Do you shop at Costco or Amazon? If so, you might want to check out the Calphalon Quartz Heat Countertop Oven. Right now, Amazon has it for (IIRC) $190. The online Costco site is asking $200 (shipping included) but it might be less at the warehouse stores. I paid less when I bought mine at the local warehouse store. Last time I checked, our warehouse had it for about $160. (FWIW, I happened to buy mine with a coupon that took the price down further).

I bought mine as an interim stop-gap. My range's oven failed right before a big holiday weekend gathering and, due to holiday madness, the replacement part would not arrive until the Monday after the gathering. I was able to carry on using my gas grill for large roasting jobs and the Calphalon for everything else including smaller bread loaves and flatbread/pizzas. I found the Calphalon and most countertop ovens are not tall enough to handle the rise of a two-pound loaf in a standard bread pan, but did fine with a one-pound loaf. FWIW, the Calphalon seems to get good marks for temperature accuracy and comes with a 12"-diameter pizza pan . The pizza pan is very thin metal. I found the trick to making pizzas in the Calphalon was preheating the oven with a couple of quarry tiles on a rack for about 20 minutes or so before putting the pan and pizza in on top of the tiles.

The Calphalon has some limitations on broiling because there are only two oven rack slots and the upper position is relatively low compared to the upper rack positions in higher end models like Breville's Smart Oven. IIRC, Cook's Illustrated faulted the broiler for being slow as a result). I found the way around that limitation by placing a spacer pan upside down on the top rack and putting the broiler pan on top of that. to get the food closer to the top heating elements. All in all, I was pleasantly surprised by how well the Calaphalon works and have kept it as a second, small oven. It also makes good toast, albeit more slowly than my toaster did.

If you are willing to spend more than $200, there are some better countertop ovens including the Breville Smart oven that Jim Mat mentioned. Cook's Illustrated (January 2020 issue) reviewed Countertop Ovens for 2020 and liked the Breville Smart Oven best followed by a De'Longhi Livenza model. Wirecutter very much likes the Breville although not as much as Cuisinart Chef's Convection Toaster Oven. Other reviewers do not like the Cusinart's control interface. (I tried it, but found it too annoying for me as well as being over-my-budget for a stop-gap oven. YMMV.)

Jim Mat and jwvideo, thanks for the suggestions! Much appreciated.

I have poopooed the Breville in the past. It's ok, but I had the door spring fail and illumination go out. Really low end stainless steel for the price. Never polished up well. Size was versatile, but quality not great.

Consumer Reports has ratings of toaster ovens costing from $35 (not a typo) to $400. (https://www.consumerreports.org/join - $10/month digital). You can set the search criteria to include models of the size (e.g., 12"+) you require.

I have the Cuisinart Chefs Convection Toaster Oven and I love it! It fit quarter sheet pans and can fully bake, roast, broil, etc. I use it as a second oven at the holidays and in the summer it is the main oven, since it doesn't make the kitchen as hot the regular oven in the range. My kids use it all the time as well, super easy to make small batches of cookies, cupcakes, & small pizzas (it comes with a 12" pizza stone). I have had mine for about 2 1/2 years, no problems with it.

wddcruise and kiniyagirl, thanks for the information. It's appreciated.

Breville, sold the first one to my sister to purchase the newer (bigger, more options) one. Think the first one was about $225 and I loved it but the newer one has a dehydrate/rising dough function the first one didn't have (although it was more expensive). I don't have a stove or a 'regular' oven.

The Breville Smart Oven I had was fabulous (and I only got rid of it to replace it with a combi-steam oven, and I still miss it sometimes). They should be close to your budget.

Breville, have had mine for 10 years this fall.

I have an Instant Pot Omni Plus Air Fryer Toaster Oven and it's life changing! This toaster oven fits a frozen pizza, can airfry, reheat, convection, keep warm....etc. There are a ton of online recipes for this and similar toaster ovens or airfry thingys. The best thing is airfried chicken wings (use baking powder...yup!) and you'd think they were deep fried in oil. Amazing.

You can get this oven on Amazon for under $200 and it almost has a 5 STAR rating with almost 500 reviews. Click Here for the Instant Pot Omni Plus Air Fryer Toaster Oven

The Kitchen Place, boba1, Toronto Veterinarian, new-beginning and TBL from MA,

Thanks for the information. It's appreciated.