I would spray it. Lowes and Home Depot have some great oil rubbed bronze spray paint. About $5. I am doing the same with some lighting fixtures I have :) Good luck.

Thanks clergychick. I've been looking in magazines and the only time I see the ORB faucet/hardware the kitchen seems to have paneled appliances. Glad that you are doing a similar mix that we are considering. Would love to see a picture when you have one available. Too funny that your 16yo is helping you recover from the matchy-match pattern. My 2yo and 4yo are still in the "everything MUST match or we will cry" stage. :)

Hi Mary, It did help. Thanks so much for going through all this trouble for me. I can tell the difference between the two finishes. I could see what you mean about the faucet having a shiny finish and how the pull is more flat. I wish I could find both items in the same color. I'm going to have a 33 inch stainless single bowl. My thought was to put the faucet and the handle in the middle, the soap dispenser to the left and the insta hot to the right. But it might look off balance with the different color. Maybe I should put the faucet, handle and the soap dispenser over to the left and the insta hot far over to the right so that they are not that close to one another. Where do you have your faucet? It looks like you didn't center it. On another note, what color granite do you have? It looks like Giallo Napolean or New Venetian Gold. It's what I'm currently considering. Yours looks beautiful.

Yes, no one can look at both and take the time to be picky about it lol. You will be the ones who notice things more than anyone. And after the dust settles most of the time you wont even think about it anymore. Side note I dont think you need contrast on your cabinet pulls, a brushed brass would be really pretty with bronze..just a thought.