Melissa, We would LOVE to help you here! Custom pillow solutions is our LIFE!! <3 Is there any way we could see the 1) print, 2) sofa, 3) your pillow options, and finally 4) your space? As you well know, balance is a tightrope and with a project like you have getting a visual on your space and the coordinating piece(s) is an absolute MUST. Knowing where to start (your style) within the vast range out there plays the biggest key in unlocking the right path to finding options for you. Knowing where you want your attention to be drawn will play a major roll in NOT having competing focal points and thus chaos and competition vs. harmony and balance. Let us know if we can help! :)

The following pictures show the 100% certified organic pillows from Live Good. These inserts are moisture-resistant, quick-drying, lightweight, completely hypo-allergenic, mold resistant and odorless. All Live Good products are handcrafted in California using 100% certified organic materials. Link: [https://www.houzz.com/products/organic-baby-livegood-pillow-prvw-vr~48286860[(https://www.houzz.com/products/organic-baby-livegood-pillow-prvw-vr~48286860) Turtle: [https://www.houzz.com/products/organic-baby-turtle-cotton-pillow-prvw-vr~48285908?lid=34936264[(https://www.houzz.com/products/organic-baby-turtle-cotton-pillow-prvw-vr~48285908?lid=34936264) Elephant: [https://www.houzz.com/products/organic-baby-elephant-cotton-pillow-prvw-vr~48283081[(https://www.houzz.com/products/organic-baby-elephant-cotton-pillow-prvw-vr~48283081) Lion：[https://www.houzz.com/products/organic-baby-lion-cotton-pillow-prvw-vr~48286439[(https://www.houzz.com/products/organic-baby-lion-cotton-pillow-prvw-vr~48286439)

They both sound nice. If you’re having two made, I’d do both if possible. They don’t have to be exactly the same and that would add interest.

I like the sofa/rug/pillows (I don't mind the xmas plaid one either) love the idea of poinsettias or the tray on the bench w/the xmas decor. However, the generic art pieces are a huge no. I'm sure once you paint the walls you can find something better to hang. as for the rug, the way to solve the problem is to layer it over another larger sisal or jute rug use something light like the creamy one above, or somethng like these (this one is Hira, natural Ivory, 8x10. you want something a foot larger(minimum) than what you have now) Birchlane Jute rug: Or, just get a larger rug, maybe like this, and use the other elsewhere. I like any of these colors. and they all work w/your flooring. I really like the Abalone Shell w/your white/black palette. the languid blue is nice too. (the others on your wall seem a little too blue/gray) here are two diff art pieces w/the same tones as these paint colors. the abalone shell is a red based color so it really works nicely w/your reddish wood floors. the two grays are on the warmer side, rather than blue undertone. some other grays some others w/diff art