charcoal would look very nice. I dont think the wood stain on the garage door would look so great though. I would do it charcoal too, so it blends in with the house. Just choose your charcoal carefully, so it doesnt look blue when you are finished with it.

I agree with cat_ky about keeping the door charcoal. I would do away with the shutters. Hard to see front door. Is it black? Then work on the landscaping, the ball bushes need to go

Darker paint is just going to emphasize the thoughtlessly pasted on fake stone. Having more of a blend in value deemphasizes that awkward design error. Leave well enough alone.

Greendesigns the stone is actually real stone. The house was built in 1958. Although I don’t love it. I appreciate the effort they made. But you’re suggesting a lighter color?

The shutters are hurting, not helping. Would be nice to have a more defined walkway to the house but that's a big undertaking. I'd look at beiges, a color from the stone, which I think is very pretty. Cool looking house, put the $$ into landscaping.

I like the stone. Looks like bedford from what I can see without a bigger picture. I do think the darker gray would look good, if that is what you are wanting, however, I dont mind the color it is either. I do think you could add some color into your landscaping and some better light fixtures. Some of the shrubs look a bit overgrown and then have been trimmed in a rounded type shape, rather than kept to a smaller size. I might look into replacing them, with something else.. Some big pots with flowers in them, would make it look more welcoming.

This color scheme might work for your stone.