It was taken from memoir by the same name. Of a family in chaos throughout the children's lives. Smart, educated parents but father was an alcoholic. The family lived in the poorest of conditions but also had some freedoms and intellectual pursuits that were rays of sunshine. Woody Harrelson played the alcoholic father. I may have seen him in one too many violent roles because he was hard to watch. Otoh, most families have some experience with alcoholism and can relate to this family in some way. As a story, it has merit. Hard to watch though imo.

That was my main feeling. Frustration that the violence continued over a long period. It makes the mom as responsible as he was. The daughter wrote the memoir because so many people can relate to the chaos of alcoholism.

I read the book and had the same reaction as Nancy. I also felt the author exaggerated some of the events for effect, or to make the book more "interesting." I really have no desire to see the movie, since I did not like the book.

purrmichigan---- so glad to see you here! :-)

Thanks! I always knew one year would be my max and it has been good being away but I sincerely miss the lefties.

Interesting that you saw exageration. I watched the 'extras' on the DVD which included a long interview with the author. Imo she was over the top. Whether thats from being raised in a chaotic home or whether thats why the book/movie was super dramatic ...idk. I think most people can relate somehow but more people would pay attention if the book and movie had been more objective.

Thanks all for your comments.

Lynn, I laughed when you noted that this was a Pidge movie. Actually, I haven't seen it and probably won't, much as I love Woody Harrelson. This is Oscar season and I want to see as many movies as I can, but there is only so much time in a week.

I did see Wonder, Lady Bird, and The Disaster Artist, however. All good, though very different.

I read the book. If it were not for the high school teacher, the author may not have escaped her circumstances growing up as well as she does. I read that her sister was not as fortunate.

Yes to Wonder- good for young and old; also a very good book. I hope to see Lady Bird. I also recommend The Florida Project. It is getting a lot of attention as a low budget film playing in select theaters. I understand it was filmed with cell phones; however, I do not think viewers would notice.