I'm glad you enjoyed it! She is truly talented.

I was disappointed in the movie and thought it was over-hyped. I didn't find their love storyline believable, nor her accommodation of his alcoholism. The whole thing was just too contrived for me. Perhaps after all the reviews, I expected too much.

But her voice... wow.

That was my reaction too when I saw it Jasdip. I went in to it thinking "eh, we'll see"...but was blown away.

I watched it during our travels this summer, mostly due to the previous discussions here. Gaga did a find job. It mostly made me want to go back and watch all the previous versions. I have seen the Kristopherson/Streisand movie and only remember being TOTALLY confused by the entire thing.

I've never paid much attention to her, and haven't seen the movie. But I watched a video of her performing with Tony Bennett, and I was awed.

I felt the same way, Jasdip.

I loved the movie and I love Gaga (and Cooper too, oh be still my heart).

I need to find a copy of the very first A Star Is Born. Then I can say I've seen them all.

I loved the music and acting....hated the ending...now I hate the movie as well. I think Bradley Coopers character should have fired Gaga's agent, managed her career and lived happily ever after...sober and teamed up.

When I heard her perform the national anthem a couple of years ago, she gained my respect as a talent. Just about the best, most respectful rendition I have heard in decades, certainly the best by a popular singer. I hadn't heard her before then.

Bradley Cooper did a great job, too. GaGa credits him for her fine acting which says a lot about his directing abilities, too.

I thought the movie was very well done, and Lady Gaga was superb. But the Judy Garland/James Mason version is still my favorite.

She was amazing.

Gaga did a great job but overall I found the movie disappointing.