Hi, I can't see enough of the Reddened Earth sample to tell at that distance, but I think you're on the right track. What I would do is find the color closest to your brick, and then use it on both the downspouts (as Chloe suggested) AND the garage doors. I always disguise downspouts on brick in this way, even if I don't use that color anywhere else on the house.

Leave the garage surround (trim) white for contrast.

Because your brick is highly variegated (contains several different colors), you won't be able to "match" it exactly. What you're looking for is a reddish brown that seems to best 'fade away' into the background of the brick. If you need to look at other paint decks, do it. The old Ben Moore "Classic" fan deck has a lot of muted red and orange colors that tend to sync up well with common brick tones. An ideal place to test your simulated brick color is on the downspout. Paint out a long section. If testing two colors, leave a foot or two of white space between them. The one that seems to disappear is your winner.

In the future, when your budget allows for a full repaint, I'd probably replace the peachy sand color with something more taupe or greige, such as SW 7031 Mega Greige. At that point, you might choose to paint the doors greige as well, or if you're happy with the brick tone, they could remain. Downspouts should remain the brick tone -where they cross the brick- no matter what.

I like the suggestion of greige. Mega Greige looks like a warm shade which could also work with your roof...brown?

chloebud has a good idea. Take a closeup of your brick and put it in the Sherwin Williams website to see what colors work with your brick.

I would go with the darkest color of your brick for the garage doors.

I would then go for a lighter and brighter color for your front door to draw the attention to your front door rather than the garage doors.

Bring in a professional to limb up the tree a little bit. Right now that tree blocks your entire home.

Nancy, those sage greens I posted look really off on my iPad screen...much better on my laptop. Anyway, sage can be nice.

Just noticed...what the heck is flying over your house in the first pic? LOL...either a very large bird or UFO! ;-)

chloebud, I had noticed that too when I took the photo. This is what you get when you blow up the photo...tandem birds!

I like the suggestions of Denita and Paintcolorhelp regarding trying to match the darkest brick color for the doors and downspouts. You definitely need to draw attention to the front door instead of the garage doors. I also agree that you could probably remove some of the lower limbs of the tree. My husband is obsessed with trimming lower tree limbs but it does look better when he's finished, I have to admit.

Nancy, thanks for the blow-up! My first thought was a bird, but tandem wasn't part of it.