No advice? Probably we should stick with the original color... Looks like the lighter colors might not look good for this type of siding... especially in the full sun.

If you want to keep the green trim, you could paint the white part a pale sage green. You already have a complementary color scheme, and so that limits you to red + green, or you could switch to a split complementary scheme, but that would probably get too busy. If you get rid of the green trim, then you have more options. The green part could be painted black or gray instead of white and still have more options.

The color consultant didnt take your brick and roof into consideration when she/he looked at your house. I love the color they picked but, not on your house. Take a good hard look at your brick, keeping your roof color in mind and pick out a color from your brick, and try a sample of that on your house. I wouldnt do the corbels, because your house isnt a craftsman, and they just wouldnt look right. However, I do think your choice of new door is much better than what you have now. The door you have, just does not seem to fit the house. You have a very nice house.

We are redoing the paint and stain on the entire exterior of our house. We have old Chicago Brick and and new dark gray roof. Looking at using Benjamin Moore paint and TWP 200 series for the stain. Would love ideas!!