I love this:

https://www.benefitcosmetics.com/us/en/product/watts-cream-highlighter

I like this Bobbi Brown concealer with a serum. It's expensive but a little goes a long way and it lasts a long time. I apply with a concealer brush. It really looks good and doesn't make your under eye area feel dry.

Physicians Formula Concealer (in tube like lipstick) is what I have used for 20+ years. It is very light, but covers well while looking natural..

I have never used much makeup and have never worn any concealer so I am of no help to you :)

Sue

AR girl, I'll be interested in seeing the responses you receive. I had to stop using my usual products in recent months due to that thin, crepey skin under my eyes.

I've resorted to simply using my favorite BB cream, which I use as a foundation. I can't wear mascara on my lower lashes because it will smudge with the BB cream, but seems to work until I find something that fulfills this need.

I've noticed that even those products that advertise that they are great for crepey skin.....aren't.

I keep going back to Lancôme--I had looked for something different when I ran out the last time but ended up back with Lancôme. Estee Lauders gets good reviews too on theirs. Haven't tired it though.

I just wanted to add...not sure of your age but at almost 50 and with the fine lines you are still going to see the lines but I did find a lot of the eye concealers settled in the lines and that is what I was looking to avoid. Also depending on how much and how you apply the concealer will affect your results.

I've had dark circles under my eyes since I was a little girl and have never found anything that really conceals them, so I will be watching this thread with interest.

I agree with the above. As one ages, using any sort of foundation or concealer is very problematic as it gets caught in the creases and lines. Embrace your lines and wrinkles! They show you have LIVED!

I haven't found anything that looks good, looks natural under my eyes, and use just a little Perricone No Foundation on a sponge for my ever present dark circles. I always look a little puffy there too, most concealers just emphasize that but its the result of having proptosis when my thyroid was tearing along at a high rate of speed. My eyes moved forward, then improved, but never did quite look the same again.

I do have concealer, Lancôme Effacernes, but I use it on my lids as a base, not under my eyes. Powdered shadow, pressed powder liner, stay put all day.

The online cosmetic line I now use says women over 50 should not use any powder based products because they emphasize lines and crepiness. Only use cream based products, no foundation or eyeshadow...particularly in powder form.

I use Keromask Camouflage Cream.

Keromask is an ultra-pigmented, highly concentrated, full coverage concealer developed by dermatologists and loved by Hollywood’s top makeup artists.

This easy to use formula is available in 25 shades, ensuring a perfect color match for all skin tones, including African-American, Hispanic, and Asian complexions.

You can buy it on Amazon.

Keromask Camouflage Cream

I don't use a concealer, but a great tightener/toner/brightener for tired puffy eyes is a cool wet (ie used) teabag! Only takes a few seconds and the improvement is dramatic - and costs nothing assuming you drink the tea. :-)

I'm with Dawn. Horrible dark circles under my eyes. I have never worn makeup.

When I was looking for a job, I went to one of those cosmetic counters where they do a "makeover" on you. That girl spent 30 or 40 minutes (and about 400 dollars worth of products on my face) and I looked worse when she got done than when I walked in the door. I felt bad I didn't buy anything, I'll just live with my circles.

Dawn....I've had dark circles since I was a kid and have used concealer since I was a teen in the 60's. Right now I'm using Bobbi Brown and I like it. I am intrigued now by Lancome and Keromask.

Lucy.....how do you know which shade of Keromask to buy from the internet?

Apply a small amount, let it dry a little, then blend w/ makeup sponge.

joaniepoanie, there is a chart here: http://keromaskmaskingcream.com/index.php/color-chart/

You can purchase samples here for $3.99:

https://beautycafe.com/collections/keromask-camouflage-cream

Thanks Lucy!

I apply a lotion, like Dermasil, then a product called BB/Beauty Benefit Creme, Medium. I buy both @ Dollar Tree...yep...$1!

Lately I've been applying coconut oil (the organic kind used for cooking) at night, and my eyes look better in the AM. For day, I apply Neutrogena sunscreen and then L'oreal visible lift blur foundation. It's kind of thin but better than nothing and not caky. I'm always trying something new, but glad I discovered the coconut oil. It soaks right in and seems to prevent puffy eyes too.