Outlining all the openings in contrasting color is an issue for me. I don't think there is much of a style to it, except builder's special. What kind of homes are in the neighborhood? Most Houzzers would suggest you live in the home 6-12 months to figure out how well it functions for you and what are the major issues with form (the way it looks.) Meanwhile, engage a local nursery to help plan out the landscaping. Some of it might need to go into the ground right away, while next spring will be a better time to plant other stuff. Get a close up of the stone; matching the paint to it should make a major improvement. Can't tell what the front door looks like. Can you get better pictures?

I would paint the sections over the garage a color similar to the roof.

@decoenthusiaste Thank you for your comment! So when I say recent, I guess it's been a little over 6 months, time flies! Our neighborhood homes are all very unique builds from the 80's on very large lots so I'm not overly concerned with clashing as there isn't anyone too close to us but it's also hard to pinpoint a neighborhood "style". Many of them have the contrasting color outlining (which I'm not a huge fan of either), and a combination of materials: stone, stucco, brick, wood siding, etc. I'm holding off on the landscaping up around the house because we will probably be doing a major reno to the exterior and I don't want to worry about new plantings being messed up during that process. I have attached close ups of the existing door. Ideally we'd replace it with a double door and add some type of covered porch, though I've been told that would be tricky with the roof line (I don't have enough experience to agree or disagree with this). We've been toying with the idea of squaring up all the arches and going with some style of Hardie Board Siding instead of the stone/stucco combo to help update the overall look. Any thoughts on this or helping to add character to the house? I just feel like it's very blah and not the warm inviting look we're going for.

Here's an approach for the garage doors. Is there a bonus room above it? I think the addition of a window in the gable would help break up its volume. If you keep the triple bay window you might replicate it in the garage gable, or match the two windows if you change the main floor one. You could match the front doors to the wood garage doors to help unify the facade. If your foyer is dark you could use more glass in the doors. If not, you could use solid ones. The ones below fit a straight opening but add the arch that would replicate the garage doors. The bumpout triple window could also be done in a stained wood rather than white if you like.

Hideaway · More Info

Indian Hill Renovation · More Info

I don't think you need to do much, but a bit of strategically-applied paint will do wonders.

The things I think that are attractive about your house, that should be emphasized, are the stonework, the large gable, and the front door.

What should be de-emphasized (by painting them out) are the garage doors, downspouts, the too-small trim at the top of the stone gables, arches and dining room window trim.

I think you can do better than the gable trim I show below but I just want to give you an idea of accenting that large gable. Craftsman homes often have attractive gable trim so you may want to look at some examples to get an idea. Craftsman homes often have stone like yours too, and a subdued colour palette. The gray-green-blue in the lower picture might be a good colour for your front door.