Laurie I had the same concerns. I saw a number of vanities from NY vanity in a showroom and was not impressed. No dovetail joints and the sliders for the drawers are on the side so you see the rails when the drawers are pulled out. They don’t slide or close smoothly. I just ordered our vanity from Yorktowne (same as Medallion).

In my opinion, the framing around the mirror should match your cabinet, assuming it is wood. As far as fixtures and lighting, I think they should match. We redid our powder room last year and are now revamping our hall/guest bathroom, so I understand you concerns.

I have the same problem with a vanity I bought also: regular liquid hand soap has left stains or discoloration marks on the stone top. Doesn’t anyone know of a way to remove them? It’s very hard to capture them in photos but here are a few.

Moen 26" Tall Tilting Oval Mirror from the Glenshire Collection Model:DN2692BN ... remove the existing mirror and install this swivel mirror. Yes, it should be centered in your eye sightline. it will cover some of the window, but will look fine. I have done this in past homes for natural light.