Need help with exterior remodel!!

3 years ago

We’ve been working so hard to remodel our home and just as we are finishing up the interior renovations, storm damage has given us an opportunity to refresh the outside too! We are really torn on the color of our new siding and can use some outside opinions. Our house is originally white , sits higher than others on the street , and gets a ton of sun on one side. We also have an asphalt u-shape drive in front. After many Pinterest searches, samples and drives looking at other houses for inspiration we surrendered to white again thinking maybe the house is just meant to the “White House on the hill”. But we are having second thoughts, maybe we will regret not going for a change. With the sun lighting up half the house a lot of colors scared me away for fear or funky undertones, granite grey looked purplish etc. our roof is landmark weathered wood , and that’s on already, We are using certainteed restoration classic colonial white for siding. The other color we we are considering is slate. Total opposites yet we feel both give the neutral vibe we want without the risky undertones. We are also doing shake on the left side. I’ve attached pictures ...any help, even new ideas would be so appreciated. We were surprised our entire family liked the dark color, but maybe they just want a change :)

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (14)

PRO
Build Beautiful
3 years ago
Hi Jennifer Robertson,

Are those photo collages? Cool!

So you're house has an symmetry which gives it some cool character and opportunity. Usually a solid, single color makes a great statement. Here you have enough push & pull of the facade that a 2-color option might give it that missing flair you're looking for.

It would be interesting to play with a one color on the 2-story section and the, 'wings,' being another. Another option that makes sense it the 2-story section and entry door section being the same color and letting the other, 'wing,' fade away visually.

Either way, with what looks like a timeless taste in simple palettes - a bright entry door of either yellow or red would really pop and make the front look great.

If you have any more questions, feel free to message me here on houzz!

Thanks,

-frank

Build Beautiful
PRO
PPF.
3 years ago
I like the dark, and if using shakes, would use them for the entire exterior.
Related Discussions
Exterior Remodel Help Needed
Q
Comments (1)
It's difficult to offer design advice without seeing the house.
...See More
Need help with exterior remodel to make house rustic
Q
Comments (3)
What is your budget? Do you need space in your living room or do you want to bump out because you think it will help curb appeal? I like the porch, I would keep it if you don't need the space. The house has good bones. Your fireplace facade is rustic so I would take your cues from that. I would paint your brick one of the mid tone grays from the fireplace and I think that will go with your roof. I would think about getting a new, more substantial front door and adding some door trim to go along with your new porch railing and columns. Greyish weathered cedar would make a nice looking porch. Chunky orangey cedar is going to be harder to pull off with the brick and the fireplace and the roof. Are you keeping the front landscaping? It looks good in the photo, just needs some trimming up.
...See More
Need Help with Exterior remodel Advise? Please!
Q
Comments (2)
I agree, there is way too much brown. I am thinking about the following: 1. Have flat areas (gables) pitched to same as rest of roof 2. Repair and paint soffit, fascia, stucco trim boards and gutters a soft white. 3. Replace Windows with white vinyl. 4. Paint Stucco a smoky taupe color. 5. Redo the front porch roof to be pitched the same as the second story. I am working on a design and will post it soon to get opinions. Like Save
...See More
Need help! I'm unable to visualize any way to update/remodel exterior
Q
Comments (24)
I wouldn't replace the bay window for what will be a fairly small difference in appearance, unless it is otherwise defective. It won't be that noticeable if the trim is painted a less obtrusive color, and when there is landscaping in place so that there is something else to look at. It only stands out now because of the trim and lack of landscaping. It's expensive to replace a large window and that money would be put to better use on other changes.
...See More
littlebug zone 5 Missouri
3 years ago
last modified: 3 years ago
I also like the dark with the very light color trim.

(if those three round shrubs in front of those windows are imaginary shrubs, move two of them between the windows and throw the other one away).
Jennifer Robertson
Original Author
3 years ago
Thanks for the comments!! I am really thinking switching the plan to the dark color is the right choice. Shrubs are totally fake just playing around in photoshop, the patio is going in today and gable roof in back is after . I’d love to do all shake ! My husband thinks shake is just okay , so we agreed on an accent , our peak was too awkward . The other idea we had in the front was to run shake down right under the windows or the the entire middle section, like the first commentator mentioned, making that area stand out . Also a portico that matches the patio cover in back to help with character but had to cut that from the budget for now . In person it’s a tri level, pretending to be a colonial.
houssaon
3 years ago
I really like the dark color and I think a mix of shakes and lap siding would look good.
Fori
3 years ago
You're probably just tired of the white. Understandable! But the dark gray--while currently popular--has less staying power, especially on traditional homes like yours. The color works better on contemporary or MCM houses. On yours it runs the risk of being "That Creepy Black House".
PRO
Flo Mangan
3 years ago
You have a lovely home and I am sure you will love it when finished. I am someone who likes older homes to embrace their authentic style. Your new roof color is going to be informing your decision on siding color. Here are some inspirational photos. My biggest problem with your home is the lack of distinctive front entry. Have you considered creating a more interesting front facade? Even some awnings might help create some depth and dimension! Can you post actual current photos please?
PRO
Flo Mangan
3 years ago
I played with some ideas.
PRO
Flo Mangan
3 years ago
I took white arbors and front door facade from this photo.
PRO
Flo Mangan
3 years ago
A red door would help announce entry. Classic.
Jennifer Robertson
Original Author
3 years ago
Thanks Flo Mangan for the visuals! we really wanted a portico over the front porch , but had to cut that for now with the patio work taking a lot of our budget. I did think about some sort of awnings on the bottom half we have the same issue with the house looking too flat, but didn’t think they would work until I seen your mock up. That’s something to consider!
PRO
Flo Mangan
3 years ago
You can paint your door red. And perhaps add black trim. That would give definition to your entry until you can do more. That plus a flared stone walkway from steps of porch to your circular driveway which would also help.
RedRyder
3 years ago
The charcoal color is very striking. With a creamy trim and some interesting features added to the front, it could be the most interesting house in your neighborhood.
PRO
Celery. Visualization, Rendering images
3 years ago
I am on the white side. :-)))