I would match the trim and siding to the fascia.

This is tough. I think these are best but since your garage door is so prominent, I would paint that the trim color too.

Opps Sorry for the double on Domino. I think the darker color contrasts with your brick tones best and pulls the near black from your brick too. But you could also do a cinnamon spice color it just isn’t as dramatic.

Thanks so much for your advice. When we bought the house the trim was reddish brown and it was too red for our taste. They had painted the fascia above the garage door and the gable to match everything else. The old wooden garage door was in bad shape so we replaced it about 10 years ago and repainted the trim and siding. The siding and windows are currently Valspar Cabin Plank and the garage door trim and gable fascia are Valspar Italian Leather. We would prefer a lighter color than the Cabin Plank and are looking at Valspar Garden Walk as a unifying color. It's similar to Italian Leather, but browner.

I will look up the Valspar Garden Walk and see what I think. Internet colors are not true, so would you describe your brick as a redish overall impression? Or an orange-ish overall impression?

Ok. I have looked up all the colors you posted. Bottom line, if you want to unify you need only 2 or max 3 colors. I would stick with 2 colors. First your brick has 3-4 colors, I don’t know the roof color but I am guessing a gray/brown? So I would consider New Black for the siding and all trim in Night View. The black will be a neutral and the Night View will actually act as a lighter tone mixing nicely with your brick. It is also a recommended pair with the Garden Walk. Garden walk will go Gray in your setting most likely. Of course, you have to get samples and look at them in all natural light conditions morning, noon and early evening.

I would have to say it is orange-ish. The mortar is cream colored and the brick has some yellowish tan in it. The roof is reddish brown and we were told it should last 7-10 years. We are planning to paint over the Cabin Plank and the Italian Leather with the new color(s), so there will be only two colors on the house.

I like Rattan Basket for the fascia and the siding. How about Garden Path for the trim and keep the dark gray on the garage? This combination is almost one of the ones Valspar suggested.

I think the fascia will look better in a lighter color and a lighter color on the siding will draw the eye away from the garage.

Above is Garden Walk against the brick in full sun. The garage door is actually a lighter color than Garden Walk.

Garden Walk does look grayer in shade.

Here is a sample of Garden Walk against the garage door. As you can see, we've been trying all sorts of color combinations.

Garden Walk with the sun room doors.

This is hard. I would not want to paint a factory finish on a rather new garage door or the windows.

We are not planning to paint the garage door and definitely not the frames on the sliding glass doors. The casement window frames are wood and will be painted. We are willing to paint the fascia but not the soffits. I think we can live with the difference between the garage door and trim painted with Garden Walk, especially since that color is darker and looks good with the brick, like the Italian Leather. The trim is mostly in shade, so that will de-emphasize the color difference. I'm not sure Garden Walk is dark enough for the overall look of the house, but we will try it and see. As Flo Mangan suggested, darker colors really do set off the brick.

I think I would match trim and siding to window trim. The garage door can stay same but that would keep “factory” colors in tact as houssaon points out and keeps color palette quiet. The colors you are considering are not cohesive. They come from different Hue families. So I think you have two main choices. A cream fascia color as houssaon showed or match window trim. Since the eye sees white and light first, that will be a strong contrast. I think less contrast is better and then add some colorful large pots overflowing with color to your landscape. Build a bed by the driveway with some light earthy stone and mulch and add colorful pots and flowers. Something like this.

This gives your landscape some interest and takes the eye to something more interesting.

similar brick homes w/darker trim. see if you like any of these

Flo, when you say that the colors we are considering are from different hue families, are you talking about the proposed Garden Walk color being a different hue than the garage door/ sliding glass door frames? Thanks in advance for helping me understand your comments.

Beth, I like all of the photos you posted but am not sure how to apply that to our house, which has much more brick and less siding.

Here are two colors along the lines of your selections. Just to try to show you the concept of Hue Families and color. Valspar is not in any major color systems so I can’t give you the scientific DNA for those colors. Here are two examples. Each of these look similar but in reality have quite different hue families. The hue will be the predominant color seen under lighting conditions that are controlled and measured. Notice where each falls on the color wheel.

By being able to know the color DNA I can make good color recommendations. So of these two colors and knowing your brick is predominately orange, I like Urbane Bronze because it is in the Yellow Hue family and has other characteristics that make it a good candidate for your home. What makes your home difficult is there are several colors with different hue families. Hence they fight a bit. Hope this helps a little. Hard to explain in a few sentences. 😊

you could use them for the fascia trim or the garage doors.

I like Urbane Bronze. flo posted it too. I like it w/Alabaster if you want something lighter.

because your garage is so front and center, I think if you tweaked that a bit it would add a lot more curb appeal.

I gave you two different types of lights and address placques. (you only choose one obviously)

first thing I'd do is to remove those arched pop in window panels. The arch is very 90's. they are easy, and cheap to remove or replace

here's a very dark door w/square windows and new lights. immediately updates the look

Same door in a lighter gray color

ligher warm gray, diff light, address placque on brick. this door has no windows, which I don't care for. just showing you the color. I like the square window panels.

black door, square grid windows, bronze lights, address, copper pots

if you can, get some iron hardware along w/the square window panels.

larger lights in a brass or copper

planters in a copper or a glazed ceramic

and if you want something different, lighten up all the trim with a creamy white, and do a navy garage door (square windows again!)

I agree Jennifer. That’s what I suggested too. Get a color match as close as you can. The different “planes” of surfaces will always look a bit different anyway. Just reduce overall number of colors and update your landscaping. Larger exterior lighting would be nice too. Consider an arbor for over garage door to create more welcoming curb appeal.

Here is example