Houzz Logo Print
samkarenorkaren

Movies Being Pulled

6 years ago

I just read that HBO MAX is pulling Gone With the Wind from their library because of racist overtones. I for one have enjoyed watching it over the years. I'm now curious to what other movies will be pulled.
SamKaren Your resident dj

Comments (49)

  • 6 years ago

    Glad I have that movie on DVD. I think it will disappear forever.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    As a teen, I remember hating that movie (so much overblown acting!, and I wanted to slap the major characters on a multitude of occasions) but loving the book, which I read about a year after. In the book you got the nuances and motivations.

    However, it should NOT be pulled. Whether I liked it or not, it is a classic in filmmaking history.


  • Related Discussions

    Think my tomato plant will survive being pulled

    Q

    Comments (7)
    Tomatos can put new roots along the stem if planted deeper. It might also be a good idea to mist the leaves or place a transluscent plastic shopping bag over the plant for a few days to keep it hydrated if it wants to wilt.
    ...See More

    how stupid can I be? going to pull up pretty plants

    Q

    Comments (82)
    Just to throw something else in here on how ignorant we as Americans are and how with out question we will buy and consume products just because we trust the source or we just do not care. Thankyou to those concerned about this issue who have posted here. I am proud to be a certified Organic grower therefore I want nothing to do with GMO for me, or my familiy ,or my customers. The link below is an article on GMO potatoes. I tried to find another article about a law suet with Mcdonalds but I couldnt'. Bottom line Mcdonalds and Burgerking have been serving GMO potates for nearly 10years in America till it came to light thanks to concerned groups which sued. Mcdonalds as a settlement in the suet to squash the issue before it became too public decided to stop using GMO potatoes rather than have a public backlash. If it were not for those who are concerned you would still be eating GMO potatoes. GMO potatoes that contain a herbiced tolerant gene (roundout) and a bacterial pesticide(BT). It is one thing to spray or coat our food with a toxin. I use BT the organic natural bacteria. But I at least have the option to wash most of it off, But to put that same pesticide in each and every cellof the plant I intend to eat I can not handle. I have not eaten at any national fast food chain in over ten years and am proud of that fact. I also will not and have not shopped at any big box store in nearly two years. I will not be a hipocrit and say one thing and do another. I want to know what I am feeding to my grandchild and family and I want to support my country by buying American and local grown food. and products. Rodger
    ...See More

    How long should the bar pulls be?

    Q

    Comments (11)
    Disco: Going through this same dilemna...think I will have two different pull sizes and one knob that matches. I have looked at so many kitchens and each one uses a different style. I am also looking at where on the drawers they are mounted. I have shaker cabs so is it on the top rail? In the exact middle? where????? On the glass uppers, is it where the rail starts 1/4 of the way down, 1/4 up? Where? What are you thinking?? I think I will use tape too and mock them up. The counting and decision of knobs/pulls is another tedious task...44 I need in all. From Menlo Farmhouse This big?From Menlo Farmhouse Down here?From Menlo Farmhouse Which one?From Menlo Farmhouse
    ...See More

    oldbat2be - what did u use to temporarily affix pulls??

    Q

    Comments (8)
    Thanks for the feedback lgiorgi. Is blue painters tape strong enough and how would you do it? Sorry, I'm just not picturing what you mean. See link to pic of what oldbat2be did - it's towards the end of the post (sorry, don't know how to just grab oldbat2be pic to put in here). Here is a link that might be useful: Temp affix pulls - towards end of post
    ...See More
  • 6 years ago

    I adored the book and enjoyed the movie. It’s a classic. Let me be clear that I am anti racism, strongly against police brutality and appalled by the political climate of our country. However you can’t erase the past. “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” The book and the movie depict a time in our history that was real. Rather than erase it, let’s learn from it. Of course the movie was overly dramatic. If this movie is pulled where does it end? Every movie that depicted gay people in a bad light? Every movie that depicts women poorly? I am against censorship.

  • 6 years ago

    I agree. That movie is a classic and should be left alone. Shame on HBO. When i first read about it being pulled my first thought was the movie Trading Places would probably be pulled.

    You're right dedtired...I too am against censorship.

    As I was in radio for years I remember the controversy about songs that were not considered suitable (remember the warning labels?)


  • 6 years ago

    Think about how many schools and libraries have banned To Kill a Mockingbird.

  • 6 years ago

    Gone with the Wind is also incredibly sexist. And classist. But that was also “of that time”. If I recall, the book even made some comments about Katie (was that the mother’s name?) being Catholic.

  • 6 years ago

    It’s my guess that the movie, Gone With The Wind, will not disappear forever. It’s likely to come back with an introduction that will act as a history lesson for viewers. Removing it from the lineup for awhile is a good thing.


    I remember when it came back on the big screen in the early 70s. People who had read the book and were too young when the movie was first released were excited to be able to see it.

  • 6 years ago

    I am against censorship in any form. I have no problem with a historical introduction.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    HBO is temporarily removing GWTW from their schedule.

    The movie will return to the platform with a “discussion of its historical context and a denouncement of those very depictions,” an HBO Max spokesperson said in an email to CNBC on Wednesday.


    Also available on Prime video--The movie isn't going anywhere. Who knows how many millions of copies of it have been made.

  • 6 years ago

    "you can’t erase the past. “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” The book and the movie depict a time in our history that was real. Rather than erase it, let’s learn from it."

    a ton of those out there protesting / rioting know little of our history. They only know what those higher up have told them in order to incite them. They've probably never heard of that quote. There's more behind what is going on that most people think.


  • 6 years ago

    Erasing or burning all the books containing facts of our History, etc., doesn't make it go away. Just

    turns the anger somewhere else and causes more and more unrest in a

    different direction by different people. Why destroy everything that

    refers to, for instance, General Lee...learn from the bad things, not make

    him more "interesting" to the future to find out why he was "banned" and

    his statue destroyed. This begins the cycle all over again. If "To Kill

    A Mockingbird" is actually read, anyone with any intelligence or reading

    ability at all should know that it is about a good cause...why on earth ban

    it? Because it was too early in the fight? I honestly never knew what

    got twisted in those minds of the "banners". Atticus Finch was a good

    man, and worked to show it....(fiction, of course...but a sign of the times,

    for sure).

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    A movie that I enjoyed more was 'Shenandoah'--about the Civil War, but no frustrated romance, and I don't recall racism, just sadness; I was a child the first time I saw it, and I remember crying at several scenes. Even if there was a romance involved, I'd take Jimmy Stewart over Clark Gable any day. I share artemis' urge to slap the man.

    I almost always enjoy the book more than the movie; if I've read the book first, I'm always disappointed that the actors are not how I imagined the characters. Exception is 'To Kill A Mockingbird.' I saw that as a child, read the book as a teen--loved them both, although, of course, I had a better understanding of the plot when I was older. I'm sure if I re-read it now, I'd understand things I missed before.

    The movies should be available, as a historical record and teaching tools.

  • 6 years ago

    Holiday Inn -- because of the blackface "Abraham" song for February. It wasn't shown at Christmas for a long time because of that and just came back 3 or 4 years ago -- if you didn't record it last year, and if it's a favorite, you might not see it again for a while.

  • 6 years ago

    Elmer Fudd won't be carrying a gun in future cartoons.

  • 6 years ago

    Yosemite sam either.

  • 6 years ago

    I'm perfectly okay with keeping guns and other violent conduct out of cartoons and TV shows intended for young audiences.

  • 6 years ago

    It’s insulting to people’s intelligence. Who watches anything without being aware of the time it’s depicting.

    Film wise it’s not my cup of tea.

  • 6 years ago

    "It’s insulting to people’s intelligence. "

    That's true for people who have intelligence. Sadly, too many don't and that's my concern.

  • 6 years ago

    I too am against censorship. The very idea that anything old is ‘bad’ and was made with ill intent is ridiculous. It was a different era, and GWTW and any other movie depicting any race, gender or whatever in a bad light could be viewed similarly and condemned if we start down this path.

    Too many high school kids already are protesting the Holocaust being taught in school because it makes them ’feel bad‘. Really? Sorry, suck it up and learn why it happened and the context. You don’t need all the gory details and photos to get the general idea of what happened, where, and why.

    What has happened to our old friend, common sense?

  • 6 years ago

    ‘That's true for people who have intelligence. Sadly, too many don't and that's my concern.’


    I’m not comfortable accommodating censorship for less intelligent people, or as some would say, dumbing down. I’m sometimes concerned that people have become overly sensitive and I’m not sure that’s altogether healthy.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Why not use the movie to honor the black actors who appeared in it? There were some wonderful performances.


    Desertsteph, I have to disagree with you. The young protestors have minds of their own and aren’t be led by the opinions of others. Change often begins with the younger generation.

  • 6 years ago

    The first Oscar to a black actress, truth about sexism/race/class...do we really want to forget from where we have come? I was always told that is why we teach History--to prevent mistakes from being repeated....Censorship is dangerous... but I guess it isn't or shouldn't be a decision made by whites..some of this we have to give over to those that time hurt. As a poor white woman I am ok with the portrayal...a black person will have to let us know their take.

  • 6 years ago

    If the world was perfect wouldn't it be grand 😏! I so agree with you Maddiemo.

  • 6 years ago

    LadydI, in pursuit of a perfect world I fear a lot of people may wear themselves out way too young and ultimately become unable to deal with life’s ups and downs.

    My sons at Uni and the tales he tells of the virtue signalling intimidation tactics should anyone have the slightest difference of opinion is concerning.

    Liberal they are not.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Too bad you think differences of opinion get explained or rationalized away by ascribing them to what you assume to be a particular (and what you assume to be polarized in lockstep) political orientation. I don't find many Conservatives to be particularly conservative or thoughtful. So what? It shouldn't preclude discussion and understanding, except for those too invested in following prescribed opinions who feel uncomfortable considering anything on their own. That applies to people of any political persuasion and or holding any viewpoint. But especially at the current time among Republicans. But the trend is changing, many have hit their limits in tolerating incompetence of leadership.

    PS. I'm not a Democrat and in the main I'm not all that liberal (except on social matters). So, please don't dismiss my views with a label.

  • 6 years ago

    Okay, don't get me wrong - while I disliked that movie, I am firmly against censorship.

  • 6 years ago

    Too bad you think that’s what I’ve done Elmer.

    My point is if the youngsters at my sons Uni are shutting down anything other than their prescribed view of a perfect world they are not being liberal.


  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Our newspapers here in Northern Canada were asking why they weren't getting more responses in their opinion section. Surely they must know that ones life as they know it could be ruined completely by not having the same opinion as what's considered by some to be correct. Just look at the shaming that goes on here by some people. I don't feel most people 'really' want opinions that differ from theirs.

  • 6 years ago

    Sorry, couldn't resist! LOL

  • 6 years ago

    Angela HaHaHa 😁😁😁!!!

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    "My point is if the youngsters at my sons Uni are shutting down anything other than their prescribed view of a perfect world they are not being liberal."

    Is being "liberal" in all things an ideal you think all people should strive for? Otherwise, I think the sense of your comment was quite clear, you seemed to have intimated that you expected someone with politically "liberal" views should conduct themselves in a more liberal way or otherwise was being selectively hypocritical. That wasn't what you were saying?

    "Youngsters" who don't find value or importance in opinions they disagree with and who are "shutting down" are imitating the conduct they see among adults of both polarized political parties these days.


  • 6 years ago

    Liberals are the least tolerant--in this new age version. The PC police has been ruling thought/speech/TV FOR YEARS, and yes it is most evident in the University setting..

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Oh my. Fox News is on.

    But thanks for demonstrating what I said in my last paragraph just above.

  • 6 years ago

    Is being "liberal" in all things an ideal you think all people should strive for?


    Elmer, I’m realistic enough to know that an ideal is not possible because my ideal would not be the same as another persons.

    The only thing I can think of as being anything approaching an ideal is balance and compromise. That requires acceptance of some fundamental differences on both sides.

    Liberal to me is an acceptance that everyone is different. If people are being shut down and intimidated, it’s concerning, and not an atmosphere I would expect in a place of learning.

    Yes I do think there’s a great deal of hypocrisy in these people’s mindsets, but I don’t know which political party they align themselves to. They could well be from different ones. It’s more about whichever particular cause they’re promoting at any one time that I think is more the issue.

  • 6 years ago

    It's a loaded word and a pejorative to some, sorry if I missed if your use wasn't that. I'm still not sure but see arcy's comment as a clearer contrast.

    If you want to know the political leanings of the intolerant people your son is encountering (a word with less baggage), consider the color of the state he's in (red or blue). If it's a state school that's a good indication. If a private school but one without a fundamentalist orientation, maybe not.



  • 6 years ago

    Elmer, I’m from the U.K.

    Sorry, I should have mentioned that, but as we discussed puddings a while back I thought you may have remembered😁

  • 6 years ago

    Ok, sorry. Some of our closest English and Scot friends are from the UK too! Some are still there! ;-)

  • 6 years ago

    I think the issue with GWTW is not so much its depiction of slavery as its romanticism of the lifestyle and its plotline of the brave South stuggling to maintain that abhorrent lifestyle against the evil Yankees who took it all away.

  • 6 years ago

    Well, Colleen, the book was written in the 1920's & published in 1936 by an author who was born, raised & lived her entire life in Georgia. The movie was released in 1940. Knowing that, why would you read the book or see the movie? Try to imagine how your own aboriginal population might tell their story.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Not every Caucasian born and raised in the South in the early 20th century, and even later, was a racist or wanted to glorify slavery. Though far too many were and are.

  • 6 years ago

    The Bible condones slavery, and so I guess you should not read that either. I certainly don't.

  • 6 years ago

    Considering the violent, curse-filled, tasteless dreck that is shoved at us today, I find any fuss made over GWTW to be funny.

  • 6 years ago

    Good point Lars. I hear there’s some pretty grim tales in it and it’s certainly not PC in some of its thinking.

    I guess it’s another example of being a product of the time it was written in.

  • 6 years ago

    LOL different kind of slavery all together and to say it 'condones' slavery is showing your ignorance of what the message of the TOTALITY of the bible is..but lets not deal in FACTS.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    We got us a bunch of white people on here discussing an experience we KNOW nothing about!! Heard a great pod cast yesterday comparing the Plantation to the internment camps of Nazi Germany--that was how Black people experienced the time of GWTW...puts a different light on it!! His push was to take the romanticism out of the Plantation tours prevalent in the South and tell the WHOLE story. The family in GWTW appeared to be kind and did not treat their slaves with torture/rape etc...maybe that is part of the problem--it isn't a TRUE depiction? We need more specific information on their objections.

  • 6 years ago

    ci_lantro, I'm not sure why you're getting all huffy with me. I am well aware of the background of GWTW and its author Margaret Mitchell (btw, I am a US citizen) but I can see why there might be objections to it and was pointing out that I think it's not just about slavery per se. One could make the same case for one of the Hitler Jugend writing a book about how wonderful life was in Germany in the late 1930s until the awful Allies defeated those gallant German troops and changed their whole lifestyle.

    Another part of the issue is that while most intelligent and thinking people would look at a book like GWTW in its context and be aware that the South wasn't really like that, but sadly half of the population is below average in intelligence (think about it) and of that proportion many would look at GWTW and its ilk as historical fact and use it to bolster an underlying feeling of injustice against the South and resentment towards those they perceive as "responsible" for this.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Just a comment on the various quotes about 'not erasing history' ... try inserting the words "white people's" and see how it can give a different flavor: 'not erasing white people's history.'

    I saw GWTW once, in high school maybe, and have no desire to see it again because of the sexism. The racism was so ridiculous (to me) that it didn't bother me. I am interested in the commentary HBO is developing to accompany future showings. It's a tricky thing to get right. If they aim it at us in the year 2020, will they have to update it again as the decades go by (and hopefully improve)?

  • 6 years ago

    Colleen, I misinterpreted/ took literally when you said: the brave South stuggling to maintain that abhorrent lifestyle against the evil Yankees who took it all away.

    I think the issue with GWTW is not so much its depiction of slavery as its romanticism of the lifestyle and its plotline of 'the brave South stuggling to maintain that abhorrent lifestyle against the evil Yankees who took it all away.'

    I see now you mean that phrase to mean 'quote/ unquote'. I completely agree with your Hitler Germany example.


    but sadly half of the population is below average in intelligence (think about it) and of that proportion many would look at GWTW and its ilk as historical fact and use it to bolster an underlying feeling of injustice against the South and resentment towards those they perceive as "responsible" for this.

    You've gotten into tilting at windmills territory there. :-)


    Here's Roger Ebert's 1998 take on GWTW movie (with an interesting dimension re: women): https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/great-movie-gone-with-the-wind-1939








  • 6 years ago

    LOL different kind of slavery all together and to say it 'condones' slavery is showing your ignorance of what the message of the TOTALITY of the bible is..but lets not deal in FACTS.

    Amen arcy! most don't know the whole of it and don't want to know... they've heard bits and pieces but don't know the why of those bits and pieces.