What to do if positive for HVX?
7 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (17)
- 7 years ago
- 7 years ago
Related Discussions
False Positive HVX Hostas - Hosta 'Filagree'
Comments (6)I know this is "normal" for this hosta, but it it butt ugly, IMHO. I think Praying Hands, and Outhouse Delight are in the same category. That is my OPINION, so don't get on my case...just express your own thoughts, which have equal value here (but not in MY mind!!!). ;-) -Babka...See MoreI know all the talk is HVX but what about nematodes?
Comments (7)Hahaha, Alexa!! I know, I'm the expert 'nema-phobe' on here, but I'm not the 'expert' at treating them. What 'omoelegba' just posted sounds like a good alternative to just tossing the offending plant--or nema-victim!! Pietre, also has had some very good success of his own. I hope he'll come on and give his advice on the subject! I'm so sorry, 'omoelegba' that you had the misfortune to buy from that person, as well!!! I wish there were a way to go back on ebay, even a year after a purchase and give a fair 'critique' of what you've been sold!!! There's no way to prevent hosta-folk from falling victim to this woman, who KNOWS what she is doing by selling her hosta. Right now--or as of a few days ago, she is trying to sell a HUGE division of hosta for $80!! Just imagine what she's passing on to the poor soul who thinks they are getting a great deal!!! FUME!!! I just hate 'deception' and 'dishonesty' and making a buck in such devious ways!! Good grief!!! I will say, I did the hot-bath treatment, as commonly prescribed, to a hosta I purchased that turned up infested, and while it looked like 'carp' that season, it did put out new growth the following year, but I decided it just wasn't worth the risk and tossed it! I should have kept it as a measure of success but it was a 'Blue Cadet' and I figured I could easily get my hands on another someday!! It was 'one of those days' when I was in a reckless mood--I can't bring myself to get rid of the most common hosta--I plant them in remote areas of my yard and let them fend for themselves--live or die on their own--but at least it's not 'hosta-homicide' as was the case with that poor 'cadet'!! Good luck, kristi--I KNOW how you're feeling!!!! Slump!!...See MoreHVX - what do newbies need to know about purchasing locally?
Comments (7)I like getting my hostas from a nursery that specializes in them. I've found that they tend to at least be more knowledgeable than growers that don't. I tend to like to talk to nursery owners.....and "somehow" it always comes up in conversation. Recently I was at 2 different places and the answers were completely different. The hosta grower was very upfront when the topic came up and told us how they look for signs throughout the growing season and use the bleach solution on their tools, etc. etc. The other grower kind of knew about it and told us they use the bleach solution on their tools but didn't want to dwell on the subject. HVX happens and when you go to a grower that exclusively sells hostas you do run a bit of a risk because that's all they grow but you also deal with people that are fully aware of what to do. BTW, I would not buy anything twice from a grower with out a guarantee....They may not have anything posted, but most people will take a dead or diseased plant back within a reasonable time. If they don't, I can't justify spending that kind of money with them.......See MoreDo I Use RoundUp First on the HVX's?
Comments (34)Babka, So far my opinion is backed up with science. I don't expect anyone to bow down to me. I do expect they will respect my opinions and if they disagree they will present facts rather than their unsubstantiated and easily disproved beliefs. I don't even expect them to believe me. I do however expect that if they offer a different opinion they should study the facts. Here are the facts. 1. HVX only exists in live tissue. 2. Glyphosates will kill hostas and all tissue to the root as far as any person alive can tell. 3. Digging up a live infected hosta in proximity to uninfected hostas is dangerous and can easily spread the disease. 4. Digging up a living infected hosta can easily leave remnants of the roots that can infect any other hosta planted in the same area for a very long time. 5. No study has found HVX to have the ability to go dormant. In fact, just the opposite has been found to be true. 6. There is no downside to killing a hosta infected with HVX. These are the facts that I have verified and keep repeating. Chris' response to these facts- "I don't think spraying with Roundup is necessary or any more effective than simply digging out the plant without spraying." Cher's response is that I can't prove glyphosate kills hostas and she doesn't think it does because her mother can't kill poison ivy with it. Paul accuses me of not being respectful because I disagree and quotes a study on Tomato Mosaic Virus proposing it is relevent to HVX virus when it is not. ...and you say that I expect everyone to bow down to me and suggest there is some other way of interpreting the facts...but you somehow never explain this way of interpreting facts differently. When others come back and say they don't "believe" that it makes any difference wether you kill the tissue before digging up a plant after hearing what I have to say several times, and offering no explanation as to why they don't "bleive" it makes any difference then you will have to excuse me if I repeat my reasoning to them. I would point out that I have never treated anyone with anything but respect. I have simply stated the facts and defended my position. If people think it disrespectful to defend a position with scientific facts then that is their problem. If you say this is because I must be young; this would be just one more point where you are wrong. Jon...See More- 7 years ago
- 7 years agolast modified: 7 years ago
- 7 years ago
- 7 years ago
- 7 years ago
- 7 years ago
- 7 years ago
- 7 years ago
- 7 years ago
- 7 years ago
- 7 years ago
- 7 years agolast modified: 7 years ago
- 7 years ago
- 7 years ago
ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5