Graywings - I suspect you are right. I am probably agonizing for no reason. I don't think cream will work as the storm windows are white. Also it will take a VERY long time to re-do all the trim. Windows need re-glazing and only the 3 attic windows have been done. It would take years before it all matched! In my subject line "exterior paint" turned into "exterior pain". How true .. I wonder why the BM website gives "complemetary colors" which are often not white. When white is the most common trim color. Maureen

Red brick with navy blue siding and the same color trim (or darker) would work.

(no, none of those your mentioned would clash w/your windows. I've linked quite a few articles for you to read. give them a shot first, and then come back if you have questions) Here's a color review on Dorian Gray. she favors Pure White and High Reflective white for the trim. https://www.kylieminteriors.ca/paint-colour-review-sherwin-williams-dorian-gray-sw-7017/ Have you ever read any of Kylies articles on exposure and paint colors? very interesting. here are a few you can peruse https://www.kylieminteriors.ca/exterior-painting-4-things-to-know-before-picking-a-colour/ https://www.kylieminteriors.ca/the-best-exterior-paint-colours-why-your-homes-exposure-matters/ scroll down to where she talks about East facing homes. SO, HOW DOES EAST-FACING LIGHT AFFECT PAINT COLOURS ON THE EXTERIOR OF A HOME? East-facing morning light is bright and will make paint colours look MUCH lighter than they will in the afternoon An east-facing afternoon will look an AWFUL lot like a north-facing one in that it gets NO sunshine and no shadows. It’s also similar to a west-facing morning light – flatter than a pancake In the afternoon, east-facing homes can look more shaded – more like they do on the north-facing side (or western morning) With east-facing light being tricky, you’ll want to pay attention to the LRV that you choose. This way, you can land on an LRV that doesn’t wash-out too much in the morning, but also doesn’t look too heavy in the afternoon. https://www.kylieminteriors.ca/paint-colours-and-lrv-the-ultimate-guide-to-choosing-the-right-colour/ https://www.kylieminteriors.ca/how-to-pick-exterior-paint-colours-in-5-easy-steps/ https://www.kylieminteriors.ca/sherwin-williams-best-gray-greige-paint-colours/ this link is all gray paint colors that she talks about. pay attention to the undertones and the LRV https://www.kylieminteriors.ca/page/2/?s=gray+exterior+colors

Similar to Emily's suggestion above I would start out with trim colors that are more similar to the hue your brick. You can either match one of the colors in the brick or go a little darker or lighter. This will give your house a consistent look that I feel will most likely subdue the red undertone. Contrasts have a good chance of playing up the red tones in the brick. The raw yellow color of the trim is showing you this right now. Going more gray or cool than the brick will likely do the same thing, playing up rather than playing down the pink undertones. A green might work by theory of complimentary colors, but you would need to try out a few to see what happens.