Our comparison points were Brookhaven, Omega open access and Dura-Supreme because we wanted a modern slab front look. We liked the designer who sold Brookhaven/Wood-mode and Dura-Supreme. All 3 priced out about the same but our designer warned us that upgraded finishes and customization vary by design and are unpredictable until priced out.

We chose the Brookhaven over the Dura-Supreme because of available finish choices. We have a modern slab front style with a glossy lacquer paint. Our designer told us that sometimes Brookhaven prices out a little higher than Dura-Supreme and sometimes Dura-Supreme prices out a little higher than Brookhaven. Hope this helps.

Maybe Rutt's Regency line?

Is the door style/finish known ? SO many variables in this process...that's why pricing really varies. Those who have or have not done many detailed features with their cabinets can chime in once you indicate where you are at with style choices. If you are doing a basic stained shaker door in cherry for instance I'd look at Shiloh or Showplace. Do you want a painted raised panel traditional kitchen with details like corbels/fluted fillers/etc..then I'd go with Woodharbour.....If you want a lot of cost savings and the kitchen is smallish /basic I'd do Ikea.

Stan Z, how did that pricing compare to other lines you looked at?

I am trying to figure out if I should be
comparing costs of mid-grade or higher end cabinetry with Brookhaven. I am not
far enough along to choose all the details but do know I like limited details on the cabinetry and will probably go with a stain-that-looks-like-paint (technical jargon :) or painted finish. I am not into lots of corbels, etc.

Since I have limited time before I need to make a decision, I am trying to compare where Brookhaven will fall price-wise. I need to get quotes from a few kitchen designers but don't want to chose KDs who only carry lines that will not fit into my established budget. I know I will get what I pay for and am confident that Brookhaven is a quality line, but there are quality lines that are reasonable and those that are way out of my budget.

Since whether or not something is considered expensive or reasonable is subjective, I am just trying to figure out what other brands will provide the same quality and look at around the same price so I can find KDs who carry those lines and not waste the time of others.

herbflavor, Ikea is not an option. Our current kitchen is about 145' sq but we may be expanding up to almost 200' sq.

We priced Brookhaven, Dura Supreme and a local cabinet guy. Brookhaven and Dura Supreme priced out about the same for our door/finish. Local guy about 2k cheaper but we could not get the right finish. We went with Brookhaven and I am still in love with our cabinets:)

I was up against a Wood-Mode kitchen once and apples to apples, they were 25% more than my Plain & Fancy. It could have been the dealer markup or error. I would also guess that Showplace would be in the Brookhaven price range. And possibly Mouser, Holiday and Decora.

folks beware. If you want a white kitchen and order white cabinets, the bottoms come out brown wood and can look pretty awful in an open concept kitchen

The bottoms of what? The upper cabinets? It depends on the brand.

upper brookhaven

katie66 , what did you end up using?