Echeveria, maybe E. pulidonis.

I don't think most Echeveria are toxic to cats (but do look it up anyway). I have a serial plant-muncher cat and he hasn't touched my succulents at all... but he's not a kitten :-P They get into everything.

Even if it's not toxic, it'll probably make them barf if they ingest it and make your plant look unsightly. Just find a nice sunny windowsill where your kittens can't go.

kd

Thanks chuckerfly and bunkfree! I looked up pictures and E pulidonis seems close and it showed similar plants; I stumbled across Aeonium haworthii that looks spot-on to my plant! Echeveria are listed as non-toxic to cats but I can't find any definite information on the Aeonium Haworthii.

I think it's an Echeveria not aeonium. I don't have aeonium, but from what I've seen they have little teeth along their leaf margins, whereas Echeveria do not.

It wants more light as well, see how the middle is light coloured and the leaves around it are pressing out flat? They're trying to get as much light as possible. If you have a nice sunny windowsill, I'd move it there. You'll see it reaching for light, so turn it often to keep it from growing all conked to one side.

kd

Thanks for the info! I'll move it to a sunnier spot (now that I know it won't hurt the kitties) and see how it does! Thanks everyone!