Wow! Almost any color will be an improvement. The roof and stone stones look very similar. I'd try a beige, light taupe, or soft grayed green. You might be able to use a very light blueish gray taken from the variation in the stone color - less blue than your shutters. Whatever color you choose, paint the siding and base of the home the same color.

And please paint the garage door the same color as the house!

I should have mentioned that we did NOT choose these colors and are trying to achieve a cohesive look now that we own it! Personally I would love to do a darker green, blue or grey, but am not sure it will work?

I don't think a darker blue green or gray will look good with your roof. A white house is always a classic.

I agree. I think whites your safest option. Until you can do a full exterior remodel. For now I’d just go white. With a pretty color shutter depending on your preferred style.

I was wondering about a color scheme something along these lines. This roof is gray, not brown, but I think greige tones would still work. Look at the soffit, for one. Love the door color here.

Mid-Century Modern Atlanta · More Info

The house kind of looks like this one I have saved in my idea book. And it's green.

https://www.houzz.com/photos/total-home-exterior-makeover-adds-value-curb-appeal-and-real-estate-value-traditional-exterior-minneapolis-phvw-vp~73636877

I think they painted the garage door 1/2 shade darker to make it recess a little bit.

I wish they would have done something different with the trash can however.

Izzy, I think OP should try some green shades as well, like the gable color on this house. I'd consider some more sage tones, with all that reddish hardscape and the planter.

Refined Rustic Kitchen & Exterior Refresh · More Info

OP's planter COULD be a very attractive feature!

So much helpful guidance! definitely open to a sage green and going to consider griege and white as well. I love a classic white but tend to think it works best on a house with a little more architectural interest than we have. Seems like we will need a separate post on landscaping ;)

I think a grayed green would be nice with your stone, similar to this example with brick. And yes, the landscaping will make a big difference.

Poppleton Park, Birmingham, MI Exterior Makeover · More Info