I think the Brown Jordan is more classic. I like the cleaner lines. I debate between the BJ Venetian and Janus et Cie Amalfi myself.

Thanks Rita for your input. I agree, the lines are nice and clean. I was wondering, however, if anyone had insight into the relative quality of construction, durability, etc.? This will be the last patio set I ever buy, lol.

My DD has her grandparents BJ's old wrought iron porch furniture on her deck. It's still in great condition and is at least 50-70 years old!

Thanks Anglophilia and Rita for you experience with BJ. Rita, I also loved and considered the Janus et Cie Amalfi, but I could tell that I would repeatedly catch myself on those filials. I love the look though, probably because I am a Francophile.

We have a Brown Jordan set that we’ve had for about three years. It’s the Flight Sling collection, so more modern than the classic look you’re going for. It’s been terrific. Some of the best quality furniture I’ve ever had.

I just sold a large grouping (11 pieces) of vintage Brown Jordan metal furniture that had never been outside. It was used in a sunroom, so the cushions needed recovering. Still had the original receipt from 1986, purchased at market. Let's just say it held its value well! I don't remember the collection name, but I like the Venetian better. It's high quality furniture.

jakabedy and allison, thanks for your comment on quality. Good to know that their quality has stood the test of time. I've just about decided to go with BJ.

Just to follow up, I bought a set of the BJ Venetian and am thrilled with the style, comfort, and quality. One if the tables had a leg that was ever so slightly short, causing the table to rock, so my vendor dealt with BJ and they sent out a replacement table that was perfect. Overall, the finish and the ‘heft’ of the pieces are just beautiful.