Spa pool vs. Small pool
mrspete
8 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (12)
cpartist
8 years agoRelated Discussions
Small Pool With Spa or Larger Pool With No Spa
Comments (8)I would think that a bigger pool would be better. We do use our spa quite often in the winter months, but we use the big pool almost every day once it's warm enough to wade in. If you miss having a spa later, you can always buy a hot tub (and close it in the summer months like my neighbor). Since the heating is going to be a problem, that might be the best way to go anyway. We were lucky that we had gas to our house, oddly, just to the water heater in the garage (I suppose electric ranges were all the rage in 1970), which we extended into the house when we remodeled the kitchen and laundry room for a gas range and dryer, and now along the side of the house to the spa heater. We have Artistic Pavers Shellock, which are pretty cool in the hot sun (compared to regular pavers) and expensive, but we end up using flip flops almost all the time anyway. We don't want to track grass or dirt into the pool and we need them for the shell under our tiki hut, so the deck isn't as important as I thought it would be. We also got a removable hand-rail offset at the main steps that we thought would be for when in-laws visit, but we ended up never taking it out. We use it for hanging towels that we grab as we step out into our flip flops. The fact that it's off-set instead of smack in the middle of the steps is really great. Anyway, biggest thing to think about is how YOU really expect to use the pool. If you are building it for your own young kids - remember they grow up fast you will be stuck with a pool you won't use for yourself once they're out of the house, so if YOU want a spa, get the spa. I was warned off of building a pool by lots and lots of people who had them for their kids - but our pool was really for me, and now my hubby uses it more than I do! The teens and their friends are just a temporary bonus. And the salt system is so easy to maintain, a happy surprise....See MoreFeedback wanted on pool and spa specs
Comments (7)Sorry -- I had not checked this threat in a long time. Posting an update for folks. We have loved our pool configuration and the choices we made nine years ago. Heating the spa does require a few hours pre-planning. We ran underground lines for gas in case we wanted to switch to gas instead of heat pump, but the heat pump has worked well enough that we've never switched to gas. Depending on the weather here in the midwest, we will start the spa heating 2-5 hours prior to when we need it to make sure it is comfortable when we get in. We tend to stop using the spa once it gets below 50 degrees out (air is too chilly for us!) If you want quicker heating for your spa, you will need gas. The heat pump has worked for us since we are planners. Most of our pool components have continued to operate well even after nine years. We did go with Pentair lights and at this time (9 years later) only one LED color is not working in one of the lights but otherwise all is good there. A few Jandy valves have needed replacement due to minor seepage (but it has been 9 years!) Also, the spa-side remote from Pentair (maybe called the Spa Command?) has been junk -- we replaced it twice in our first three years and finally gave up and moved to controlling everything via Pentair's wireless phone app which has worked well. The River Flow swim current has continued to work well for us. It has gotten a lot of use this year with the pandemic shutdown. We were very pleased this year to have our own swim current to exercise in! We probably used it more this year than all 8 prior years combined. It does require some work each year to winterize properly (using very large marine plugs). We do that in the early fall before the pool water gets cooler. Overall it has been a fun splurge that is used more to create fun in the pool (currents for floats, etc.) and occasionally for exercise until this year when it got heavy use for safe exercise in our own back yard. Our pool cover also is still doing well. We went with a mesh cover (believe it was Merlin) that had attachments in the ground over and past the raised bond beam wall as well as into our travertine decking. They also designed in reinforcement rubber in spots where needed. We have cushions that are placed at rub points. The cover seems to be doing very well. It is typically used November - March and stored inside when the pool is open. Snow weight has not been a problem due to the mesh design and the milder winters we now get in the midwest. The travertine pool decking has held up very well. We have some minor spalling on a few tiles (winter freeze/thaw), but not enough to cause any worries after 9 years. The travertine has been an amazing pool deck surface. It stays cool in the summer and also does not seem to get slippery when wet. It has continued to look very nice. We occasionally have had a few weeds growing between some tiles occasionally over the years, but it has been minor (maybe because I pull them promptly if I see them!) Overall our pool has been very nice and I very much appreciate all of the helpful feedback I got many years ago when we were building it. Hopefully this information helps the people currently with pool projects "in the works". We are getting close to ten years now with our pool!...See MoreBuilt in small pool & spa
Comments (0)We are thinking about putting in a small pool & spa. Don't have a lot of room, but I really miss having a pool just to float & relax. Keeping it around 4-5ft depth. Do you have a built in small pool? Is it used or a waste of space & money. We live in Southern California about a mile from the beach. Our last pool was full size & I used it often. Opinions please...See MoreDeciding to install pool/spa. Advice please!
Comments (33)We have our second house in the Palm Springs area (Cathedral City) and would not have bought any house that did not have a pool. Our pool is about 12' wide (irregular shape) and 30' long. One end is quite deep, and the shallow end is about chest deep. The spa is 7'x7' and is large enough for the two of us, but we've had four in it comfortably. We also have an above ground hot tub in Los Angeles, about 2-1/2 miles from the beach, and it is probably 6'x6' - I'm not there right now, and so I'm not exactly sure. Anyway, it is supposed to accommodate four to six people, but they would have to be children. For us, three is the limit. Right now our pool is 86° without using the heater, and it takes about 15 minutes to heat the spa to 102°. In the winter it takes a bit longer, but since I heat the pool to 85° in the winter anyway, the spa heats up quickly. It does take about a day to heat the pool in the dead of winter (December) - otherwise the water would be about 55°, I think. I have not noticed an excessive gas bill when we do heat it, however. We have a pool maintenance company that comes twice a week and charges $175 a month. We need this because we are not here all the time. If we lived here full time, it might be different. I think it would be difficult to sell a house in Palm Springs without a pool, and most of them seem to have one. We were willing to consider a house without a pool but room for a large pool, but it would have had to be $100k less than what we would pay for a house already with a pool. I don't need the pool to be refreshing - I prefer warm relaxing water, even when it is 110° outside....See Morejust_janni
8 years agoILoveRed
8 years agobznbaker
8 years agoRon Natalie
8 years agoILoveRed
8 years agomrspete
8 years agocpartist
8 years agojust_janni
8 years agoRon Natalie
8 years agolast modified: 8 years agocountingblessings
2 years ago
Related Stories
DREAM SPACESStep Inside a Luxurious Pool House and Spa
This Montana pool house takes inspiration from Japanese design and the beauty of its surroundings
Full StoryPOOLSWe Can Dream: 7 Things to Consider Before Investing in an Outdoor Spa
Check out these tips and tricks for adding a luxurious outdoor spa to your landscape
Full StoryGARDENING AND LANDSCAPING19 Spectacular Pools Near and Far
These incredible infinity pools, heavenly oceanside pools and luxurious lap pools around the world have unmatched allure. Take a dip
Full StoryGARDENING AND LANDSCAPING13 New Ways to Make a Splash With a Hot Tub
Check out the modern options and custom features that are making outdoor spa tubs hot again
Full StoryGREAT HOME PROJECTSHow to Replaster (or Remodel) Your Pool
Have an old pool? It could be time to update the plaster, landscaping and more for a pool that works swimmingly with your current style
Full StoryGARDENING AND LANDSCAPING5 Modern Pavilions and Pool Houses
With glass walls and a streamlined sensibility that direct focus toward the view, minimalism can be a natural fit for outdoor structures
Full StoryGARDENING AND LANDSCAPING8 Tips for Pool House Perfection
Set your pool house up in style so that you and your guests can focus on the most important thing: relaxing
Full StoryPOOLS8 Ideas for Petite Pools
Modest in size but big on looks and function, pools like these offer a private swim space without requiring lots of room
Full StoryHEALTHY HOMEThese Steps Will Help Keep Kids Safe Around Pools and Spas
Implement several layers of security to prevent life-threatening accidents in and around the pool
Full StoryROOM OF THE DAYRoom of the Day: Modern Pool House Nestled in Downtown Philadelphia
Homeowners redo an atrium with a pool to be a more pleasing and practical space
Full Story
bry911