Building a Home Remodeling Design Dilemma

Remove chimney and move electrical, or design around them?

3 years ago

I had great response from my first question, and it sent me back to the drawing board. Now, more questions!

The first picture is the current floor plan. In the bathroom, we are looking to incorporate a closet into the bathroom's sqft, but there is a RAG and non-functioning chimney that are in the way. The other space is currently an awkward hallway and a long, skinny laundry room. It was originally a bedroom and we would like to return it to a bedroom by taking down the interior wall dividing the hallway and the laundry room. The problem is that a small electrical panel was placed in this wall.

Our primary goal for these rooms is better use of space in an economical way. The second picture is a design that avoids the cost of removing the chimney and moving the electrical box, but it makes some compromises to do so.

This is only one part of a bigger renovation, so we need to keep the budget on these rooms in check. Would our money be better spent working around these things, or are the compromises so severe that we should we consider the cost of removing the chimney and/or moving the electrical panel?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

BlueberryBundtcake - 6a/5b MA
3 years ago
I think the big compromise here is that the bedroom with the electrical panel in the closet doesn't actually have a closet, it has an electrical room. You can't block the panel, so they can't really hang clothes or store things in there. I'm not sure if it's even technically a bedroom; you could certainly use it as a bedroom either way, but it may not be valued as one. It could work as a guest room, since most guests don't usually put their clothes in their clothes in the closet, but you'd probably need to provide a hook or something for a suit, dress, jacket, or whatever that really needs to hang and not fold.

Where would you move the electrical panel to, if you were to move it? I'm not seeing a convenient and obvious spot in the vicinity. It could be pretty expensive to move, as it needs to be near where the power comes into the house, and if it moves too far, you may not have enough slack and need to rewire a bunch of your house.

I dont think the chimney is a big issue, and it may not be fully removable (or at least be exorbitantly expensive to do so) depending on what it's attached to (furnace?) and what it's made of (masonry or metal). I'd probably try to just work around it.

On a separate note, I would skip the jack and jill bathroom design. If you really need that bathroom, pick one bedroom to connect it to. The hall bathroom is right there and makes more sense as the shared bath, since it's bigger and has a bigger vanity, and jack and jills can be awkward with the two doors. If you don't need that bathroom, it could be cannibalized for a useable closet for the bedroom with the panel.
Corey
Original Author
3 years ago
Thanks blueberry. The Jack and Jill is part of the existing floorplan. I had considered using it as a walk-in closet for this bedroom, but the budget won't let us touch it.

The chimney is masonry. I'm not sure of it's original function. It's currently walled over on all sides and only visible from the attic.

There isn't a convenient or obvious place to move the panel, which is why I'd prefer not to. This house actually has 3 different panels, and the other two are currently in closets. One electrician said he would just put the panel on the bedroom wall and hang a picture over it!
Related Discussions
how to decorate around an old chimney...
Q
Comments (2)
Guess I didn't describe it well and I am camera challenged !! There is a sheetrocked wall that is 10ft high. We have a mantle ( standard size) with a tiled surround that we had done 3 yrs ago when we had the iron cover taken off of the opening and new chase put in and a Valor gas coal glass front stove put in. Look like a small oldfashioned cook stove..heats very well. If we remove the sheetrock you can see all the brick chimney up to the ceiling...problem is it isn't as wide as the mantle...so as in a traditional house where you have a wall of face brick that matches the size if the mantle and then walls to R and L we would have to use old brick from another chimney to widen this one to make it "fit" the mantle....just seems like WAY to much as I type this...any ideas....they will be here in 5 minutes !! THANKS I always love your posts.
...See More
Help - best way to ensure no leaking around chimney??
Q
Comments (28)
"Thoughts on best approach for re-work of siding/flashing greatly appreciated. Have heard that it might be best to cut into the brick and attach step flashing." Best way (my opinion) to attack the chimney/asphalt shingle area is with flashing and counter flashing. The flashing is typical step flashing. A piece of metal bent 90-degrees, one leg gets fastened to the roof deck with each course of shingles and the other leg runs vertically up the side of the chimney, floating (not secured) against the side of the chimney. The counter flashing covers the vertical leg of the flashing that is floating against the chimney. A groove is cut in the mortar joint and an edge of the counter flashing is inserted into that joint, held in with soft metal wedges, then the gap is sealed with sealant. The counter flashing is folded down to cover the flashing. It's a 2-piece flashing system where the two pieces move independently of one another. Here's a reference drawing to better show what I was trying to describe. When flashing a chimney, it's best to use a durable metal; typically copper or lead, or lead-coated copper. Something as durable as the chimney itself. If using aluminum, a thicker stock is more durable than the thinner gauges sold at most box stores. Your cricket or saddle? Due to the geometry I prefer to not shingle them, but they can be, especially if larger in size. Small ones are typically wood framed and completely covered with metal. Probably the most common slap-dash chimney flashing is simple single-piece step flashing that is "sealed" to the side of a chimney with several tubes of pookey. That is not the way to go.
...See More
Need Floor plan concept software that lets you move whole rooms around
Q
Comments (16)
I have a tremor, so can't use a pencil etc. I used Live Home 3D app to design my house. It worked out great. However..... I couldn't handle the 3D mode. I used 2D only. I also found that it helped at the very beginning just to use the rectangle/square tool (with a color for each room) to make rooms and then drag the rooms around, change sizes, etc. Once I got more or less what I wanted, I used the tools for wall thickness, etc. to fine tune. I used this tool also to figure out a layout for my kitchen, cabinet sizes, etc. If you do a lot of versions of your house in Live Home 3D, I would recommend creating new sheets (files) frequently. Rendering for design changes can be slow and bog you down: the fewer versions on one sheet, the better. IIRC I created a new file every 2 weeks or so. Once I had my plan more or less, I handed the plan over to the "designer", who put it in her CAD software, made corrections, did zoning compliance, inserted electric, etc.
...See More
Best way to tackle framing around an old chimney?
Q
Comments (4)
We, too, live in an old house. Please do not rush in changing the structure and the charming quirks of your home. Visit other old houses in your area and see the original features. Take your time . We cherish the unlevel floors, the 72” high doorways in the oldest portion of the house, the old fireplaces. Do not let anyone who doesn’t love , love, love old house work on your house. Yes, we have indoor plumbing, air conditioning, and electricity, but always in a respectful way to honor the house. Spend your time researching the history of the house and the families who lived there. I am doing the genealogy of our house and it is fascinating. The man who built it owned the sawmill that sawed the framework. He loved to race horses, engage in politics, and raise a family of six children. I spent several days on Newspapers.com to discover the history of the second family, the family that bought the house in 1927. The newspaper had stories of bridge parties and dinner parties and college graduations. One day, a meeting of 48 women were meeting here and planning to have luncheon “on the pleasant lawn” when weather intervened and the luncheon had to be served indoors “ on small tables.” When a son serving in the Navy brought his bride home, his parents entertained with a reception at home, “vases of roses” decorating all the rooms. I have a huge notebook of these clippings. The 11 year old son of this family was so smitten by the history of this house, he became a renowned restoration architect in New England. We have original wavy glass (1803) in our original windows, (please do not replace your windows with vinyl), we have hand planed walnut doors on our cupboards, we have working fireplaces. Embrace your history and your unique opportunity to preserve something special. Slow down and make reasoned, thoughtful decisions to become guardians of history.
...See More
acm
3 years ago
Maybe it's just me, but I can't map those two images onto each other at all...
Corey
Original Author
3 years ago
The orientation on the two images is the same. The current floorplan image is the grey section on the remodel plan.
BlueberryBundtcake - 6a/5b MA
3 years ago
acm, it took me a bit to figure out how the two work together ... I think the new vanity is ending up in the closet behind the current toilet and vanity, the linen closet to the left of that is becoming part of the bedroom, which is a combination of the hall and the room above it (wall removed), and the new toilet is in what was the closet between the tub and the chimney.

If you can't touch the jack and jill, maybe just close off one of the doors? That's usually just a matter of removing the trim and door and adding drywall.

Is the chimney maybe attached to your furnace? It doesn't necessarily have to be directly adjacent to it to service it. Our furnace flue goes sideways for a while across the basement before it goes up its chimney.

I thought about the panel a bit more ... if you flip it onto the outside of the closet, facing into the bedroom, then the closet could be used as a closet. If it's painted the same color as a wall, they're not that obvious, particularly on a wall that's similarly sized to the width of the box, or you could go with the electrician's suggestion of putting art on the door.
Corey
Original Author
3 years ago
"acm, it took me a bit to figure out how the two work together ... I think the new vanity is ending up in the closet behind the current toilet and vanity, the linen closet to the left of that is becoming part of the bedroom, which is a combination of the hall and the room above it (wall removed), and the new toilet is in what was the closet between the tub and the chimney."

Yep! That's it.

Moving the panel to the outside is a good suggestion, thank you. With the closet there, do you think there is enough room to get around the bed?
BlueberryBundtcake - 6a/5b MA
3 years ago
Well, you've got 8.5' at the overlap of the closet and bed, 5' for a queen bed leaves 3.5' of walking space to split between the two sides. It should be workable ... pinch point on the closet side looks like it would be about 10" long, though it is access to the panel, so you wouldn't want to cut it too tight ... I'm guessing that closet is about 4' wide and using existing walls, so I don't know if it would be practical to consider shrinking it to give more space to reduce the pinch point.

Remove chimney and move electrical, or design around them?

Comments (7)

BlueberryBundtcake - 6a/5b MA

Corey
Original Author

Related Discussions

acm

Corey
Original Author

BlueberryBundtcake - 6a/5b MA

Corey
Original Author

BlueberryBundtcake - 6a/5b MA

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Remove chimney and move electrical, or design around them?

Comments (7)

BlueberryBundtcake - 6a/5b MA

CoreyOriginal Author

Related Discussions

acm

CoreyOriginal Author

BlueberryBundtcake - 6a/5b MA

CoreyOriginal Author

BlueberryBundtcake - 6a/5b MA

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Corey
Original Author

Corey
Original Author

Corey
Original Author