The Kohler Memoirs Classic Comfort K-3818 and Kohler Memoirs Stately Comfort K-3819 are both recommended toilets by Consumer Reports based upon their similarity in design to the Kohler Kelston K-3754. Note that these are all "comfort height" -- which I personally despise.

We have a Kohler Memoirs and I find the flush underpowered. However, ours is 10-12 years old, so they have probably improved the mechanism.

Personally, I don't think it really matters if the lines on the toilet complement the mouldings. That's like saying the bridesmaid dresses at a wedding need to match the tablecloths. I don't really agree that a toilet can be more or less "formal." You should just get what you like and what fits the space.

I installed a Kohler Memoirs Stately last fall. I was trying to keep close in style to what would have been original to a 1920's house. I've had no issues with it and really like the look. I paired it with the matching pedestal sink.

We built in early 2000 and used a whole house of Toto toilets because that’s what everyone raved about. They were one piece toilets except for the powder room which was a 2 piece. The 2 piece one was the only one with a decent flush. Every other toilet had a terrible flush which left fecal matter on the bowl in every toilet. they had to be cleaned constantly.

Fast forward...we now have another new house with all Kohler one piece Kathryn toilets. I did zero research. Just chose this toilet based on looks. Figured it couldn’t be any worse than the Toto I researched to death.

these toilets not only look good, but perform flawlessly and flush all of the yuck down....every single time. I have two teen boys and lots of family home frequently. Yeah.

We installed the Classic Memoirs 2-pc in our master bath in 2014, and the Stately Memoirs 1-pc and matching large pedestal sink in our powder room in 2017 and are happy with them. Now we do not notice the comfort height, but it was odd at first. It does seem that everywhere I look, I see a Memoirs toilet.

Thank you all for the feedback! It is very reassuring! (Though somewhat less reassuring about my Toto picks for elsewhere lol.)

I am also a shorty who doesn't love comfort height toilets, but I am very much the minority in my household, so I have long learned to accept it.

emho23 - I can't say I agree about toilets not complementing the space. They come in all different shapes and lines to suit various tastes AND styles. A super sleek, modern toilet would look out of place in a traditional room. I actually DO like the looks of the Memoirs quite a bit. For other rooms, where the toilets are hidden in their own closets, I chose the toilets for their performance and smooth sides to aid in keeping them clean. But for this room, I wanted the "pretty" toilet that matched the space.

I installed the Memoir in all my bathrooms and have had no issues with them. They are champion flushers. However note I got the one that is 1.6 flush.

What I actually said was that the toilet doesn't need to match the mouldings, and I stand by it. I did not say anything about toilets complementing spaces or not. Obviously, a modern fixture might not suit a super traditional space. Again, get what you like and what fits the space!