skip to main content

Design Dilemma Paint Building a Home

Siding Suggestions

3 years ago

last modified: 3 years ago

I'm looking for siding and trim suggestions for my house. I like the idea of LP Smartside, but can't decide on a color. I love the look of stained cedar and think it would fit in our wooded setting, but I'm concerned about maintenance. Can you guys sell me one way or the other? :) Here's a current photo to get an idea for the setting and the plan showing the modifications (existing brick will be gone). Windows have been ordered and are dark bronze if that helps narrow anything down. Thanks!!!

Featured Answer

PRO

Mark Bischak, Architect

3 years ago

All brick with vinyl shingles in the gables.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

kanliker
Original Author
3 years ago
Thanks for your input! I'm not sure what brick does to the budget, but it's something to keep in mind! Husband might be a tough sell on that one though.....
Related Discussions
Your siding color suggestions for this little house?
Q
Comments (28)
We rarely get updates on planned projects on GW but I'm thrilled to present one now! We started the process in April 2017. He was understandably reluctant to accept help for months, but we assured him his numerous nieces and nephews wanted to help. We donated money, helped tear out the overgrowth and hired reputable contractors to replace all the windows, put up vinyl siding, new shutters, new doors and storm doors. He is so happy about the changes and has accepted our help. We guided him but he chose to keep the brick and he chose the colors and even the door style. (He likes yellow but immediate neighbor has yellow siding.). We took small steps but ever forward, encouraging him, assuring him and thanking him for the generosity he has shown all of us for 50+ years. I've said before he is a dear and inspiring man. Here are a few before and after pics. Front porch will be replaced this month as weather allows. Thank you all for your great advice and kind words.
...See More
Gutter/ rain creating mildew on siding any suggestions
Q
Comments (4)
For fungus stains, the classic cleaner is chlorine bleach diluted with water. I might try adding a little powdered laundry detergent. I've cleaned those kinds of stains (and just about all others) from vinyl siding with trisodium phosphate dissolved in water. However, I think TSP is either banned or regulated in some states. Either cleaner can be applied with a scrub brush on a long pole, and rinsed with a high pressure garden hose. Wear protective clothing and goggles. Trust me, you don't want to get that stuff in your eyes.
...See More
External siding color suggestion Harbor Blue vs Platinum Grey/Storm
Q
Comments (5)
Thanks for responding. Attaching the pictures of both Harbor Blue and Platinum Grey with Storm Shake. This is Naperville, IL. Not much woods as this is a new subdivision.
...See More
Ideas for mindfully updating this 70s/80s contemporary home?
Q
Comments (11)
We just went with a highly reviewed local "general home maintenance" (how their website describes them) company. They're licensed, insured, & bonded and offer a one year warranty for work. They were wonderful to work with, honestly, and the price was very reasonable in my opinion. No, our siding is cedar bevel / clapboard. Before/after pics attached. They removed the rotten pieces and replaced them without damaging any of the the original siding that was still in good shape. They checked for any damage to the original underlayment when removing the siding or mold. Much to my surprise, they said everything there still looked great so didn't think any more work was needed than just the few damaged/rotten boards. You can't visually tell where the work was done, it blends in seamlessly. We also had them replace some rotten trim around the clerestory windows. They painted the new trim and siding boards with a paint we color-matched within a few days. However, I believe cedar siding doesn't actually need to be painted or treated (pros can correct me if I'm wrong) so I wouldn't think it's an issue if you don't paint right away.
...See More
lizziesma
3 years ago
Do you have woodpeckers? Use wood siding and they’ll love you.
kanliker
Original Author
3 years ago
We don't have any right now, but it is on my list of concerns with cedar. Someone told me if you put out feeders they will leave the house alone...???
PRO
Mark Bischak, Architect
3 years ago
When evaluating brick, factor in the maintenance that does NOT have to be performed over 100 years.
User
3 years ago
last modified: 3 years ago
The new reversible order and duplicate posts is very irritating and confusing. The best answer feature is silly.

Smartside is aspen wood waterboard with a paper facing. It relies on a preservative to keep it from rotting. The cut ends are very vulnerable to water so good installation is critical. The paint must be maintained like any other painted finish.

Cedar shingles dipped in stain require very little maintenance and will look fantastic on this house even as they age. Don't use a second cladding with the shingles and let them wrap the corners (no corner boards). I would not consider any other cladding for this style house.

The wide casements may have hardware problems unless they are well made.
PRO
Creative Visual Concepts, Kevin Strader
3 years ago
There are some companies that do faux cedar siding. You may want to take a look at them. One of them is Allura. You could do charcoal for the trim. If you're interested in seeing virtual finishes on your home check my website, Creative Visual Concepts.

Related Stories

LIFE Inviting Kids Into the Kitchen: Suggestions for Nurturing Cooks

By Alison Hodgson

Imagine a day when your child whips up dinner instead of complaining about it. You can make it happen with this wisdom

LANDSCAPE DESIGN 6 Suggestions for Harmonious Hardscaping

By Jay Sifford Garden Design

Help a sidewalk, driveway or path flow with your garden design, for a cohesive and pleasing look

HOUZZ TOURS Houzz Tour: Nature Suggests a Toronto Home’s Palette

By Annie Thornton

Birch forests and rocks inspire the colors and materials of a Canadian designer’s townhouse space

LIVING ROOMS Double- and Triple-Sided Fireplaces Offer Countless Benefits

By Samantha Schoech

They can divide an open layout, blur indoor-outdoor boundaries, warm a modern look or just your toes. Is a mutisided fireplace for you?

GARDENING GUIDES How to Turn a Side Yard Into a Glorious Garden Room

By Debra Prinzing

With just 8 feet or so, you can turn a plain side yard into a garden that lets you get carried away

GARDENING AND LANDSCAPING 8 Splendid Side Yard Designs

By Debra Prinzing

Treat your skinny side yard like the beautiful green corridor it wants to be, with these verdant garden designs as inspiration

GARDENING AND LANDSCAPING 10 Ways to Make the Most of Your Side Yard

By Becky Harris

Don’t overlook the possibilities for this often-forgotten space

MOST POPULAR 25 Ideas to Perk Up Your Side Yard

By Becky Harris

Turn this often overlooked area into an enticing and useful outdoor space

LANDSCAPE DESIGN How to Tap the Potential of a Big Side Yard

By Debra Prinzing

The expanse is a chance to design something that's grand yet inviting and in tune with the home

REMODELING GUIDES 9 Top Siding Materials

By Bud Dietrich, AIA

Everyone knows brick and stucco, but what about fiber cement and metal? Learn about the options in exterior siding before you choose

Sponsored

Buckeye Carpentry & Renovations

Industry Leading General Contractors in Pickerington

More Discussions

Color ideas for a house with red brick accents or covering brick?

4

Please help me choose exterior paint colors ASAP!!

12

Need help to break the plainness please!

11

opinions on two tone exterior

1

I finally found a solution to what BM color matches Andersen white

0