Seeking some Design Advice for Stair Renovation
Hi Everyone,
We finally decided after owning our home for 5 years that it was time to paint the upstairs trim and the trim going up our staircase white before we replace the carpet upstairs later this year. In addition, we will be painting the walls upstairs and up the staircase a light grey as well to move our 1970s house into the 21st century.
Since it will be a bit complicated to paint the trim white up the stairs (it is a lot easier to temporarily pull up carpet in our hallways upstairs than on the stairs), I decided something needed done with our stairs. Yesterday I checked some various steps and confirmed the hardwood goes all the way up to the top step, but is currently covered with carpet. That immediately made me want to plan to remove the carpet up the steps and utilize the hardwood floors.
Doing so brings up some design issues I am hoping to get some of your feedback on...
1) Since my trim will be white and my walls a light grey, will my currently brownish stained stair treads look a little off color wise next to white and grey?
2) I am a bit hesitant to paint the stair treads, but would certainly be open to painting the risers white, the same color as the trim going up.
3) I also planned to paint the spindles white, but then again that led me to the question of what to do with the handrail going up the steps, as well as the banister. Would doing a slightly darker stain on the banister and handrail (perhaps an almost brown/black gel stain) that is different than the steps look odd? Would doing a semi-gloss black of these items clash too much with the brown steps, white trim and grey walls?
I like to have concrete plans before I do anything, so figured I'd turn to some of you for your thoughts. Any help would be greatly appreciated. I am honestly open to any suggestions.
Thank you in advance!
Comments (6)
Katie B.
3 years agoI like the warmth of the wood
I think I’d leave the stairs alone and only paint your door trim, baseboards and walls
can you take a photo of the landing at the top of the stairs?
penguin330
3 years agolast modified: 3 years agoHello everyone! So just an update on this project. I painted all of the upstairs trim white and the walls grey and it came out very nice. Now I am moving on to the stairs. I tore out the carpet and padding yesterday which went a lot smoother than I expect. Took less than 90 minutes as there was no tack strips and the staples came out very easily. My original plan was to stain the treads with a gel paint and paint the risers white.
However, as you can see on these pictures, there is a white substance on each of the treads and on some of the risers. Initially I thought this was some sort of adhesive for the carpet/padding, but it is really smooth to the touch. Nonetheless, I tried sanding it and it made it smoother, but it did nothing to remove the white. As a result, my wife and I are on board with painting the risers white, but now painting the treads black which we have seen on various websites across the internet. We think it will look good with the white trim and grey walls.
BUT.... Before I go about painting anything on these steps, I wanted to at least ask to see if anyone has any idea what this white substance may be? I want to make sure I address it before priming and then painting these treads.
If anyone has any idea what it may be and what I may need to do to get rid of it (to some extent), please let me know. Also, if you think simply sanding it to make it smooth with the stained portion and then painting over it will work fine, please advise.
Thanks in advance!
Related Discussions
Renovation Novice Seeking Advice, Pretty Please
Comments (11)Sounds like you have a lovely project. With any of the dark finishes I like to have integral metals -- not coated finishes though some are very good. Rocky Mountain Hardware makes bronze in several different tones and their quality is tops. I've used them in two homes now and while some of their styles are stylized they have a Mushroom Knob (p 2 of the knobs) in a coppery bronze that I just love. They would be gorgeous with black, as you'll see. I've ordered them from Cape Cod Brass twice now and used CC for all my hardware -- they have a range of other good brands. Re F&B, I've worked extensively with their paint and it's my go-to brand for interior work. Depending on location, the Farrow's Cream can look like a parchment yellow or much more aggressively egg yolky. Alternately House White is very warm as is New White, which has an umber undertone and White Tie is an elegant ivory. Love their coatings, great to work with and the color complexity is terrific. They hold up beautifully and while people color match them that loses the complexity of undertone in paint with 8-12 pigments when color matching with only 3-4. Only 1 other paint has a similar surface quality in the matte (Estate Emulsion) finish and I really appreciate the effect on old walls. If there are plaster walls in your home you will see that most. I love a pull down faucet and Rohl has dark finishes in some of their styles though their bridge faucet is classic. Good luck with your choices! Would love to see the exterior paint job you mentioned if you feel like posting a pic. I so respect restoration and preservation of our visual heritage. Here is a link that might be useful: Rocky Mountain Hardware...See MoreSeeking advice on 1915 foursquare kitchen renovation
Comments (14)Thank you so much for all the comments! In answer to the questions, - We have thought about a prep sink, and plumbing anywhere is straightforward because we're over a basement. But we have a second house with a similar setup and a prep sink, and we never use the prep sink, it just gets in the way. We are thinking about adding an undermount prep sink that could be covered up with a cutting board if we wanted to. - Unfortunately, we're pretty limited to the space we have. The original footprint of our house has 100 year old heart pine floors throughout and our historic district regulations wouldn't allow a massive reconfiguring. We don't mind the space limitations, we're an old house people, just want to be sure what we have is well planned-out. - We have seen what the brick looks like and it's great. The chimney was originally exposed in the kitchen of the original house and the former owners covered it with a soffit when they remodeled the kitchen. - I know there is no space on the left side of the range, but if we get the 48" range, I would have a griddle on the left hand side, and the griddle cover would serve as a staging area. That said, not having a staging area on that side (esp. because I'm right handed!) is a big concern. This has given me plenty of food for thought. I'm going to think today about putting a second oven in on the window wall. dyhgarden - I also like your idea. It would make a lot of sense to have the range on the window wall, and we could definitely add a second window instead of widening the window (window work can't be done until next year anyway so we have plenty of time to adjust the plan). I'm worried the range would be in the way on that wall, though. But I think I'm a little scarred by having a cooktop peninsula on the hallway side that forces a bottleneck in that walkway. Here's a larger layout with hopefully readable dimensions:...See MoreExterior Design Dilemma Seeking Facade Decor / Improvement Advice
Comments (10)You are a dare devil for chopping off the deck on your split ranch, and I love it. I just had a blast scribbling on your house too! Your last inspiration pic gives you a great spring board. Focus on creating new squares and rectangles that align with and distract from your current windows. Create a shallow trellis around the first floor doors - center the left on the middle of your 2nd story triple doors, and center the right on the middle of your 2nd story double windows. Make an iron railing outside the second story doors, a very shallow balcony the same depth as the trellis and line it with some pots of greenery. Make a rectangular hedge around the patio to give more geometry for the eye to focus on away from the wall of the house. Add in ground trees on the left, with some heft. Towards the middle and right go for tall evergreens set in urns, mixed with some shorter ones. Something else needs to happen with the second story far left window and far right double windows. Not sure what....See MoreLooking for some advice on a kitchen renovation. Different finishes?
Comments (0)So, finally diving in and doing a kitchen renovation. We decided on a cabinet that is in our price range. Also did a little custom designing in the kitchen. We are looking to do the island, and all lower cabinets one color(rift oak, winter finish) and all the uppers a maple wood Alabaster finish. Personally, I think it will look great, My wife has a visualization issue whereas she ideally would like to see it in person. Thoughts? The picture below is from the designers program, Colors are not exact. TY!...See More
Jennifer K
3 years agolast modified: 3 years ago
bat7
3 years agopenguin330
3 years agoSo I forgot to update everyone. I ended up painting the walls grey, the trim white, the handrail black, and after sanding, painting the stair treads black (Behr Porch and Patio) and the risers white. It came out much better than I even expected!
I still need to put some sprt of trim at the bottom of the last riser where it meets the tile FWIW.
Rs S