Would you do Mirrormate or individual mirrors?

I would change the light fixtures, the mirrors, the window treatment, wall art and paint. The best ROI for resale is spending very little when making your changes.

Thanks! Any suggestions for style of light fixtures and paint color?

Start with a budget. How much are you willing to spend to enjoy the bathroom for the next 2-4 years that you will not get back when you sell? Light fixtures (4 at $200 each), mirrors (3 at $200-$500 each), new window blinds (2 at $100-300 each)? Professional painting? Then make your decisions.

@apple_pie_order Our budget for the bathroom is $5k. With your estimates we definitely don't have the budget to change the vanities or countertops. So my focus will be on picking a paint that best brings together the wood vanities/granite countertops/and white greyish tiles. Next selecting the lighting fixtures and mirrors that update the space as best as possible. For paint I was considering soft grey but would that be too dull? Or a blueish grey and/or green but not sure if that outdates it more. Any thoughts?

You might want to check locally for places that reface cabinets, since converting these to a more standard white cabinet with modern doors would change the look quite a bit. From there I would go to individual mirrors in front of each sink, and new sconce lighting on the walls instead of lights over the mirrors.

If you refaced the cabinets you would still have the lower "ladies make-up" area in the middle, which is a very old style for a vanity. However, I still see new cabinets with this stepped design, so maybe its coming back.

Bruce

Spend the money on bathroom sconces next to each of the two mirrors you plan to get. I would get the functional vanities professionally painted a pale gray, get gorgeous framed mirrors, and high end lighting. Repaint in a soft white that has a hint of pink in it.

Don't change the vanities. They seem to be in good shape. All the drawers work? The cabinet doors are secure? Maybe just paint them white (or whatever you do to cabinets to get them a different color).

I don't have any objections to the mirror at all, but those lighting fixtures have gotta go! The overhead light, too. I would maybe put smaller lights the entire length of the mirror.

Then, I would add some "portable" luxe. A plug-in towel warmer. A posh new shower fixture (reinstall the old one when you're ready to leave?). Plants. A regular bouquet of fresh flowers.

I agree with changing the mirror to two mirrors and adding bathroom sconces. I'll definitely look into painting the vanities as they are in great working order I just feel everything is very mismatched but not in a cool eclectic way.

I agree with most ... leave the cabinetry. Wood tone seems to be coming back in style - so maybe it will be perfect at the time you move. What is the style in the rest of the house? It's hard to give suggestions on fixtures and mirrors without knowing ...

I would leave cabinets. I like big mirror instead three ones. I would get silver frame for mirror and paint light gray walls. I would get full length runner instead individual mats. And yes transitional lights above the mirror.

The house was built in 1999. There is a lot of wood throughout the house but the bedrooms and stairs are carpeted. The kitchen has a similar color in the cabinetry with black granite and is in keeping with that Tuscan-inspired vibe. I had originally wanted to redo the kitchen or at least have the cabinetry painted white but the cost just kept creeping up so in that project I am just changing the backsplash to white subway tile, adding a hood exhaust over the oven instead of the existing microwave, and painting the walls. We recently redid the master bedroom and it has a dark blue painted wall (Benjamin Moore Old Navy) and the bottom is wainscotting in Chantilly Lace with a four poster bed and heavy oak furniture (I will post a photo later).

Something like this but lighter gray vanity.

Soothing Charmer | Bath Remodel · More Info

You don’t necessarily need to change the size of the shower but I would change out to frameless. I would leave the vanity, it’s lovely, paint change mirror and light fixtures.