Look at SW Lemongrass.

And yes, the floor must stay for now, although we may want to replace it in a couple of years. It's not perfect, but it's not ugly enough to be a priority at the moment.

OK, I looked at the online pics of the other colors that were suggested. I like the looks of the BM Pistachio and BM Parkside Dunes. The SW Lemongrass reads very beige on my smartphone screen, so I am doubtful that it will be what I'm looking for. So I think that I may order the BM Celery Ice, Pistachio, and Parkside Dunes samples.

I was just suggesting that when viewing the samples of paint, that you also put them near the flooring to see how they go colorwise. (even if down the road you do change the flooring, you just want to be sure it's not a fight with the current flooring).

I️ looked up Lemongrass on my phone and it does look beige. It is definitely green. Pics on phones and computers are definitely not true.

As salonva suggested, here's a pic of the current color samples near the floor.

pistachio!

I ordered 3 samples the other day from Samplize: BM Celery Ice, BM Parkside Dunes, and BM Pistachio. If past is prologue, I should be receiving them within the next couple of days. We'll see how those compare to the last batch. My husband thinks that I should use only Sherwin Williams paint, as our handyman refuses to use any other brand (and got SW to match the Valspar color I picked out for the porch ceiling), but I will be doing the painting myself and really prefer the Benjamin Moore greens so far. Anyone have an opinion regarding using Benjamin Moore paint vs. getting Sherwin Williams to match the colors?

I much prefer Benjamin Moore to Sherwin Williams. Most of our house (walls) is painted with either California or Benjamin Moore. I've personally only worked with Sherwin Wiillams on a piece of furniture. The piece took months before I could take the wax paper out of the doors or use it because it wasn't cured, and sometimes I still swear it's a bit soft. The equivalent product in Benjamin Moore had less smell, cured faster, and is rock solid.

Color matching can come out perfect or vary ... the bases are different, so they have to reformulate the color to suit their base (there are lots of ways to reach the same color, even between lines within a company there may be multiple formulas), and it will have some dependence on the skill of the employee how good they are at fine tuning to assure the match.

Thanks, BlueberryBundtcake!

so funny how different they look in different lighting! Now, according to the picture with them near the floor, I would say the middle one looks best, with the one on the right a close second. I don't think the one on the left works. (I think I offered the opposite opinion previously?!. that's why picking paint is maddening, especially per computer monitors).

Hey, all! The second set of samples arrived today! Here are this evening's photos. Top to bottom (or left to right): A = BM Celery Ice; B = BM Parkside Dunes; C = BM Pistachio. Thoughts on these vs. each other, and vs. the previous set of samples?

In this lighting, I'm liking Pistachio, but Celery Ice is nice, as well. Parkside Dunes would make a really pretty Easter egg, but I'm not sure I like it for your wall.

I agree with Blueberrybundtcake!

Can you compare the Bm light pistachio to the Pistachio?

To my eye Green Cove Springs is the best. pistachio looks like the closest match to the shower curtain and the green in the stained glass, but I think it would look better to have a lighter shade on the wall for a bit of contrast, instead of the shower curtain and painting matching the wall color and blending in with it.

Here's the Light Pistachio (top) vs. Pistachio (bottom). The Light Pistachio reads more blueish to me, and I am not as fond of it in my space as I am of the Pistachio.

Out of the first and second batches, my current 2 frontrunners are as follows (top-to-bottom): (A) BM Pistachio and (B) BM Green Cove Springs (pictures taken around 2:15 p.m.). My mom is partial to the former, which I also like, as it really does coordinate well; she doesn't care much for the latter. However, I am also considering the latter for its brightness & contrast (as per V Smith, who indicated that the Pistachio might be too matchy). I think that the Celery Ice is a little too bright-lime-green, the Lime Froth just a skosh too yellow, the Parkside Dunes just a skosh too blue, and the Light Pistachio also too blue. Opinions? Is there a clear winner, or should I order more samples? My mom has suggested the following colors: SW Supreme Green, SW Topiary Tint, SW Slow Green, SW Break Time, SW Waterscape, SW Relish, SW Easy Green, SW Kind Green, SW Aloe, and SW Hazel. Would anyone second any of those?

I've also read an article in which SW Ryegrass was touted as a "perfect green". Opinions there?

I wish I could help, but I’m awful with choosing paint colors. Hopefully, others will chime in! I’m just following along, enjoying the progress and looking forward to the afters. :)

I like the pistachio best in most of your photos. Not all, which isn't surprising with how much the appearance of the stained glass changes with the light. I also liked it best with your floors.

All of the SW colors your mom suggested are bluer than BM Pistachio, and most of them are a LOT bluer. From your various comments, I don't think that's the direction you want to go. Only Relish and Supreme Green are less blue than the BM Light Pistachio, and Relish is darker than BM Pistachio. No disrespect to your mom, but I don't think any of her suggestions will be winners when you look at them in your space.

BM Citra Lime might be one to look at. It's between Pistachio and Celery Ice in hue (closer to Pistachio), value is similar to Green Cove Springs, and the chroma is between Pistachio and the "bright-lime-green" Celery Ice.

SW Ryegrass is lovely but too yellow and too dark for what you are going for, I think. I'd describe more as sophisticated and earthy than dreamy and cheery.

That Citra Lime seems like it might work, but I want to order a sample. So to avoid postage charges, I'll need to find a couple of other colors to sample, too. I considered the SW Lemongrass, as Christine suggested, but all the pics I could find of it looked way too yellow, so I don't think that will work. Anyone else have any suggestions?

Maybe SW Lacewing? Others that look promising: Kelly Moore Echo of Spring (Kelly Moore is a regional brand, ignore if you don't have them in your area), Pratt & Lambert Green Whisper and Wisp Green, SW Gratifying Green, SW Gratifying Green.

OK, I've ordered the following: BM Citra Lime, SW Lacewing, and SW Gratifying Green. With any luck, this'll be the last batch I need to make my decision. Thanks, cawaps, for the suggestions!

Third batch of samples arrived today! Here they are, top to bottom, (A.) BM Citra Lime; (B.) SW Lacewing; (C.) SW Gratifying Green. Interestingly, the Lacewing & Gratifying Green don't look all that different to me in person, but in pictures, the Lacewing looks much drabber.

Here are the colors in the same order, left to right, above the tub:

Here are the colors in the same order, left to right, next to the floor:

The first pic you posted today by the window is too dark to see anything at all ( at least for me). I think looking at the next 2 photos, either of the other 2 work for me. IF you can do one by the window with some light on might get better opinions. (NOT an expert here, so will defer to others but thought I would opine).

Thanks, salonva! Here's a redo of the first picture -- this one taken around 7 p.m.

LOL - Apparently my posts on my new cellphone are not syncing with my account here. It's asking me to thank myself for my post above!

Here are the 3rd batch colors at a different time of day (2:20 p.m.):

Top to bottom: SW Gratifying Green, SW Lacewing, BM Citra Lime.

Can you take out Lacewing (to my eye, the loser in this new batch) and replace it with Pistachio from the last batch?

I like all three of Citra Lime, Pistachio, and Gratifying Green. I'd probably go with Citra Lime, but I have a demonstrated track record of choosing vivid greens. I think Gratifying Green would probably have broader appeal--but you only need to please you, not "everybody."

Thanks, cawaps! Here's (top to bottom) SW Gratifying Green, BM Pistachio, and BM Citra Lime. I agree that the Lacewing, while close to Gratifying Green, is less appealing, probably because it has a tad more grey. I think that the Citra Lime is just a smidge too vivid for my space. My mom likes the Gratifying Green. I think that she's right. It's got just the right amount of lightness and brightness to perk things up without overwhelming the space or upstaging the stained glass.

Oops, I forgot to post the photo!

I think any of the three would be a winner at this point. Gratifying Green sounds like it's in the sweet spot for you. Don't forget to come back and show us the final result!

I think Gratifying Green is a great choice for all the reasons you listed!

Hi, all! Here's a picture of the paint job. I love the new color! Thanks to all for your input!

That looks great, Elaine! You all chose well! 😍

Hubby has bought a new wood-look toilet seat to replace our current wooden one and better coordinate with the new wooden toilet paper holder, so I expect that he will install that soon.

When our handyman comes, I will ask him to repaint the woodwork (the same white), as it does need it (I was comfortable DIY-ing the walls, but the woodwork is outside my comfort zone). Maybe in a couple of years it will be time to change the floor (also a project for our handyman). I am still on the fence about replacing the current "boob light"; I may just leave it, as it's inoffensive (to us, at least) and inconspicuous enough not to upstage the stained glass.

I am considering a couple of luxury items. The master bathroom in our previous house had an oversized jetted tub that I miss, so I am thinking about getting a bubble mat or a spa-jet attachment to allow myself to enjoy tub therapy again. Also, I am considering adding a bidet attachment to the toilet for less-toilet-paper-intensive hygiene. Any recommendations for (or advice against) either?

Here's the "boob light", in case anyone wants to weigh in on that.

The popcorn ceiling will stay for now, although they may be changed eventually. We will soon be having some of our other popcorn ceilings covered in beadboard by our handyman, but that's currently on hold due to the coronavirus.

Lovely!

Color looks great!

I'm not bothered by the light. Unless it's giving poor light or you've seen something you like better, I'd say that it's fine. As you said, it's not the star of the room. I'd be more looking at replacing what I'm assuming is a vent ... it stands out due to its color and looks kind-of old.

Have you used a bidet before? It would be something I'd want to try before installing if you haven't already ... make sure it's something you'll want to use enough to make it worth the install.

When you have your handyman there next, you might want to have him look at that spot at the end of the vanity counter ... it looks like there's a small gap between the wall and counter edge.

Wow that looks soo nice!!! Enjoy it!

Thanks, all! I really love the color, which makes the bathroom feel much more uplifting. I am gratified by Gratifying Green.

BlueberryBundtcake, I think that what you're talking about is the vent fan. It's kind of loud and probably old (house was built in 1985, and we are the 3rd owners), but it's functional. I was glad to have it while painting, to keep the paint fumes at bay.

Also, you have a good eye, BB; there is, in fact, a small gap between the wall and counter edge. I know that the previous owners did quite a bit of DIY, which may explain that little imperfection. It looks as though it would be easily remediable.

I have used a bidet on a couple of occasions. Although hubby has been good at ensuring that we never come close to running out of toilet paper, I know that virus-related panic has made toilet paper harder to come by this year. That, along with my conservationist inclinations, has me thinking that a bidet might be a good idea. There was, not too long ago, an article in Consumer Reports that compared different bidet attachments, but I am curious about the experience of my fellow Houzzers.

The paint looks fabulous! I'm so glad all the effort you put into making a choice paid off!

Boob lights are much reviled, but I have a lot of them (my unit was a rental before I moved in). I keep looking for replacements, and I'm just "meh" on most flushmount and sem-flushmount lamps. I haven't found anything I like well enough to go to the effort of replacing them. So I'm in the same boat as you on that front, and certainly won't offer you or your boob light any criticism.

Thanks, cawaps! The only alternative light I found about which I could get excited was a cream-colored Tiffany edged with green, and I was advised that it would compete too much with the stained-glass window piece.

BTW, cawaps, your cat avatar is gorgeous!

I will let Arizona know you appreciate her feline beauty!

Today I enjoyed a candlelit bath in my newly painted bathroom. In doing so, I noticed what appear to be paint splatters from the previous grey/greige paint (much more obvious by candlelight). Now I am considering whether to tackle them myself or save it for my handyman's next visit.

Also considering what to do about the vent fan. I asked hubby what he thought of it, and he agreed that it's loud but doesn't seem to be gung-ho to replace it. I think that it's ugly, but that doesn't bother him at all. So I wonder whether it could/should be painted white to blend in better with the ceiling and, if so, whether that's something I should attempt on my own or add to the list of tasks for the handyman.

Still on the fence about the bidet attachment and wondering whether anyone here has experience, pro or con, with one. Also wondering whether anyone could recommend in favor of or against any particular spa jet attachment or bubble mat.