Need help fixing light switch wiring across two rooms.

7 years ago

A few months ago my dad attempted to replace some light switch plates in our downstairs bathroom and garage, and in the process killed the lights to the garage. What we have is a double switch in the bathroom which controls the two lights in there, and another double switch in the back of the garage. There is one double switch that was left alone which controls both the mudroom light and the garage lights. After he replaced the bathroom switch the lights in the garage will only turn on if the lights in the bathroom are turned on.
The switch in the back of the garage is supposed to control the garage lights and the back porch lights. I had limited equipment but I was able to attach a single switch to the back panel which allowed the garage lights to turn on but at the expense of the back porch light, which turns on when the switch is turned off. I know we need to get a double switch for the back door but my main concern is the fact that the switches for the garage lights (both the one in the mudroom and the one in the back of the garage) only function if the bathroom light is on. There is a new double switch in the bathroom but I am not sure if it is the type of switch or the way it's being wired that is causing this issue.

To recap:

Bathroom (double switch, controls bathroom lights, was replaced, is required to be flipped on for either garage light switch to work)

Mudroom (double switch, controls mudroom lights and garage lights, untouched)

Garage (double switch, controls garage lights and back porch lights, currently has a single switch which alternately turns on garage and back porch lights depending on which direction it's flipped in).

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (9)

greg_2015
7 years ago
A double switch like one of these?

My guess is that the power used to come into the black screw, pass through the tab on the right without going to the switch and exit on the other black screw to continue on to the garage or mudroom or whatever.

The power would also pass through the switch to the lights.

Now, you might have the two sides mixed up so that the power to the garage/mudroom has to pass through the switch.

Do both lights in the bathroom come on when you switch on either switch?

Regardless, the first step is to identify which wire is the incoming power. Which wires go to the lights and which wire continues on to the garage.
Toph Hughes
Original Author
7 years ago
Yes, the double switches look pretty much the same as that image.

No the lights in the bathroom are working fine, both operate each bathroom light fine, but only the switch on the right side affects the power to the garage. When that one goes out, the juice doesn't continue on to the garage.
Related Discussions
Timer Switch with two load wires?
Q
Comments (17)
klem's response was unwarranted. There's nothing wrong with asking questions. Bus_driver's initial response was because usually when someone comes on here asking about something that their 'handyman' couldn't figure out, it's because the handyman is clueless and unqualified and the homeowner is usually not really interested in DIY which is why they hired the handyman in the first place. So hiring an electrician is usually the end result. Your handyman is clueless and unqualified. You never just hold connections together to 'test it out'. Twisting a wirenut onto the connection literally takes 5 seconds. And the fact that he even wanted to test it before finishing the installation is worrisome. That's basically him admitting that he doesn't know what he's doing. Electrical connections need to be tight in order to work properly. Electricity is not something that someone should just 'play' with. You need to know what you are doing before you do it. So, rest assured, your timers are probably fine for the job. Just call up an electrician and get him to install them.
...See More
lighting fixture wiring issues; *patient* help needed
Q
Comments (3)
Fairly easy fix after you do some investigating. 1. check the switch, one black wire and one white wire (white should be painted black but probably isn't), 2. at the junction box hang the wires loose and turn the power on, with a tester see which black wire is hot. Turn the power off and that black will be connected to the white in the OTHER cable, paint the white black. 3 All remaining whites go together, all remaining blacks go together, all grounds together. turn power on. If any of these conditions do not apply, stop and ask for more directions.
...See More
Converting Switched Plug to New Ceiling Lights - Wiring Help Need
Q
Comments (5)
The feed to a switch loop used to be given special dispensation in the code from having to be remarked. In the current code you are (and you should in your work) remark it. As you've shown it (assuming you are using the same devices), your circuit will not work. The switched half of the outlet has no power feeding it ever and neither does the switch and the resultant lights. If you don't want to retained the outlet as switched, you can feed the switch (and the downstream lights) with the hot in the receptacle box (you'll need to replace the receptacle or jumper the "split" connection on it).
...See More
Smart Light Switches (Help My Electrician Forgot Wires)
Q
Comments (3)
Thank you so much for the comments! Yes, I researched the lutron Caseta Wireless and it is fantastic! Steve I understand where you are coming from, but in my situation where I wasn't around much for our build (I have a demanding seasonal job in Nebraska) i wasn't able to specify some things. Although, as my wife put it, a lot of it seemed to be common sense (like only having one location to turn on our great room lights and its in a corner, along with two other situations that are similar. In this situation, the areas where wire would need to be run would require ruining a lot of freshly painted drywall. The lutron caseta doesn't require a smart hub it can work stand alone with the provided pico remote, but if you want bells and whistles and want to control it with the lutron smart app or apple home kit (yes i tell siri to dim the lights for me) than you can with the purchase of lutrons smart bridge for 79.99 more. The in wall dimmer switch with remote is $60, smart bridge $80, or bundles together for $100. https://www.amazon.com/Lutron-Wireless-Lighting-Starter-P-BDG-PKG2W/dp/B01M3XJUAD/ref=sr_1_3?s=hi&ie=UTF8&qid=1516080745&sr=1-3&keywords=lutron+smart+bridge
...See More
greg_2015
7 years ago
Just in case my word description was too confusing. This is the path that the continuous power should be taking:

And this is my guess at the path that the (wannabe) continuous power is currently taking:
greg_2015
7 years ago
So as I said, the first step is identifying the wires.

Remove the switch altogether. Turn the power back on (obviously make sure none of the wires are touching anything). Use a tester to see which wire is live. That's your source.

Turn the power off. Connect the source to one of the other wires with a wire nut. Turn the power back on. What came on?

Do the same thing until you identify everything.
Toph Hughes
Original Author
7 years ago
Thanks so much for the help. I will try that and get back to you if it doesn't work.
Vith
7 years ago
So your dad did it wrong and didnt even test to make sure all was well? Geez... makin us handymen look bad here.
Toph Hughes
Original Author
7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago

this is what the switch I'm trying to fix looks like.
greg_2015
7 years ago
So it isn't a double switch. It's two switches.

Have you tried identifying the source and destination wires like I mentioned?

It's a bad picture so I can't really make it out. Can you draw a diagram of how it's hooked up?
Vith
7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago
Well, he double tapped one of the switches, so the other switch depends on that. Need to unhook them and find which black is the live hot. Then wirenut two spare wires to the source and take those to each switch separately to provide constant power to each switch.

I suggest cutting power to the circuit, unhooking the blacks and have them not touching anything or each other and turn on power again and testing with a klein voltage tester to find the hot. This is normally how I do it. Just ensure no one else is going to be in the area or able to touch the wires while you are diagnosing. Cant use a cheap tester, they go bad and give false positives and are also too sensitive to differentiate which wire is hot when they work as intended (they start beeping just getting near the box).

Need help fixing light switch wiring across two rooms.

Comments (9)

greg_2015

Toph Hughes
Original Author

Related Discussions

greg_2015

greg_2015

Toph Hughes
Original Author

Vith

Toph Hughes
Original Author

greg_2015

Vith

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Need help fixing light switch wiring across two rooms.

Comments (9)

greg_2015

Toph HughesOriginal Author

Related Discussions

greg_2015

greg_2015

Toph HughesOriginal Author

Vith

Toph HughesOriginal Author

greg_2015

Vith

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Toph Hughes
Original Author

Toph Hughes
Original Author

Toph Hughes
Original Author