Advice on Hiring an Architect
Mark J
6 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (23)
Related Discussions
Hiring An Architect
Comments (40)MacyPA, I'm sorry you have had such a bad experience with an architect (if he even is one). I am a licensed architect and hearing how he has treated you is disappointing and unprofessional. Regardless of his profession, it sounds like he has poor social skills and bad business sense! Unfortunately with all things in life, you have good, bad, indifferent, lazy, etc people no matter what their trade is. First off, it is YOUR house, why in the world would you continue to employe ANYONE who doesn't listen and then design what YOU want!?! The only caveat to this is if you purposely hire a huge name designer for their specific brand of architecture (ie Frank Lloyd Wright, Frank Ghery or A. Hayes Town). So, if you are fighting to get YOUR wants for YOUR house, then this guy is NOT for you. Do NOT waste any more of your time and money! Secondly, his fee does sound low... so it may be that he's giving you a discount b/c he's in with the contractor and development. Or he's just cheap and thus it may be a "you get what you pay for" scenario. But at least you are only paid up through schematics. Personally, I would take what you have paid for and find another architect. Take the time to really interview candidates. (It's a tough economy, architects in the Southeast are pretty hungry for work.) Your house design by nature is very personal, so you really need to 'click' with your architect. You need to feel comfortable that the design professional will take everything you say seriously and really listen to your program requirements, issues and concerns. With that, one hopes the architect can provide solutions that work for you, wether you conceived of them or not. So much of what we architects do is synthesize information. So obviously, listening is quite important. On the topic of CAD drawing... It is hard for me to believe that there are [profitable] architects practicing today that don't use the computer. I love hand drafting, BUT it is wildly inefficient & impractical these days for most every kind of architect. (And it sounds like this guy could benefit from the preciseness the computer affords.) In the end, I'm happy you actually considered an architect. It's encouraging to hear that people still find us valid in the residential sector. Unfortunately this experience my have turned you off... BUT please know a good architect can be a very worthwhile investment. You are spending a LOT of money, time and energy on your new home, why shouldn't it be designed how YOU want and need? An architect should be YOUR advocate (not the builders or developers). The architect should have YOUR best interests in the forefront of making the design work for you, on your lot and in your budget. Feel free to email me, I'm happy to answer questions. Depending on where you live, I am happy to offer recommendations for architects I know around the USA....See MoreHiring an architect
Comments (12)Andy, For one, I had one of my design charrettes (if you're a regular here, you'll know what they are). The client loved what we came up with in that 5 hour session. Got back glowing emails, etc. We really didn't have to get going on construction docs right away because what was driving the bus schedule wise was the site/grading plan approval. About a month later I get a sketch by the husband with a "How 'bout this??" note. Different "bubble diagram". I rework the whole thing. Get a reply back that it now addresses all their concerns and they love it! About two months go by and I get another note from the husband with "How 'bout this??" I rework the whole design again. Get another note back saying "Looks great now! We love it!!". Two more times with this. I finally ask the husband what's going on. He says the problem is his wife always likes the initial design but over the ensuing weeks begins to have growing doubts about it and he sketches up something to "fix" it. At this point I'm wondering if I can make them happy. I didn't want to "leave them hanging" but I'm having serious doubts about a happy ending. The husband calls up. He says he loves what I'm doing but the wife wants to show my ideas to other architects and then get back to me with their comments. I jumped on that like a dog on red meat and politely said I think I've done the best I could so best to go with someone new. That was last fall and still no building permit filed for yet. For the other one there where about 30 small reasons that together added up to one big reason but part of it concerned the lack of trust I wrote about above. And that one was rough. This project was a reno of an existing empty house. We scheduled a meeting out there and a few days later I concluded, for a variety of reasons, it wasn't working out. I thought I owed it to them to tell them face to face in lieu of an email and decided to use the meeting to tell them. What I thought would be a 5 minute discussion turned out to be an hour. They refused to take "no" for an answer. I was drained. In retrospect I might have been able to bring them around on the trust issue given their effort to keep me as the architect but there where a bunch of smaller reasons too. When I look on these situations, it's never been about my income but always about my assessment of keeping the client happy while having their trust. For 36 years I've set that as the order of priorities and the income has always been good....See MoreDid you hire an architect?
Comments (216)Or if you don't want a house that's a disaster because there aren't strict codes; codes that protect people from shoddy work or bad engineering. For example, I'm in FL. After hurricane Andrew, codes became much stricter and thankfully so since most of the homes that blew apart in Homestead wouldn't have if they were built to stricter codes with things like hurricane strapping. So you want to double your cost so that it shows hurricane strapping on the plan? You don't need an architect to add hurricane strapping, your builder can easily accommodate that. If you receive shoddy work, I recommend finding another builder. We're getting ready to do a whole house remodel and addition to our one story home. We've found a builder that we like and will be working with an architect to prepare our plans. I'm anticipating that working with an architect will give us the cohesive exterior look we want, as opposed to an addition that looks like it was just an afterthought slapped on to the original house. I'm hoping for a finished design that looks like a beautifully renovated farmhouse that was added on over time. I'm also hoping to achieve the most ideal layout, since the current footprint is so lacking. I know what I want but need help translating that into a workable design. I think you're making the right decision....See MoreHas anyone switched from online plan to using snd architect
Comments (12)Now that I have a bit more time, I wanted to add some more detail to this. I started off looking at online plans. I must have saved 50 of them to my Pinterest board. I also perused this forum, and read every thread I could that said "Has anyone built the (fill in the blank) plan?". I must have said "This is it! This is THE plan!" about 7 or 8 times. Each time, the more I looked at the plan in greater detail, the more I realized it wouldn't work for our family for some reason or another. The last IT plan I found, I posted here. Got a lot of really good feedback about why it really wasn't a very good plan. Got a private message from a very helpful member with awesome information, including contact information for an architect on this board that would be very helpful. So, not having anything to lose and lots to gain, I reached out to said architect, who was indeed very helpful with tons of information about design, links to threads, links to homes he'd designed remotely, etc. And thus, my dream home concept was born. The way I look at it is this: I *could*, in theory, order a home plan online. And work with the online architect firm to fiddle with the plan to make it work better for our family (at a not insignificant cost). And there may be 50 or 60 of those same homes built across the US every year, and that may work just fine for lots of people. But I didn't want "just fine". I wanted my perfect home. So I'm working with an awesome architect who is creating something custom, and beautiful, and fits my family's needs perfectly, and fits the land we're building on, and looks like it belongs, and is truly one-of-a-kind. So...that's a novel, but gives a bit more information on my journey from online stock plan to architect awesomeness :) :) :)...See MoreMark J
6 years agoOne Devoted Dame
6 years agolast modified: 6 years agoMark J
6 years agoUser
6 years agolast modified: 6 years agoBLDG Workshop Inc.
6 years agoUser
6 years agolast modified: 6 years agoCharles Ross Homes
6 years agogreenacresmama
6 years agobuilding2017
6 years agocpartist
6 years agocpartist
6 years agobuilding2017
6 years agogreenacresmama
6 years agolast modified: 6 years agoPensacola PI
6 years ago
Related Stories
WORKING WITH PROSHow to Hire the Right Architect: Comparing Fees
Learn common fee structures architects use and why you might choose one over another
Full StoryWORKING WITH PROSHow to Hire the Right Architect
Your perfect match is out there. Here’s how to find good candidates — and what to ask at that first interview
Full StoryDESIGNING A BUSINESSDesigning a Business: New Advice Column for Pros Tackles Hiring
Design business coach Chelsea Coryell is ready for your questions. First up? How to know when you’re ready to hire
Full StoryWORKING WITH AN ARCHITECTWhat Architects Want You to Know About Hiring the Right One
Learn from the pros how to find an architect who makes the most sense for you and your project
Full StoryWORKING WITH PROSHow Much It Costs to Hire a Landscape Architect
Learn what landscape architects do and how they charge for their work
Full StoryLANDSCAPE DESIGNHow to Hire a Landscape Architect
Find the best fit for your landscaping project with this guide to evaluating and selecting a pro
Full StoryWORKING WITH PROS10 Times to Hire a Landscape Architect
This pro can solve problems, ensure that your home and landscape complement each other and help design special features
Full StoryWORKING WITH PROS10 Times to Hire an Architect
These pros help solve design problems, manage projects, build smarter homes and much more
Full StoryARCHITECTURESmaller and Smarter: An Architect’s Resolutions
This architect and midcentury fan plans to get out of his comfort zone in the new year
Full StoryWORKING WITH PROS5 Steps to Help You Hire the Right Contractor
Don't take chances on this all-important team member. Find the best general contractor for your remodel or new build by heeding this advice
Full Story
Virgil Carter Fine Art