Okay, I have to say, you guys are AWESOME! @remodelfla - looks like that eBay seller is the same as the Amazon seller -Oracle, and the same price. Will have to check on whether shipping makes the difference. Just got notice that the sample has shipped so hope to get it this week. Trikeenan is out and Sea Turtles are in - love the glass but had to decide quickly and the turtles spoke to me (the Honu is sort of our family emblem). @fouramblues - that is the post I was looking for, and you got the name of the tile, too - Yay! (somehow "Bell" turned into "Beth" in my mind overnight - no wonder I couldn't find it). I think my flooring is American Olean so that was interesting....will research that tile when I get back on the desktop - search limited on iPad here. And I'm not sure what makes it "rustic" - mostly interested in low color variation (the "camel" looks like far too much) and the tile sizing/pattern - random, and more honed, smooth. But not polished/glossy. And not pitted. Interesting, but not to overpower the turtles. And I should mention, the backsplash on the other side of the kitchen is just under 3" tall and abut 20' long, so we don't want to cut a zillion tiles to fit, so multi-width will certainly make that easier. I was just at Home Depot buying dripper irrigation supplies and saw an interesting one called Bamboo something that I had seen online a few places in my search - it's all 1/4" strips and $15sf, but I get a military discount there and it's in stock. Thank you for all the help! Open to more ideas!

UPDATE: (It's not Ann Sacks, but that tile is similarly pretty!). I was able to track this tile downright before our renovation started! A tile dealer in New York had a customer return 5 square feet, and he shipped me the 2 square feet I needed just in time. I love love love it! I will post pictures of the full renovation (we did 2 bathrooms!) in another thread. Thanks for trying to help me track it down! Lisa B.

It's Jeffery Court Tile. http://www.jeffreycourt.com/ I don't know which one, but he has a large internet presence so you might be able to ask .

It's very hard to find matches to something like that. Your best option might be to try all the surplus stores in your area that carry discontinued tile. I was able to find a tile match that way for a family member that had a house built using tile that was a widely-popular, standard-grade tile in the area at the time the home was built, but it's tough to find. You might consider replacing the entire flooring to get one match throughout the entire house if you can. That's such a positive thing you can do for your whole-house decor if or when it might fit into the budget.