New Construction Home: Pay Cash vs Construction Loan

5 years ago

My husband and I are in contract to build a house on a lot that we purchased with cash. We are ages 53/54 and about 6 years from retirement.

We are considering whether to pay cash or take out a construction loan. With either scenario, the builder would be paid in 5 draws based on specific parameters of the project being met (foundation poured, framing, drywall, etc.)

Cost of Lot: 153,000
Cost of House: 584,000
Total: 737,000

Equity in current house: 400,000

I have only talked to our current mortgage lender so far. That bank offers a construction to permanent 3/1 ARM at 4.375% plus about $4500 in closing costs. Since we have the full amount in cash at Ally Bank, we feel that it makes no sense to finance the construction loan considering the interest rate and closing fees. We can pay the full amount of 584,000 to the builder from our savings account and still have 275,000 left in an emergency fund. Then when our current house sells, we will recoup 400,000 which can be placed in CDs/Bonds.

If we do pay cash to the builder, we are wondering what safeguards we need to protect ourselves. These are some of the items I can think of as of now? Open to any advice

1) Obtain Cost Sheet from builder? We have our contract, plans and Spec Sheet but the bank would require a "builder cost sheet" for financing so wondering if this is something we should obtain if we are providing our own financing.

1) Hire our own inspector to inspect work prior to each draw?

2) Do we need to worry about obtaining Lien Releases for the subcontractors?

3) Do we need to purchase additional title insurance other than the initial title insurance when we closed on the lot?

4) Do we need to involve a real estate lawyer? We've already signed the contract so I don't know what value a lawyer would add at this point.

5) The builder is requiring a letter from our bank stating that we have sufficient funds to satisfy the contract price. Should we ask him to provide us with any documents proving that he has sufficient capital to pay his subcontractors. The builder has a good reputation and we trust him but just wanting to make sure we protect ourselves as well.

Any other advice from people who have paid cash for new construction?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

Denita
5 years ago
You absolutely need a real estate lawyer that is familiar with construction contracts and lien law. Did you have an attorney draw up the contract or did you use the builders contract?

It is critical to get lien releases from subcontractors. Discuss this with the real estate attorney you hire. Do not use the same attorney the builder is using. Get someone that is knowledgeable and that represents buyers/homeowners and not builders, There is a tremendous value to having an excellent real estate attorney represent you right from the beginning of this process. You are already behind the 8-ball having signed a contract without an attorney (IMO). Please get an attorney before you do anything else.

Yes, to an independent knowledgeable inspector.
baseballmom94 thanked Denita
homechef59
5 years ago
Yes to your own RE attorney. Yes to a methodology of lien release tracking. Yes to setting up a construction draw schedule even if you don't have a loan. Your builder should know when he needs draws and design a schedule for you.

Planning is everything. Know what you want and stick to it.

Strangely enough, once the foundation is dug, a lot of risk diminishes. If there are no rocks or water, your foundation costs drop off.

Shop around for other lenders. You only need a construction loan. Not a construction to perm. They are different.

It's good to have a line of credit in your back pocket when building. I suggest you explore a home equity line of credit on your current home. If you need it, you have it. If you don't use it, you were prepared.

Lenders will love you. They love to lend to people who don't need the money. And, they love lending to people who already own the land. Expect and prepare for cost overruns. Construction lending is high risk and you are lowest level of risk of a high risk endeavor. Make the lenders compete for your business.
baseballmom94 thanked homechef59
Related Discussions
Better to pay cash or get loan to build custom home?
Q
Comments (38)
So it's May 2015 and I am just joining this conversation with the same plans to build with plenty of cash to do it without compromising our retirement and other investments. I have already gained some new insights by reading everyone's comments here so thank you! We also have our current house almost paid off which will be used to recoup some of our costs when it sells. And like several of you, we don't want to sell and move two times so we'll wait until new construction is near completion. But something just keeps nagging me about having some kind of safeguard in case something happens along the way. We know and trust our builder, but hey, anything can happen expectantly along the way. So I Googled Beth's original headline and came across another blog that revealed something very reassuring to me. Everyone knows about construction-to-permanent loans, but how about just taking out the initial construction loan and then paying it off in full at the end with no permanent loan? The lender assumes responsibility for getting an accurate appraisal, inspections, approvals for builder draws and final title. A 12-month construction loan would involve miniscule interest costs for the peace of mind in return. And what say you? An inquiring mind wants to know!
...See More
Construction Loan.. Purchase Price vs. Assessed Value
Q
Comments (7)
If the land is already transferred, you don't need an attorney. And YOU don't pay income taxes on land that was gifted to you. Each person has an annual cap on their gifting limit. Then, the rest is suppose to be tabulated and goes against a total gift allowance (use to be 2 million per person) at their death. The amount is significantly above 2 million now. Then all assets above the lifetime limit the year of their death gets taxes at estate tax rates. You have the option of checking with other banks too. Land is transferred all the time for $1 and other consideration. I think many people have found that when they buy the land (even at 100K), they still need to bring 20% or so to the table. If you are already planning to bring about that to the table, probably not much to worry about. If the land was you planned equity, then probably a good idea to get with some other banks. Would be a bummer if you were 2 months out, and this bank changed their mind!
...See More
Remodeling (Construction)Loan, Draws, and Who Pays (x-posted)
Q
Comments (12)
Most home remodels that are being done are with cash or HELOC's. I don't know of anyone in the past 18 months who has gotten a home remodel loan. Banks have gotten way too bit from "house flippers" who thought they could turn a profit by cheaply putting lipstick on pigs. Most will do HELOC's because the amount is smaller and secured by the equity in the home. A true home remodel loan will require extensive vetting by the bank and appraisers over the plans to be able to try and verify the value after the remodel as well as the reputation of the contractors involved so as to be sure of the completion of the project. It's part voodoo and part neighborhood value. And you should NOT put the cart before the horse on this by fronting any materials before the loan is approved. Because it may not be. However, once the loan is approved, you should pay out of pocket to get it started if need be. You should always have a safety cushion for those type of expenditures that the bank is hurry up and wait on. And at least a 20% cash cushion for overages. You will need that, and maybe more on older homes. Plus, the bank will have a difficult time approving a loan unless you can prove you really don't need a loan and actually have the cash or home equity to do the project outright.
...See More
New Home Construction (Budget Decisions 3rd Car garage vs SunRoom Bump
Q
Comments (30)
I go with the sunroom, too, and here's why. You can build a shed for cheap at some point, and until then you'll probably keep one car inthe driveway, and all the bikes and basketballs in the garage along with the yard and snow tools. The sunroom will make a great playroom while the little ones are little. I've seen that sunroom with nothing in it but a low-pile play rug and Lego. Or balls. Or plastic hockey sticks. Or those big Little Tykes (slide, trikes, trains) Or Hot Wheels. Or dollhouses. Or art projects (easy-to-clean tile floor). Usually just one or two of those. But a great playspace, near you but not, outdoors but not. After they are done with those types of toys, it can be dining space and added living space. You don't need the shed until Boy #1 gets a car. Oops, didn't mean to scare ya lol! Upstairs, I wonder if you can steal some space from the game room to make a reach-in closet for Bedroom 2, and use its walk-in closet to expand the bathroom. 5 boys will need more counterspace, more drawer storage, and (I can't believe I'm saying this, I'm usually a 1-sink gal) 2 sinks. Downstairs, consider eliminating the study closet and adding a shower to the powder room.
...See More
homechef59
5 years ago
I reread your questions. No. You don't need additional title insurance. You will need a policy that covers the construction and materials on site. This is specialty insurance.
cpartist
5 years ago
Actually not a RE attorney. Get a construction law attorney.

In reality, our bank has saved us because they made sure there are no liens and working with us, refused to release funds until they got our ok's. Additionally their formula required the builder to agree to something like 10 draws versus the builder's 5 draws.

One other thought. Look around to see if you can get a better rate. We got a 10/1 ARM at under 4%. Granted our rate is 2 years old but our money was better left in our mutual and ETF funds where they are growing at a higher rate than the loan amount.

New Construction Home: Pay Cash vs Construction Loan

Comments (4)

Denita

homechef59

Related Discussions

homechef59

cpartist

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US