Is this a counter height set? Roarah writes as if it is, it looks like it could be, but I didn't see you mention it (maybe I'm missing it). The thing that I notice, counter height or not is that the chairs seem to be low in comparison to the height of the table. It looks like, if seated there, you could scooping your food right into your mouth (not that any of us would :-).

I personally am not at all fond of sitting at a counter height table because I find the chairs often cause the legs to dangle. But if you don't find that a problem and are comfortable with it (and have no older folks who might not be as comfortable at that height chair), then what I like is not at all important!

yes for now this will be the only table. Why is it uncomfortable for longer periods? Do you see that it is too cramped ?? Thanks for the advice

Yes it is counter height, sorry for not mentioning it. Is counter height uncomfortable for longer period of times?

Also regular size tables dont come in square and 8 chairs, since we dont have formal dining this will be our primary table for most part we will spend time here with family and friends

I do not know why but my legs go numb when sitting for more than ten minutes on bar stools. The stools are also hard to pull in to the table. I am now in my forties but have had a kitchen pub table like the one you show since my late twenties and even young found them better for a quick sit not a long one.

I don't like sitting at counter or bar height chairs/stools either, nor is it practical for small children.

So the counter height seating is a personal preference and as long as you and your family are comfortable with it then I wouldn't worry too much about it. I think you are asking if they style of the table and chairs goes with the style of your kitchen? I would say yes because the lines in both are similar (neither have any curves) and the wood tones work. It will be a lot of wood color in one area but the rest of your room is pretty light in color so it shouldn't feel too dark. I think it can work. :)

Another dislike for counter height chairs and stools here.

Having the storage box where it is would drive me up a wall. I wouldn't be able to cross my legs or swing them out to get down off the chair which I wouldn't be able to move as I'm sitting in a high chair.

Style wise, yes it would work. The only thing I would do is change the spindles on that small dividing wall to better match the chair backs.

ETA- Hopefully the spindles aren't new?

Counter height is another fad/trend that will not pass the test of time. It suits the stand/chat move on crowd but really not much else. For maximum comfort health, posture one needs to anchor their feet to the ground. Sitting high is a NIGHTMARE for kids..they squirm,and are restless under 'normal' circumstances. Having their feet dangle away only compounds it. For a bar/pool table area they are CHIC, for daily dining--not so much. I would keep looking.

We have a counter height dining set at our lake condo. I find it to be comfortable enough to sit and eat a meal. I don't think I'd want to linger at the table for a long time, but I'm not one to be comfortable at any table for an extended period of time.

How many people usually sit at the table? What are the dimensions of the dining space and the square table? Don't forget to add room for the stools and bench to move in and out. Not sure the logistics of the bench would work either as the whole bench has to move out from the table and then back in.

That table might block the entry way when extended.

There are other companies offering square dining tables. Here is a link for you.

http://canadel.com/en/dining-and-living-furniture/tables/wood-tables?shape_name=35

What else do you have planned for the living room in front of the slider area? That might work for the square table set-up also.

I am not a fan of counter height. I have noticed for those who have them that they seem to be a smaller version of a regular set. Not so much in the OP's example.

For a very tall person, yes counter height is probably comfortable. For a short person, no.

You have a large kitchen. I don't think you need under the table storage.

I also don't care for counter height, but it may be fine for your family. I see a lot of them for sale on Craigslist here.

I would also have your family sit at the display model and see if the storage area underneath comes in contact with your legs or feet. If your children are young, will they be kicking it or resting their feet on it?

So, the table will go in the eat in area? I'm not sure the scale will work. The ceilings are lower and I think a counter height table will look cramped and will look too tall next to the railing.

What are you putting in the open space across from the kitchen sink? You have room for a nice long farm table which will be a great space for hanging out, homework and dining. You can put an indoor/outdoor rug under the table if you are worried about carpet spills.

I agree with the above comments on counter height being uncomfortable. I imagine the storage box ends up used as a footrest.

I would add that you should rethink the idea of a bench. Fixed in place banquette seating is one thing, but how are two people expected to move a double seat up to a table?

I think the square shape works for a table to sit and linger around. It's personal preference on the bar height or not. I do agree that bar height is difficult for smaller children to use. My complaint which has already been mentioned is that while that pedestal style is fashionable, they are a pain to sit at due to lack of leg and foot space.

I visit a friend who has counter height seating at her kitchen island. She also prefers we remove shoes before entering (I'm fine with that). But with no shoes and a counter height chair, I can sit there about 10 minutes before feeling serious foot pain... and I'm 6 foot one. (Okay, I do have a bad, once-broken, ankle.)

I can definitely do counter height seating if I am wearing shoes... but again, I'm six foot one, and many if not most of my friends are not. If you want to linger, most people would be more comfortable at table height. (And a full meal IS lingering!)

Now, the tables look counter height and the chairs possibly more table height... I again could handle this, because I'm taller than the average bear. If everyone you know also is, and will also be so, fine. But, my personal opinion, you'd be best off getting something standard table and chair height.

That being said... the style is great!

Thank you for the response, I see that from most comments that counter height is uncomfortable to sit for longer hours and for young kids (10,7). I agree to the response that since it is low ceiling, counter height might look odd there. I will look further for a regular square table that has a leaf and can seat 8 so we can add seat when necessary and just keep it small on a daily basis.

I like counter heights, but never experience them for longer periods. can someone suggest a good square table that will fit our space and has 8 chairs with leafs?

thank you

Wayfair has a good search function. I put in square table, 8 seats with a leaf and came up with a few options. You'll need to be really careful with dimensions and clearances. Based on your photo, I think an 8 seater will be tight in that space.

Wayfair search

Thank you, yes you are right 8 is tight on a daily basis, but when we have large gatherings we can move the table to the center and add the leaf to accommodate 8 at the table. I will look in wayfair never bought from there.

I think you are wise to revisit counter height. I have been shopping used dining sets on Craigslist for a few days now to help someone who is setting up a new apartment on a budget, and I can't believe how many used counter height sets are out there! I personally wouldn't buy one for all the reasons already stated. In addition to Wayfair, try places like Joss & Main, Pottery Barn, Ballard Designs, and even your local furniture stores. Even if you find something that is outside your price range, it'll give you a place to start.

Also, if you find something, be sure to do a general google search on that particular table for pricing. Wayfair can be very high for some things.

Thank you, will do

Not a fan either, I try never to sit on them.

A friend had a counter top height table and sold it after about a year....too uncomfortable. We have two bar stools at our breakfast bar and are not comfortable for long...as someone said, my legs get numb, even with feet propped on the rung of the leg. Glad you decided against that height. Have you considered a round table with a leaf? We like our oval (with leaf) table that we have in our dining room. Most have mentioned square but I guess I just prefer round tables in the kitchen/dining room.

No not considered round, some reason never thought about that, will have to look at some to decide, thanks for the input

I say yes, except NO to the bench. My brother and sister in law have a table similar and it's a nice gathering spot. She even has a lazy susan in the middle and you still have plenty of room. I know a lot of people don't like counter height but if you aren't the formal type, that table will serve you nicely.

I can't handle counter height for very long either because of the numbing factor.

On a daily basis how many are going to be seated around your kitchen table? I think the size of the one you posted will overwhelm the space you have. It also looks too wide to play any board games comfortably if you wanted to.