I'd be careful of Moen. I have a Grohe in powder room -- it's been great. The only thing Rohl I have is a soap dispenser in my kitchen. I was told that it was one of the best (they do tend to be a problem sometimes) and they were right.I have had no issues with the soap dispenser! Moen faucets were in the house when we bought it new 13 years ago and I was happy to have the Moen name. But those faucets and shower fixtures have dripped and leaked and the finish chipped off -- awful. They couldn't be repaired. When we got around to replacing them in the Master bath we had to stay with Moen (which didn't make me happy, something to do with the valves in the shower and tub aren't interchangeable with other brands and too involved to switch out). But there are different levels of Moen and I do like the ones we have now. They've only been in the MB for a few months, though. So we'll see how they hold up. If you shop for Moen, don't go for the most economical. That Moen name doesn't necessarily mean what it used to.

I had a Rohl Perrin and Rowe bridge faucet in my last kitchen at my Shaw's farm sink. It was really beautiful and extremely well made. Sidespray held up well too. Don't know much about the Herbeau. They look fussier to me. But that's really the design and not the quality of the faucet. Is there a faucet you love? I'm looking at faucets myself now and feel like I'm all over the place. Can't even seem to narrow it down to a particular style. I thought I had...but then I hadn't.

Yes, itâÂÂs looking like I will have to go that route and start over. I have found several fairly reliable brands in faucets I like but not so much in the all-in tub wall mounts w/hand spray in the style I seek. Boy it does get discouraging learning that much of what was good is a bit dicey now in the plumbing fixture department. At least by picking separate components I will not be replacing a whole unit if something breaks. From what IâÂÂm reading most of this stuff is now made in China (even well-known brands) and to me grossly overpriced for the quality it is. IâÂÂll pay mid-high for something good but not something thatâÂÂs a pretty bunch of crap. I miss the old days when there were certain brands you could turn to and know what you were getting. Now itâÂÂs a maze.

I've got the same set up. I've got the Shaw's farm sink with the prep sink in the island. (I just bought the house.) The previous owner installed the Whitehaus Vintage III with two different spouts/spigots. While the bases of the faucets are exactly the same size, the spouts are different shapes. You might try that approach. There are pictures below. I am having to replace the Whitehaus cartridges because of a slow drip on both faucets. They are 10 years old. At least they are available. I spent hours trying to figure out what brand and design that had been installed. If it had been me, I would have selected a different arrangement. I prefer the single sprayer with a soap dispenser arrangement. The two separate hot and cold controls are extra motions. With the cross handles, I can never remember which way to turn them to turn them off. The lever handles might be better. The Shaw's sink doesn't drain well. It requires the use of the sprayer arm every time I do something. It's very deep and hard on your back. It's pretty, but I would rather have my old Kohler Strive single bowl with a grid. I do like the fact that the drain is in the corner. The ceramic finish seems to be holding up to time and use. At this point in life, I don't think anyone builds a good faucet. I long for the days when you could just stick a new washer in the faucet. I might suggest saving my money and buying something cheaper than the Rhol, Perrin and Rowe. Kohler, Moen and Delta actually have good warranties and stand behind them. Everyone else seems to be a reseller. Pretty, but flawed. This is the main sink faucet This is the prep sink The pictures are different finishes. As I said, maybe different spouts/spigots. Good luck with your decision.