citrusy fragrance.

Erasmus - thanks. :)

I agree about the pink rose being Heritage. :)

My Crocus rose looks like yours Ashley -- pale lemon yellow.

Thank you Erasmus and Rosecanadian! Pink roses do blow fast . I think they are indeed Heritage as they are also almost no thorns on the stems.
Rosecanadian- your MIP blooms are so gorgeous! I only saw one or two blooms like that among my MIP in the Spring flushs. The rest of time they are less pedals comparing to yours !

Toto - really? I'm not really thinking they're all that nice (on my bush)....maybe you're giving me a new appreciation for them! :) :) Thank you!