What are the pros and cons of solatube vs velux solar tubes ...
Joann Yurchesyn
11 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (234)
Thomas Hosie
4 years agolisianthus
4 years agoRelated Discussions
Need current advice on Solatubes
Comments (7)Recently bought a ranch house in Atlanta that received very little natural light in the bedroom and living room because of wide roof overhangs around the whole exterior of the home. I did a ton of searching, trying to find how to filter more natural light into my home. I find out through looking and looking on the net that these things called sun tunnels (similar to skylights) might be just what I need to get more natural light. Now that I know that they exist, my goal now is to find out what they do and how they work. Fast forward, there are several did decent brand names. The 2 most popular ones are Solatubes and Velux sun tunnels. They come in several different sizes 10", 14", 22". Most homes will use either the 10" or 14". Some of the other less popular brands will come in other sizes like 13", 24". They range in price from under $200 to about $500. They can be installed by a DIY'er or a professional. Professional installers charge for the total install including product and installation from around $600 to $1300 for one 10" or 14". I got about 4 different written quotes. One company came out but never ever got back in touch. The Solatubes and Velux have 10 year warranties, I was fortunate enough to see these installed in customers homes already and was able to talk at length with happy customers who has had these in there homes for as many as ten years with absolutely no problems. Some had the Solatubes and some had the Velux. Some had one installed and others had as many as 6 and again everyone was happy. One company offered the very best deal by lowering the price with a greatest discount if you buy more than one. One company online right now has a buy one you get a discount buy two you get a greater discount buy 3 and the discount is massive. I'm just sorry they weren't in my state. I ended up getting 3 14" Solatubes installed by a certified installer, his price was reasonable, his service was great and he arrived just when he said he would. He was efficient and he knew exactly what he was doing. He worked alone and it took him about 5 hours to do 2 on a ranch. And it took him about 2 hours to do another on a 2 story home in the same neighborhood. Also, there's a 30% tax credit available depending upon how you file your taxes. I'm extremely satisfied with the installs and the amount of light is absolutely phenomenal. It has taken my dull and dark rooms to rooms that are now so bright that we need sunglasses (lol). I had strangers open up there homes to allow me to physically see what they look like, through the company referral. I am so grateful to them for that. If I could I would have an open house just to have people see exactly what they look like in a home. If more info is needed just ask A very happy homeowner south of the airport in Atlanta...See MoreSun Tunnel / Solatube vs Skylight
Comments (15)gregoryandkristin both good and bad. Most people think of placement when they're worried that they'll get too much sun in the afternoon, but there are other factors to consider too. The good skylight is installed on a west sloping part of the roof that gets bright sun. It looks great and we love it (it has blinds that we use occasionally, we sprang for the remote control kind, which was worth it). The two bad skylights were installed on a part of the roof where they're in full shade most of the day. (Our house is a split level, so the shade comes from the upper story.) As a result, the light coming in is weak and weird, kind of like having a really dim fluorescent light. It's a bit better in the summer when the angle of the sun is different, but unfortunately I wanted these skylights to help make the rooms brighter in the winter. It was an extremely disappointing and expensive mistake. If I had known better, I could have mitigated it by choosing a larger size skylight and having them installed off-center in the room. That would have put them more out of the shade, but also the light would have bounced down one wall. Reflecting off the wall would have subtly amplified the light into the room, if that makes sense. So, when you plan skylights, size and placement is extremely important. If you're in doubt, get a a lighting architect who can study the sun patterns and do virtual modeling for you....See MoreSolar tube for interior bathroom
Comments (13)We first installed a solatub in the late 1980s in a bathroom in my previous home. In the 15 years that we lived with it we never had to do any maintainance to the solatube in side or out on the roof. It never leaked. We loved how much it lit up the room. We didn't need to turn on lights in the bathroom during the day like we did before installing it. When my daughter bought her house 8 years ago, we had a solatube installed in their windowless hall bathroom as a house warming gift. They love it. It even lets some light into their hallway. Their solatube has not leaked or required any maintainance at all. Last year the added a large solatube in their dark family room and also put one in another bathroom that lost its window due to an addition on the house. Solatubes are definitely less expensive than a skylight for both the product itself and the install. I know that because we replaced 27 year old skylights in our current home when we reroofed 2 years ago. They never leaked but we replaced them just due to their age. The skylights were way more expensive than the solatubes my daughter just installed. I suggest you go with the Solatube brand or the Velux brand rather than some lesser brand....See Moresolar tubes lighting
Comments (17)Oh, I miss my solatubes in my old house. They were added to a 1960 split level to bring light to an windowless bath, the upstairs landing (it was a large space, almost a room), and the stairwell, which also brought more light to the entryway. No problems with the retro-installation, no leaks. You can now, I hear, get different filters for different kinds of light. You can also get baffles to control the light. The two solatubes in the hall had integrated lights, at that time we used incandescent so I'm sure any bulb now would work. In the bath, we added the integrated fan. We had lights over the vanity so didn't need an additional light for nighttime. Funny story: a guest finished up in the bathroom once and asked me how to turn off the overhead light! The caveat is, that if you get snow, the light is different went it's covered with snow. But light still comes in! Here's the main thing I liked: before, we kept the upstairs light on much of the day, and in winter definitely needed it on by 3pm, in summer by 6pm. After, we didn't definitely need to turn on the light till 5 in winter, and 9 in summer....See MoreHU-38602259
4 years agoWilliam Roy Designer Kitchens
4 years agoWilliam Roy Designer Kitchens
4 years agojulieste
4 years agolisianthus
4 years agolast modified: 4 years agojulieste
4 years agoSide3
4 years agoAngela
3 years agoAngela
3 years agoAngela
3 years agoAngela
3 years agoSOLARGY SW
3 years agolast modified: 3 years agoSOLA - LITE
3 years agoSzalma Virág
3 years agoVivian Buentiempo-Johnson
3 years agoHU-524860945
3 years agoSOLA - LITE
3 years agohummingbirdgardener
3 years agoheidifielding
3 years agoAlex511
3 years agolast modified: 3 years agoSola-lite
3 years agolast modified: 3 years agoSola-lite
3 years agoSola-lite
3 years agoAlex511
3 years agoRayM
3 years agojujuz20
3 years agolast modified: 3 years agoAlex511
3 years agolast modified: 3 years agoSola-lite
3 years agoAlex511
3 years agolast modified: 3 years agoJenn Leiker
3 years agoSOLARGY SW
3 years agoSOLARGY SW
3 years agoSola-lite
3 years agoTina Chin
3 years agolisianthus
3 years agochery_m
3 years agoSkip Kizzire
3 years agoSola-lite
3 years agolast modified: 3 years agoHU-687364716
2 years agoSOLA - LITE
2 years agolast modified: 2 years agoCheryl Andrade
2 years agolisianthus
2 years agomollymcbaby
2 years agoSola-lite
2 years agoChrissy Morrissey
last yearVivian Buentiempo-Johnson
last yearKami A.
last yearVivian Buentiempo-Johnson
last year
Related Stories
LIGHTINGShining a Light on Solar Tubes
These eco-conscious skylights are gaining in popularity for all the right reasons
Full StoryGREEN BUILDINGGoing Solar at Home: Solar Panel Basics
Save money on electricity and reduce your carbon footprint by installing photovoltaic panels. This guide will help you get started
Full StoryGREAT HOME PROJECTSHow to Add a Skylight or Light Tube
New project for a new year: Increase daylight and maybe even your home’s energy efficiency by opening a room to the sky
Full StoryMATERIALSInsulation Basics: What to Know About Spray Foam
Learn what exactly spray foam is, the pros and cons of using it and why you shouldn’t mess around with installation
Full StoryTHE HARDWORKING HOMEWhere to Put the Laundry Room
The Hardworking Home: We weigh the pros and cons of washing your clothes in the basement, kitchen, bathroom and more
Full StoryGARDENING AND LANDSCAPINGChoosing a Deck: Plastic or Wood?
Get the pros and cons of wood, plastic, composite and more decking materials, plus a basic price comparison
Full StoryREMODELING GUIDESThe Hidden Problems in Old Houses
Before snatching up an old home, get to know what you’re in for by understanding the potential horrors that lurk below the surface
Full StoryLATEST NEWS FOR PROFESSIONALSHighlights From the 2019 Greenbuild Expo
Not able to make the convention for green-building professionals? Here are a few things you missed
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNBefore and After: 6 Kitchen Makeovers in 200 Square Feet or Less
See how pros used new layouts and finishes to make these kitchens work better for homeowners
Full StoryREMODELING GUIDESTubular Daylighting Devices Bring In Natural Light
More advanced and less pricey than traditional skylights, TDDs are the most modern way to let the light in
Full Story
Skylight Options LLC