Any one of those blues would look wonderful. It is hard to say. I would look to go with one of the darker shades.

Which one is the closest to what you want and how would you change it if you could?

7 would look nice w/a crisp white.

you might think about doing some cedar in the gables. wood looks great w/blue.

see the cedar shake w/the navy and white?

So here are some blues. which one do you like?

this is BM Hale Navy and Crisp White. Notice the Haint Blue porch ceiling!!

again, notice the wood accent. so pretty w/blue. this one might be similar to Salty Dog

I don't think you have this one, but it's very pretty, especially w/the stone work

Could be Blueprint^

Naval or Indigo Batik.

love the deep navy w/crisp white and bright yellow

I'd also do a very pale blue or "Haint Blue" on your porch ceiling.

The lighter color is Behr Watery

2 or 5

I think they ARE too bright. A deeper (closer to navy) blue with white trim has a more elegant feel. You can see the examples Beth posted. You will have a lot of trim for contrast (and then a happy color door!) so I would go deeper. If I had to pick one of the current samples, I liked #7. But I like @Beth H’s darker ones better. Keep looking. (And remember that the sun will lighten your paint over time.)
I had a deep blueish-green house and barn. It was BM River Blue. The trim is an ivory not white.

Thanks all. I am after the look one of Beth's. I prefer the darker one below but love the top one too. We have alot of shade and I don't want it to look black so I am nervous with super dark. With our samples Color #3 shows no blue on cloudy days. I like #2 In the Navy but it looks a tinge purple to me. I really like Newburyport as a color but think it will be too smurf bright over a big space. Does anyone know what color this is on Beth's pictures? We do plan on painting the porch ceiling's a haint blue. The porch will be white with natural color wicker outdoor furniture.

what direction does the front face?

have you tried Hale Navy? I think that's the color on the last photo you posted above.

Hale Navy with Pale Oak trim.

don't be afraid of it looking too dark. against the crisp white, it's going to look great. Heck, I think it would look great in black!

speaking of, this is Addisons Wonderland home, in a mix of Soot and Witching Hour. But it does look like soot. the white is Dove Wing.

I actually painted my wall is a custom mix of Hale Navy and a deep black. You could play around w/your samples and pick one of the blues you really like but thing are too 'bright', and mix in a deeper navy or thrown in a bit of black.

here are some darker tones for that one color you like

I just found this one. it's BM Indi Go-Go. If you think the other navys are too dark, this one may be light enough aginst all your shade.

Paired here w/warmer whites. I like the crisp whites better.

Hudson Bay is another one that is dark, but not too dark.

Here's that one pic you asked about:

Here's Hale Navy

BM VanDeusen Blue: (I've used this color. it's very pretty. if you home is in mostly shade, this may be be dark enough for you)

BM Stormy Sky and Classic Gray on the trim

BM Ocean Floor

beautiful w/the greens. White Trim is White dove

Maybe these others will help.

Some of these are gray/navys. Decorators white is a cool white. great for a crisp white against the dark blue

The Gentleman’s Gray may be the right one if you’re worried about the Hale Navy being too dark on cloudy days. It’s a “touch” lighter but it has the same deep color feel. What is so gorgeous about navy and white is the crispness of the look. You need a deep color for that contrast.
I love the idea of natural wicker porch furniture!

I like #2 In the Navy but it looks a tinge purple to me.

Because it belongs to the Purple-Blue hue family. Twilight is the most similar to In the Navy you'll find. You can see on the color wheel that it is in fact less purple and more blue.

Thank you so much! I am going to get a sample of it.

If you don’t want a dark blue that leans purple to your eye, and if Twilight is too dark for you, look at BM Summer Nights

If you don’t want a dark navy or a blue that seems purple, BM River Blue has a green undertone. I used it for my previous house and barn with an ivory trim.

I absolutely love Newburyport blue. It is such a rich blue. Your house looks great.

The roof is a good compliment and the metal awnings are an attractive detail.

Thanks for posting an update it is always good to see the progress.

Love the color - it really suits the house! Congratulations - you must be relieved, lol. I am waiting for the painter to appear and start repainting our house, and the suspense is awful.

Great choice! It looks great already.