Hand railing vs code in narrow Colonial stairs
DYH
5 years ago
last modified: 5 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (16)
DYH
5 years agoRelated Discussions
Need help/ideas for porch & stair railings
Comments (12)Insofar as arts & crafts style meant honest materials/ design your heavy 6x6 newels/guardrails are fine. By honest materials, I mean shingles and heavy timbers that aren't ashamed about what they are. 20 years previous, Victorians embraced the idea of all forms of sham and pretense. The porch posts were more like table legs writ large. The popular furniture style du jour was expended into the porch, the cornice, and the dormers! If a material could be tortured into a convoluted shape by saw or blade, it was. Or they cast it in plaster and tacked it on. Was it supposed to be emulating ancient stonework? then paint wood it and embed the surface with sand! Instant faux-stone. Things would not always (if ever?) be what they appeared. A&C was a reaction against this, and timber and shingle and natural lines without artifice and pretension were embraced. Your little bungalow is a simple expression of an honest ideal. "Let things be what they are". They _did_ like to use oversize elements, especially on the porch. Think of the huge pyramidal rounded fieldstone piers, and knee-braces and timbered gable decorations. Brutalism is something else entirely. It's about raw unfinished (and intentionally roughened) concrete surfaces. Not 6x6 porch railings. I grew up in a 1938 house that was sort of a stone cape cod and adirondack lodge combo. It had a third-floor interior balcony/catwalk enclosed with 4x6 white pine rails and 6x6 newel posts. Woodsy, but not brutal. The stair treads were solid 6x10's. I should scan the construction photo album from that place some day... Casey...See MoreMetal horizontal stair railing advice!
Comments (11)Thank you all for your feedback! I appreciate it, and I’m actually really surprised that so many of you think it looks nicer this way lol. We are in touch with the builder and they have been pretty responsive and will get back to us soon with a resolution. At this point, I can live with it if it’s going to cause huge delays to get this fixed.. also excellent point about the safety aspect of things catching. Thank you all once again!...See MoreFunky Stairs need Hand Rail Ideas
Comments (48)I understand that OP needs it to be cheap until closing because this is a lender requirement (not unusual) and if it is fixed before closing, it becomes a fixture and stays with the property even if the buyer doesn't close. CONSIDER: A solution to this would be a rehab type loan rather than the typical purchase loan. Benefit to the buyer is they don't need to resort to expensive hard money type loan as mentioned up thread. Also it gives the buyer the TIME to figure out a permanent solution. The buyer can close right away on a rehab loan. The disadvantage to a rehab loan is that the interest rate is slightly higher than your typical purchase mortgage. Something to explore....See MoreRailing or no railing? Per code, I can do either.
Comments (17)Looks much better without the railing. I don't like how the railing cuts the view of the windows. I will like it even less when the black shutters go back up. Without the railing, the house looks more stately. Railing frou-frou detracts from a stately look. Slightly beefier posts would look nice but the ones you have look fine, too. Disabled, injured, elderly aren't going to want to negotiate the sidewalk & sidewalk steps to get to the porch so the argument that it is necessary for them doesn't hold water AFAIC. Great looking house. I like it very much....See MoreDYH
5 years agoDYH
5 years agoDYH
5 years agoSaltiDawg
5 years ago
Related Stories

REMODELING GUIDESRenovation Ideas: Playing With a Colonial’s Floor Plan
Make small changes or go for a total redo to make your colonial work better for the way you live
Full Story
REMODELING GUIDESArchitect's Toolbox: Aim High with Interior Railings
Expressive, evocative railings can take your stairs to new heights
Full Story
STAIRWAYSBeautiful Stairs: Safety Meets Style
Solid to Near-Transparent Materials Turn the Humble Railing Into High Design
Full Story
Design Opportunity: Style in the Stairs
From ornate iron scrollwork to spiral-cut wood dowels, balustrades are great supporting acts
Full Story
KNOW YOUR HOUSEStair Design and Construction for a Safe Climb
Learn how math and craft come together for stairs that do their job beautifully
Full Story
REMODELING GUIDESArtful Stairs: Continuity in Steel
Ribbonlike Stairs of Steel Seem to Nearly Float on Air
Full Story
STAIRWAYS17 Ideas for Storage Under the Stairs
It’s not just about the ups and downs. These clever staircases also provide storage, display and seating
Full Story
KITCHEN DESIGN9 Ways to Enjoy Your Narrow Kitchen More
Use color, pattern and even your cooking supplies to personalize your skinny cooking space
Full Story
DECORATING GUIDESWhat to Do With the Space Under the Stairs
Whether your stairway is curved or straight, it’s valuable real estate. Here are 10 ways to use it and dress it up
Full Story
KITCHEN OF THE WEEKKitchen of the Week: Storage Galore in a 1920s Colonial
Pullouts, slots, special drawers and more — this customized kitchen packs in plenty of organizing solutions
Full Story
schoolhouse_gw