Houzz Logo Print
ldstarr

The Devil's Advocate

8 years ago

I was just reading thru the postings concerning the school shooting yesterday, and one of the consistent themes is "No one needs to own an assault gun". I agree 100% with that statement. On the other hand, nobody is saying "teenagers do not need to be permitted to drive cars". It most cases, a teenager driving is a convenience, not a necessity. In 2016 alone 2150 teenagers were killed in cars, but in 18 years 212 teenagers have been killed in school shootings. Here's my question. Why the outrage over school shootings but no outrage over licensing teen drivers?

Comments (32)

  • 8 years ago

    I remember reading somewhere that teenage driving/accidents are the #1 cause of death in teenagers.

  • 8 years ago

    mama, you are correct.

  • Related Discussions

    Devil's Advocate

    Q

    Comments (20)
    moccâ¦â¦very nice selection you have. The blues that I have now are Wishing Well, two Drinking Gourds and just got a Fragrant Blue from Hallson last week. The Drinking Gourds I've had for 2 years and have both done great. One is potted and one is in the ground, the only hosta I have in the ground except for the Wishing Well, which I picked up two weeks ago. I attached a link in case you have not seen this one before. All of what you have look great, so please feel free to suggest anything at all and I'll add them to my list. I very much appreciate your advice. Here is a link that might be useful: Wishing Well
    ...See More

    Ls Paisley Print size?

    Q

    Comments (8)
    I emailed Rob Canning, who is now the owner of Lakeside hostas, having bought all of Mary Chastain's plants from her and moving them to Michigan. Rob states that LS Paisley Print is a medium, not very tall, but it spreads out into a wide plant. That's the word from the guy with the original clump!
    ...See More

    Need help Excavators on building this

    Q

    Comments (5)
    While 1) digging up basement, where will I store the dirt? Unless you're planning to use it for landscaping hills, the excavator takes it away to wherever. There's always someone looking for "clean fill."If he has got a good eye, he will keep just enough to backfill. And maybe forego that, instead opting for freeflowing fill. Interesting restriction. But it sounds like adequate room to work. You bring in lumber in stages as needed only, trusses can go directly from delivery vehicle to the roof. Once the first floor is on, you now have additional storage space. Stack the masonry/siding neatly. I built houses with as little as one-three foot sideyards on tight city lots. I'm afraid too many diy have the mistaken idea that homebuilding has to be a messy, sloppy business with everything everywhere. (Not that you don't see those sites!)
    ...See More

    What type of pepper is this?

    Q

    Comments (4)
    Looks like Jalapeno to me! The coolest looking pepper I grew recently was Malaysian Goronong and I guarantee your dad won't guess that one!
    ...See More
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Apples and oranges.

    Kids in cars are not out looking for how many people they can kill in a single accident.

    And people ARE outraged over so many teen driver deaths, usually caused by distraction. This is why texting laws came into effect. Many states are implementing other cell phone usage laws.

    ETA: "because of the way distracted driving laws are worded, law enforcement could potentially determine that shoveling a muffin in your mouth while maneuvering through traffic is enough to warrant a ticket."

    The difference is, lawmakers are TRYING to do something about distracted driving.

  • 8 years ago

    We do license drivers, after training and passing a test, and insurance is also involved.

    None of that is true for guns.

  • 8 years ago

    I agree with last post. But what is scary are cars and trucks used as terrorist weapons. Not meaning to go off topic

  • 8 years ago

    Sorry moonie, I think you're missing my point. I'm not discussing intent, some shooters are just looking "to get even" with a few individuals. My point is, why not just stop licensing teens to drive since it kills so many each year.

  • 8 years ago

    So rather than banning firearms, just use a licensing criteria. If more people would advocate for a "middle ground", rather than an extreme view, something might actually happen to improve gun safety.

  • 8 years ago

    Idstarr, i might agree that the driving age should be raised. I might even agree to your "middle ground" comment... for a start. But I'll never agree that the average citizen has any business with assault weapons.

  • 8 years ago

    Some states have graduated steps for teens to obtain driving licenses. My state, Illinois, doesn't issue a permanent license until a person is 19. There is a learner's permit at 15, when the driver can only drive with a an adult in the car. Later, the teen is prohibited from driving with more than one non-adult in the car (unless the other minor is a relative -- a nod to relieving an adult from driving kids to school, appointments, etc. Prior to receiving a permanent license, a teen's parents can tell the state to revoke a permit -- no questions asked. If a 'learner' has traffic offenses before 19, he must start the procedure all over again. No one can go beyond the first permit stage before completing 50 hours of driving instruction.

    *Because* distraction* is an overwhelming cause of all vehicle accidents, especially those involving teens, why not remove the biggest modern day distraction by blocking cell phone reception in a moving vehicle, excepting police and emergency vehicles. This technology exists and is used by trucking companies and other companies that have employees on the road. These companies are avoiding damage and lawsuits. We could very simply avoid deaths and injuries for a whole population.

    Who would be opposed to the cell phone ban? Why, the cell phone companies, of course. They have a big lobby. Who else? There's the Yammerer whose phone is attached to her ear, who doesn't know where she's going, who can't plan her life to avoid being lost or late. (Whose calls are not *urgent* to anyone but her.) She doesn't want to be 'inconvenienced' just to save some lives.

  • 8 years ago

    People also die from obesity, should we arrest anyone more than 10% overweight?


    There's no logic in your argument as far as I can see. Cars are essential to modern life and new drivers (of any age) cause more problems than more experienced ones. Guns aren't essential at all, most countries do just fine with strict bans and limited ownership tightly controlled.

    Stop there.

  • 8 years ago

    I don't see that our current gun laws are being enforced. There are too many 'legal' gun owners that do have criminal records or have mental instability issue or don't meet other criteria for legally owning a firearm. Because of (IMO) poor reporting of these criteria, ineligible people are able to 'legally' obtain firearms.

    I would find it quite interesting to see the difference in these types of violent crimes, if indeed it were more difficult to be eligible to legally own a firearm.

  • 8 years ago

    Using the OPs logic, don't license adults to drive either??

    Adult drivers kill too.

  • 8 years ago

    I live in a state with a graduated license system. You have to have logged X amount of miles with only your parent and been driving for X time with your permit to get to a restricted license. It restricts the times and number of people in your car. Then you have to be X age to move to a completely unrestricted license. I wonder if it's cut down on the deaths. I hope so. You can't tell teens not to drive. They need and want to drive. But do it in a controlled environment. Seems right to me!

  • 8 years ago

    I think some *restrictions* are necessary for the public good -- for drivers and on guns.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    We really need to ensure that we are enforcing our current 'restrictions'.

  • 8 years ago

    Teens having access to cars has benefits in ways that *people* having access to guns do not. Do guns determine whether everyone can get a job the way cars can? Cars and guns belong on different levels in the hierarchy of need - I need food, but I don't have to have *quite* as much cake as I *want*.

    ...Is how I see this.

  • 8 years ago

    Bourbon Milkshake, do you honestly think that responsible gun owners want to take your cake? That is absolutely not what we want. We want to be able to protect our families if needed. We have our own cake.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I suppose the comparison was a bit flip. Heightened feelings taken into consideration, I should have been more diplomatic. But I do honestly believe that comparing access to guns and access to cars is comparing things on different ontological planes of need, even when we're comparing access to guns for *everyone* and access to cars for *just teenagers*. The argument, posed by the OP, that since we allow teenagers to drive we have to allow the same access to guns is spurious (all due respect, OP), because teenagers need cars in ways that we don't all need guns.

    If someone wants to say that people need guns in the same way that teenagers need cars, the argument can be evaluated on those terms.

  • 8 years ago

    Not every kid has a two parent family. Many of those kids have after school jobs that are not accommo

    dated by the school buses. Many of them stay late for teams and sports. Mom cannot leave work early to cart junior around.

    Even if there are two parents in the house, most parents have to work just to make sure the 1% can remain comfortable. Then there's the rural kids who live at the back end of nowhere and would be walking dark roads with no sidewalks if they stay late. My friend lost her only child because of a hit and run on one of those rural roads. He stayed late for play practice and she was working - out of necessity, not boredom or greed.

    The days of Ozzie and Harriet are long gone. Most average kids today absolutely need to drive.

  • 8 years ago

    But but but. Driving is a PRIVILEGE, granted by what ever jurisdiction one lives in, where as gun ownership is a RIGHT, guaranteed by the US Constitution. Privileges can be encumbered with all kinds of stuff imposed by the privilege grantor, but rights are rights are rights, clear and simple. You have the right to bear arms. PERIOD. Just like the other rights granted, say the right of free speech. I can yell "fire!" in a crowded theater, threaten the life of individuals or encourage others to do so, tell blatant lies, and impune the reputation of anyone I please, after all, I have the right to say ANYTHING I care to, no holds barred. Same goes for all the rights granted to citizens of the US by The Bill of Rights in the US Constitution. They're absolute, aren't they?

  • 8 years ago

    LOL there are quite a few of these oddities in our lives. The one that always strikes me as I deal with parents completely out of their element is the hoops it takes to get a dog from the pound but parenthood, no one admits most of us could use a class or TEN. Truth is as adults we are not able to be of one mind about how to guide a child into adulthood. With FREEDOM comes responsibilities. I think we have decided no one is responsible. I don't think it is working for us for the most part.

  • 8 years ago

    There are exceptions to free speech. You cant incite riot or panic. The first amendment will not protect you from defamation of another.

  • 8 years ago

    As Emma Gonzalez said ... BS!




  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    "where as gun ownership is a RIGHT, guaranteed by the US Constitution."

    Same was true at the same time of the RIGHT to own slaves. Guaranteed by the US Constitution, which also provided how they would be counted in the census - one slave = 3/5ths of a white person, so a total of 5 were to be counted as 3.

    When everyone realized what a mistake slavery was and how much misery was caused, it was changed. Same as with guns today and the same remedy will work and needs to be done.


    As I said in another thread - kentrees, if you want to exercise your 2nd Amendment right (to a well regulated militia), you'll have to join your state's National Guard. Any other interpretation is a perversion of what was intended.

  • 8 years ago

    Are we headed to another Civil War?

  • 8 years ago

    Ummmm, my 'rant' was meant as sarcasm.

  • 8 years ago

    **Idstarr
    So rather than banning firearms, just use a licensing criteria. If more people would advocate for a "middle ground", rather than an extreme view, something might actually happen to improve gun safety **

    It is my understanding that the NRA is unwilling to budge a millimeter toward any middle ground. NRA, you know,,,,, the ones who hold the puppet/purse strings for a large chunk of Congress critters. The NRA gives them a grade based on their gun rights voting record or position & donate accordingly. Every reasonable proposal is thwarted with “if we give in to this, it is just the first step in taking away ALL the guns from us good guys.” They will not budge!

  • 8 years ago

    Why, oh why are we not screaming for more strict adherence to laws already in place?

    That is not the work of the NRA, it is the work of agencies that report critical information (prison system, military agencies) which would prevent unsuited people people from passing a background check for a license.

  • 8 years ago

    Sorry, but the NRA does not enact laws. It is our elected officials who need to take the middle ground. I realize that the NRA is a very, very powerful lobby, but when enough citizens demand a middle ground approach to gun control and are willing to back up their demands at the polls, change will come. Unfortunately, it is always the "extremes" that are heard due to the media's constant quest for sensationalism. We the people, have allowed the "extreme" (NRA) to dictate our gun control, or lack there of, and until we have a collective backbone, nothing will change and the killing will continue.

  • 8 years ago

    An tripartite absolute right: life. Liberty. Pursuit of happiness.

  • 8 years ago

    For those of you blinded by what you think are absolute and immutable rights under the Constitution, take a look at this article. The problem isn't hard to understand if you open your eyes.



    One reason why the US has a mass shooting problem