skip to main content

Wellborn vs Kraftmaid cabinets

4 years ago

Looking for recommendations in longevity? Trying to be budget conscious but would like this renovation to be long lasting.

Featured Answer

PRO

User

4 years ago

last modified: 4 years ago

1. Don’t confuse Wellborn with Wellborn Forest. Different companies, sorta the same family, but estrangement and other issues might as well have them be strangers.

KM and WB each have different levels of price and quality within their fold. If you are Comparing KM Vantage to the lesser specified WB Premiere or lower, and not their top Estate product, of course WB’s price will be lower. It isn’t a valid comparison. KM Vantage is a great mid to upper mid market line that has almost as many customizations as do some “custom” lines. WB’s Aspire frameless is a stepchild among them all, and doesnt really receive the support that it deserves. KM has no comparable frameless lines, or inset. That is KM’s market lack.

WB is an odd company, and does some construction techniques differently that results in issues that they do not view as problems. They also refuse to use white oak, and only use red oak. They also penalize sellers for warranty claims or miss ships that every other company routinely assumes responsibility for and takes care of. That’s just a few among other idiosyncratic and borderline company behaviors that wouldn’t make it in a publicly held company. Because it is a family held company, they choose to create their own world.

Their Estate quality is good, if you can design around their issues, but overall, I choose to not work with them due to their other issues.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (11)

salonva
4 years ago
I will be curious to see the replies. I know they are both good- but I suspect Kraftmaid is considered better.
Nadine thanked salonva
Nadine
Original Author
4 years ago
I would love to hear from folks who have chosen either of this companies cabinets. What was your experience ? Did your cabinets hold up well.
Related Discussions
Mullet vs. Wellborn Cabinets
Q
Comments (0)
I am in the cabinet selection process for my new build home and have just received pricing back for custom Mullet cabinets in the kitchen and Wellborn Select cabinets in four bathrooms, pantry, laundry, wet bar. All will be painted. I am currently $8,000 over my allowance. The builder's designer said that if I go with all Wellborn cabinets including the kitchen, I will be $3000 over my allowance. I am wondering if this is worth the compromise. I will be looking at the Wellborn cabinets in a house tomorrow to see if I am happy with the quality and look. The designer keeps telling me that the Wellborn cabinets are maple doors but when I look at the Wellborn website, it appears that the Select series if MDF doors. I am okay with going semi-custom instead of custom in the kitchen but I want wood doors, all wood/dovetail soft close drawers. My other thought is that the factory finished Wellborn painted cabinets may hold up better than the painted finish on the custom cabinets. Thoughts from the group on whether saving $5000 is worth giving up the Mullet kitchen?
...See More
Kith Cabinets vs Wellborn?
Q
Comments (2)
@baseballmom94 Who did you end up going with and what was your experience? My designer is recommending Kith or Shiloh for my bathroom vanities. Just curious your thoughts on what you actually decided on. Thanks!
...See More
Medallion/Schuler Cabinets vs. Dura Supreme vs. Kraftmaid
Q
Comments (26)
Yelena, Although, my kitchen reno is still a work in progress and I can't speak on purchasing an ENTIRE Schular Cappuccino Cherry Kitchen Cabinetry, I'll be happy to share my experience. So far, I can say that I have compared prices, as well as, quality between Yorktowne, Medallion and Merillat Masterpiece. Hands down, Lowe's Schuler Cabinetry was/is the best savings for the same good quality. If I had the budget, need or desire to replace all my cabinetry as part of my Kitchen Renovation project; I would 100% recommend Lowe's Schuler Cabinetry, Cappuccino Cherry! Not to mislead or steer the topic; But my experience with Schuler's Cherry Cappuccino was/is somewhat limited to a fortunate mistake as a result of replacing my old appliances: Which was always part of my original kitchen renovation plans and budget; Including, my backsplash and countertops. In lieu of, keeping my 18 year old Yorktowne, Solid Maple Cabinetry because. my cabinetry was/is in great condition. Asides for the "Spice" stain color, I still love Yorktowne's "Hallmark/Ambrosia" door style and the amount of time spoke for the quality and my experience, By happenstance, my new appliances (Microwave & Oven) didn't fit into my old cabinet space. So, I was force to address the "Spice" stain now that I had to order a new "face front" cabinet. Which ultimately meant, I would be paying to populate the stain color that I never liked or compromise my design and new appliances. Which I felt lead me towards having the best of both worlds; Two-Tone Cabinetry (Paint and Cappuccino Stain) aka: a "fortunate mistake" because Schuler's "SAVANNAH" matches Yorktowne's "Hallmark/Ambrosia" Door Style perfectly and the Cappuccino Stain coordinates well with my new Cafe Matte White and Brush Bronze Kitchen Appliances! Now, if I can only get a response from Rob regard the flooring he used with his Cappuccino Stain Cabinets, Hope this was helpful,
...See More
Kemper Echo vs Wellborn Cabinet Help!
Q
Comments (1)
Standard Kemper, sure. It’s mid grade. Not the lower spec Echo. Unless you’re doing an entry level home. Wellborn nothing, ever.
...See More
salonva
4 years ago
I would love to hear as well..... hoping someone who can speak firsthand sees this
Barb
4 years ago
We did kraftmaid cabinets in 2011 in our kitchen remodel. Honestly they look brand new today and I use my kitchen heavily. Not a single issue with them but we did go top of the line with options. They are a dark brown cherry (I believe they called them antique chocolate maybe). No complaints here.
Nadine
Original Author
4 years ago
Thanks Barb ! I am looking at Kraftmaid Cherry as well with all plywood construction. I need to make a decision soon . Wellborn has a curved cabinet that I love and it makes the flow in the kitchen look so good. Struggling to decide if the quality is in Wellborn.
Cocotini Hartman
4 years ago
Although I haven't had Wellborn cabinets personally, I recently was looking at a 9 year old house that had a Wellborn kitchen. The glazed finish was perfect, no chips or rubbing, drawers all closed perfectly. All the doors were pristine. Either nobody cooked in that kitchen, or the cabinets had held up extremely well.
Nadine
Original Author
4 years ago
Thanks so much ! We cook often and hope this is the outcome for us as well.
kirbybunny7
4 years ago
Crazy! I am between the two at the moment as well. Waiting on Wellborn pricing but have been impressed with Kraftmaid Vantage specs and price. Here is the sample door I ordered - hickory with a praline stain. Let us know what you decide!
Nadine
Original Author
4 years ago
Interesting ! And not a piece of story that I have heard. I did know WB is a family owned company . I have looked at several cabinets but am unsure if I like them as well as the KM. The issue is two different kitchen stores, 2 different designers . WB has a cabinet that I love. Just the shape of it. Am not so sure I can get it from KM. Overall , I want quality and longevity at a fair price. Do you have a cabinet that you feel is a quality piece ?
User
4 years ago
last modified: 4 years ago
Dynasty by Omega is a better built choice than either, with more customizations. And not a big price increase either.

Related Stories

KITCHEN CABINETS Choosing New Cabinets? Here’s What to Know Before You Shop

By Ventana Construction LLC

Get the scoop on kitchen and bathroom cabinet materials and construction methods to understand your options

EVENTS The Latest Looks for Cabinets at IBS and KBIS 2020

By Erin Carlyle

White and wood finishes dominated at the trade show, but companies also displayed black, blue, green, gray and more

KITCHEN CABINETS Painted vs. Stained Kitchen Cabinets

Wondering whether to go for natural wood or a painted finish for your cabinets? These pros and cons can help

COLOR 7 Sophisticated Blues for Your Kitchen Cabinets

Complement a white or neutral room with cabinetry in deep navy, blue mist, cobalt, teal, turquoise and more

KITCHEN STORAGE Kitchen of the Week: Bamboo Cabinets Hide Impressive Storage

By Carol Crotta

This serene kitchen opens up to reveal well-organized storage areas for a family that likes to cook and entertain

KITCHEN CABINETS Kitchen Cabinet Color: Should You Paint or Stain?

By Ventana Construction LLC

Learn about durability, looks, cost and more for wooden cabinet finishes to make the right choice for your kitchen

KITCHEN CABINETS Your Guide to Choosing Kitchen Cabinets

By Vanessa Brunner

Updating your kitchen? See designers' top choices for kitchen cabinet styles, hardware choices, colors, finishes and more

KITCHEN DESIGN 11 Great Alternatives to Glass-Front Cabinets

By Laura Gaskill

You may just break up with glass when you see these equally decorative but less fragile cabinet options

INSIDE HOUZZ The Most Popular Styles and Cabinet Choices in Kitchen Remodels

By Erin Carlyle

Transitional remains the No. 1 style as farmhouse loses steam, according to the 2020 U.S. Houzz Kitchen Trends Study

HOUSEKEEPING How to Clean Your Kitchen Cabinets

By Leslie Reichert

Learn the techniques for keeping stained, painted and laminate cabinets in tiptop shape

Sponsored

More Discussions

Nuage Quartzite - any water issues?

16

Omega cabinet shaker door outside edge profiles

2

Kitchen remodel in my future

9

I am working on the kitchen of an investment house we are refurbishing

1

What are these above my cabinets?

10